This article requires a subscription to view the full text. If you have a subscription you may use the login form below to view the article. Access to this article can also be purchased.
- AAP —
- American Academy of Pediatrics
Vaccine refusal forces us to confront tensions between many values, including scientific expertise, parental rights, children’s best interests, social responsibility, public trust, and community health. Recent outbreaks of vaccine-preventable and emerging infectious diseases have amplified these issues. The prospect of a coronavirus disease 2019 vaccine signals even more friction on the horizon. In this contentious sociopolitical landscape, it is therefore more important than ever for clinicians to identify ethically justified responses to vaccine refusal.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) says dismissing families who continue to refuse vaccines is an “acceptable option,”1 but some practices have gone further by not accepting vaccine refusers as patients at all.2,3 The phenomenon of nonacceptance has been underexplored; in both empirical studies and ethics analyses, researchers largely focus on dismissal.4–7 In this article, we first criticize arguments for nonacceptance that invoke a supposed right to choose one’s patients. We then argue that nonacceptance is problematic because (1) some of its motivations are intrinsically immoral, (2) it does not appear to accomplish some of its goals, and (3) even when nonacceptance does accomplish its goals, it fails to appropriately balance the various values it implicates. Throughout the article, we engage with the existing ethics literature about dismissal and conclude that even if dismissal is sometimes justifiable, nonacceptance is not.
A Right to Choose One’s Patients?
Some may argue that nonacceptance is ethically justified because they believe the clinical relationship is fundamentally a free association between clinicians and patients, as the American Medical Association Code of Medical …
Address correspondence to Mark C. Navin, PhD, Department of Philosophy, Oakland University, 746 Mathematics and Science Center, 146 Library Dr, Rochester, MI 48309-4479. E-mail: navin{at}oakland.edu
Individual Login
Institutional Login
You may be able to gain access using your login credentials for your institution. Contact your librarian or administrator if you do not have a username and password.