TABLE 4

Summary of Studies Included in the Network Meta-analysis Reporting Baseline and EOT Child Disruptive Behavior Outcome Measured by CBCL Externalizing T-Score

Citation Risk of Bias (N Randomized)Group: Intervention (N Analyzed)CBCL T-Score at Baseline, Mean (SD)CBCL T-Score at EOT, Mean (SD)
Butler et al 201166G1: MST (53)G1: 67.7 (8.4)G1: 63.4 (10.2)
 Low (108)G2: TAU (51)G2: 66.4 (9.8)G2: 63.7 (9.9)
McCabe et al 200972G1: PCIT, culturally adapted (21)G1: 66.95 (8.95)G1: 45.83 (11.28)
 Low (58)G2: PCIT, standard (19)G2: 67.21 (11.99)G2: 48.82 (13.31)
G3: TAU (18)G3: 69.22 (12.27)G3: 58.73 (11.62)
Cummings et al 200880G1: SET-PC (16)G1: 65 (4.64)G1: 57.53 (6.85)
 High (54)G2: IYPP (16)G2: 69.89 (7.77)G2: 59.78 (10.72)
van de Wiel et al 200783G1: Coping power program (38)G1: 74.6 (6.4)G1: 69.6 (8.4)
 Moderate (77)G2a: Family therapy (10)G2a: 77.1 (6.4)G2a: 72.6 (7.9)
G2b: Behavior therapy (16)G2b: 73.3 (8.9)G2b: 67.8 (9.8)
van Manen et al 200488G1: Social cognitive (42)G1: 66.8 (9.5)G1: 63.3 (10.8)
 Moderate (97)G2: Social skills training (40)G2: 69.7 (6.6)G2: 61.6 (8.4)
G3: WLC (15)G3: 68.3 (5.9)G3: 63.7 (7.1)
Jouriles et al 2001101G1: MFT (18)G1: 66.28 (10)G1: 57.0 (11.1)
 High (36)G2: Comparison (18)G2: 65.56 (9.13)G2: 60.11 (10.81)
Hutchings et al 2002115G1: PT, intensive (21)G1: 74.2 (9.3)G1: 63.9 (11.1)
 Moderate (42)G2: Standard (13)G2: 75.3 (5.9)G2: 67.0 (9.23)
Barrett et al 2000120G1: RST (23)G1: 67.4 (7.0)G1: 59.8 (11.5)
 High (57)G2: TAU (12)G2: 70.0 (5.8)G2: 74.0 (5.0)
  • IY-PT, Incredible Years–Parent Training; IYPP, Incredible Years Parenting Program; MFT, multigroup family therapy; MST, multisystemic therapy; PMTO, Parent Management Training Oregon Model; PT, parent training; SET-PC, Supportive Expressive Therapy–Parent Child; RST, reciprocal skills training; WLC, waitlist control.