Outcomes in Mild to Moderate Isolated Thrombocytopenia
OBJECTIVES: Incidental isolated mild to moderate thrombocytopenia is a frequent laboratory finding prompting a referral to pediatric hematology-oncology. We tested the hypothesis that patients with isolated asymptomatic mild thrombocytopenia would not progress to require an intervention from a pediatric hematologist–oncologist.
METHODS: This is a 5-year retrospective review of 113 patients referred to pediatric hematology–oncology for isolated thrombocytopenia. Initial, lowest, and current platelet counts along with clinical course and need for interventions were recorded. Thrombocytopenia was categorized as mild (platelet count: 101–140 × 103/μL), moderate (platelet count: 51–100 × 103/μL), severe (platelet count: 21–50 × 103/μL), and very severe (platelet count: ≤20 × 103/μL).
RESULTS: Eight of 48 patients (17%) referred for initial mild isolated thrombocytopenia progressed to moderate thrombocytopenia at 1 visit. At present, 2 of these patients have moderate thrombocytopenia, 17 remain with mild thrombocytopenia, and 29 patients have resolved thrombocytopenia. Nine of 65 patients (14%) referred for moderate thrombocytopenia progressed to severe or very severe thrombocytopenia on 1 occasion. At present, no patients have severe thrombocytopenia, 18 remain with moderate thrombocytopenia, 14 improved to mild thrombocytopenia, and 33 have resolved thrombocytopenia. Only 3 patients required interventions from a hematologist, whereas 10 patients required therapy from other subspecialties.
CONCLUSIONS: We only identified 3 patients (3%) with mild to moderate thrombocytopenia who required an intervention from a hematologist to improve platelet counts. Patients with isolated mild thrombocytopenia with a normal bleeding history and physical examination findings frequently have normalized their platelet counts within 1 month.
- ITP —
- immune thrombocytopenia
- SLE —
- systemic lupus erythematous
- UAB —
- University of Alabama at Birmingham
What’s Known on This Subject:
Isolated thrombocytopenia is a common pediatric laboratory finding among patients with a bleeding or bruising history as well as being an incidental laboratory finding. The outcomes and need for referral to pediatric hematology–oncology have not been established.
What This Study Adds:
The majority of patients with mild or moderate thrombocytopenia normalized platelet counts within 3 months. Mild isolated thrombocytopenia without a bleeding history or abnormal physical findings did not require interventions from pediatric hematology–oncology; moderate isolated thrombocytopenia cases rarely required interventions.
A broad differential diagnosis exists for pediatric patients diagnosed with isolated thrombocytopenia, defined as a platelet count <140–150 × 103/μL.1,2 When platelet counts drop to <30–50 × 103/μL, patients may develop petechiae, bruising, and epistaxis, prompting primary care providers to obtain a complete blood count.3,4 Isolated thrombocytopenia may also be incidentally identified by a primary care provider who performs a complete blood count for other indications, including concerns for anemia, leukopenia and/or leukocytosis, or as part of a routine health screening with hemoglobin and/or hematocrit.5 Once isolated thrombocytopenia is identified, a primary care provider may further evaluate or refer that patient to a pediatric hematologist–oncologist on the basis of either the primary care provider’s concern or parental desire.6 Parents and patients referred for isolated mild to moderate thrombocytopenia may experience emotional distress either during the wait for their referral visit and/or the time spent in a waiting room at a pediatric hematology–oncology clinic. Often, this distress is due to concern by the patient and/or parent that the child has cancer. In addition, current health economics necessitates improved use of health care specialists. Therefore, having a clear understanding of which patients with mild to moderate thrombocytopenia require evaluation or intervention from a pediatric hematologist–oncologist would help primary care providers make the most beneficial referrals.
Although we hypothesize that pediatric patients with mild to moderate thrombocytopenia, no clinical symptoms, or any abnormal physical findings may not warrant an immediate referral to a pediatric hematologist–oncologist, there is minimal literature that can support this hypothesis. We could not identify any pediatric reports of outcomes for patients with mild or moderate thrombocytopenia and identified only 1 adult study of patients with mild persistent thrombocytopenia. Among the 191 adult patients with mild persistent thrombocytopenia, 60% remained with mild thrombocytopenia, 7% normalized their platelet counts, 7% developed an autoimmune disorder, and 6% were diagnosed with immune thrombocytopenia (ITP); 6 patients developed adult-specific malignancies (including breast, lung, and colorectal cancers and myelodysplasia).7 To better understand the outcomes for pediatric patients with isolated mild to moderate thrombocytopenia, we conducted a retrospective chart review to assess the incidence, outcomes, and need for intervention from a pediatric hematologist–oncologist among all patients referred for thrombocytopenia over a 5-year period. We tested the hypothesis that patients with isolated mild thrombocytopenia without bruising and/or bleeding symptoms would not progress to require an intervention from a pediatric hematologist–oncologist.
We conducted an institutional review board–approved retrospective study of all outpatient referrals to the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) Pediatric Hematology Oncology Clinic from June 2012 to June 2017. We excluded patients initially admitted to the hematology oncology service at Children’s of Alabama for thrombocytopenia who required additional follow-up in our outpatient clinic. The diagnosis and demographics were recorded for every patient. We recorded the date and platelet count at the time of the first episode of thrombocytopenia and the referral visit, lowest platelet count, and the most recent platelet count (as of January 2018). We categorized patients as having mild (platelet count: 101–140 × 103/µL), moderate (platelet count: 51–100 × 103/µL), severe (platelet count: 21–50 × 103/µL), and very severe (platelet count: ≤20 × 103/µL) thrombocytopenia at the time of referral on the basis of the lowest platelet count and current platelet count. We included 1 patient as mild at the time of referral despite being referred for thrombocytopenia with a platelet count of 143 × 103/µL; this patient had a previous clinic history of mild thrombocytopenia and an initial in-clinic platelet count of 123 × 103/µL. History of bruising at the time of referral, age, sex, and referring provider were recorded from clinic and referral notes. Therapeutic interventions and reason for intervention were recorded from pediatric hematology clinic notes. Finally, antineutrophil antibody, antinuclear antibody, platelet antibody, and immunoglobulin G levels were recorded. Descriptive statistics and univariate analysis were conducted by using JMP Pro 12 (SAS Institute, Inc, Cary, NC).
Among 2820 patients referred to the outpatient UAB Pediatric Hematology Oncology Clinic over a 5-year period, 2256 patients were referred for evaluation of a hematologic disease. The most common hematologic referral to our clinic was for sickle cell disease (n = 296; 13%) and the second most common referral was to evaluate thrombocytopenia (n = 204; 9%). Among the 204 patients with an outpatient referral for thrombocytopenia, 113 of these referrals were for isolated moderate or mild thrombocytopenia. The incidence of referrals for mild to moderate isolated thrombocytopenia was 23 patients per year. The mean age at referral was 10.6 years, and younger age was associated with a lower platelet count at the time of referral (P = .02). More patients were of male sex, and the majority of practitioners making referrals were pediatricians (Table 1). There were no statistical differences in the mean referral platelet count among 29 patients (26%) referred with a parent or referral report of increased bruising and/or bleeding as compared with 84 patients without a reported history of bruising and/or bleeding history (P = .2).
Among the 113 patients with isolated thrombocytopenia evaluated in our pediatric hematology clinic, 48 (42%) had isolated mild thrombocytopenia at the time of referral. Among the patients with isolated mild thrombocytopenia, 8 (17%) progressed to the moderate range during at least 1 point of follow-up, but no patients progressed to the severe or very severe ranges (Table 2). Twenty-nine (60%) of these patients currently have normal platelet counts, 17 (35%) have persistent mild thrombocytopenia, and 2 (4%) have moderate thrombocytopenia. Among those patients who had resolved thrombocytopenia, 23 resolved within 1 month and 3 additional patients resolved between 1 and 2 months. Two patients remain with moderate thrombocytopenia, 1 patient continues to be monitored by pediatric hematology for a RUNX1 mutation (familial platelet disorder with predisposition to acute myelogenous leukemia), and the other patient is being treated in rheumatology for juvenile idiopathic arthritis.
Sixty-five patients were referred with isolated moderate thrombocytopenia. Eight patients (12%) progressed to the severe thrombocytopenic range, and 1 patient (2%) progressed to very severe thrombocytopenia on at least 1 occasion (Table 2). For these patients with moderate thrombocytopenia at the time of referral, 33 (51%) currently have a normal platelet count, 14 (22%) are in the mild range, 18 (28%) have moderate thrombocytopenia, and no patients have severe thrombocytopenia on the basis of their most recent blood count.
To determine the role of monitoring of complete blood counts before referral, we analyzed the time to normalization for platelet counts. Among 62 patients who had normalized platelet counts, 43 (69%) normalized at their initial referral visit to pediatric hematology–oncology. In total, 50 (81%) patients had a normalized platelet count within 1 month of their referral visit, and 55 (89%) normalized within 2 months. Next, to evaluate outcomes on the basis of the length of time patients had thrombocytopenia before the primary care provider referral, we reviewed the 2 most common clinic visits resulting in a diagnosis of thrombocytopenia: (1) acute illness (n = 32) and (2) well-child evaluations (n = 18). Thirty-one of these patients were evaluated within 2 months of their first episode of thrombocytopenia. Twenty-three (74%) currently have normal platelet counts, including 14 whose counts had normalized at the time of the referral and 19 who resolved within 2 months after referral. In contrast, of the 19 patients with thrombocytopenia identified during an acute illness or well-child evaluation who had thrombocytopenia for at least 3 months before the referral visit, only 10 (53%) have normal platelet counts.
The majority of patients were not identified with a specific diagnosis for their mild to moderate thrombocytopenia. Several of these patients presented with viral symptoms at or around the time of referral, and the symptoms either resolved before the clinic visit or soon thereafter. Specific viral etiologies were not commonly tested for, and only 2 patients were formally diagnosed with Epstein-Barr virus infection during their evaluation for thrombocytopenia. Fourteen patients referred with moderate thrombocytopenia were diagnosed with ITP, but only 3 patients required interventions. Twelve patients were diagnosed with a drug-induced thrombocytopenia (4 for valproic acid, 2 for methylphenidate, 2 for dexmethylphenidate, 2 for risperidone, 1 for valganciclovir, and 1 for sertraline). Five patients were diagnosed with rheumatologic diseases (3 for systemic lupus erythematous [SLE] and 2 for juvenile idiopathic arthritis). Two of these 5 patients presented with joint pain and thrombocytopenia; 1 patient developed joint pain 1 month after the thrombocytopenia referral; 1 patient developed fever, rash, and joint pain 20 months after the thrombocytopenia referral; and 1 patient with a history of lupus developed thrombocytopenia 6 years after the lupus diagnosis. Finally, we identified 1 patient with a clinical history of bruising and moderate isolated thrombocytopenia who was diagnosed with a rare, qualitative platelet defect (Table 3).
Among the 115 cases of mild and moderate isolated thrombocytopenia, we identified 13 patients (11%) who required an intervention. Only 3 patients required therapy from a hematologist for ITP (1 for bruising and 2 for sports participation). The remaining 10 patients who required an intervention for thrombocytopenia received those interventions from another subspecialist (Supplemental Table 4).
Few patients with newly diagnosed isolated mild to moderate thrombocytopenia progressed to very severe thrombocytopenia in this cohort, and only 3 patients required interventions prescribed by a pediatric hematologist for moderate chronic ITP. One patient with a history of bruising and moderate isolated thrombocytopenia was diagnosed with a rare, qualitative platelet defect. No patients with an initial outpatient referral for isolated mild to moderate thrombocytopenia progressed to leukemia.
Many patients referred for mild to moderate isolated thrombocytopenia had a recent history of virallike symptoms. The majority of these patients had a normalization of their platelet counts within 1 to 2 months. Pediatric patients with congenital or acquired viral infections may develop thrombocytopenia because of alterations in platelet production or platelet destruction. Prevalent viruses linked to thrombocytopenia include HIV, hepatitis C, cytomegalovirus, varicella virus, Epstein-Barr virus, and others. In patients presenting with viral symptoms, isolated thrombocytopenia, and normal physical examination results (including lack of hepatosplenomegaly), the isolated thrombocytopenia may continue over the course of the viral illness. Although there is concern that thrombocytopenia and fever might be a presentation of leukemia, our results mirror those in other large reviews of children with leukemia demonstrating that isolated thrombocytopenia with a normal hemoglobin, white blood cell count, and physical examination results and no symptoms of bone pain is unlikely to be leukemia.8–11
Drug-induced thrombocytopenia was the second most common diagnosis for patients in this cohort with mild to moderate thrombocytopenia. An established database for medications with a high incidence for drug-induced thrombocytopenia is available at http://www.ouhsc.edu/platelets/ditp.html. We also identified several potential additional diagnoses, such as SLE. Juvenile idiopathic arthritis and Crohn disease and/or ulcerative colitis should be considered by a primary care provider when patients present with mild to moderate thrombocytopenia. Although anemia is the most common hematologic manifestation of SLE, identified in up to 90% of cases, 40% of case patients with SLE present with a platelet count of <150 × 103/µL and 27% present with a platelet count of <100 × 103/µL.12,13 Our data is used to support screening patients with thrombocytopenia for SLE by clinical history and physical examination, and in patients with high clinical suspicion, further testing with antinuclear antibody is warranted. A second nonhematologic diagnosis to consider in patients with thrombocytopenia is Crohn disease or ulcerative colitis as an extraintestinal manifestation of these diseases. Similar to SLE, anemia is the more common hematologic manifestation of Crohn disease or ulcerative colitis, yet our group and others have identified thrombocytopenia as a rare presenting hematologic manifestation.14,15 Finally, we identified 1 referral for a patient who was diagnosed with a rare, inherited functional platelet defect. These patients often present with manifestations of bruising, epistaxis, and/or menorrhagia in the setting of mild to moderate thrombocytopenia and a family history of mucocutaneous bleeding or menorrhagia.
The most common diagnosis for all referred patients with thrombocytopenia was ITP. However, these patients frequently presented with severe or very severe thrombocytopenia rather than mild or moderate isolated thrombocytopenia. In addition, several case patients with ITP presented to the emergency department rather than in referral to our outpatient clinic. Patients with mild to moderate thrombocytopenia that progress to very severe thrombocytopenia during ITP typically present with acute onset of bleeding or significant bruising.16
As a retrospective study, some limitations are worth noting. One limitation is that we analyzed history of a bleeding disorder from the referral clinic notes rather than using a validated bleeding score. Therefore, to fully assess the risk for disease-specific progression of thrombocytopenia among patients with mild to moderate thrombocytopenia, assessing bleeding history in a more comprehensive and standardized manner is helpful. There are several pediatric bleeding questionnaires designed to help distinguish between children with and without von Willebrand disease.17–20 A second limitation exists because patients could develop progressive thrombocytopenia that was not identified. Because patients may not experience clinical signs of thrombocytopenia until a platelet count is very low, we may have missed patients with platelet counts <50 × 103/µL between clinic visits. Third, we continue to follow some patients with persistent mild to moderate thrombocytopenia without clinical signs or symptoms who lack a defined diagnosis. These patients may have a mild autoimmune thrombocytopenia or platelet antibodies not yet identified, but because they are not progressive in their current disease course, more expensive and invasive testing has been deferred. Thus, an ultimate diagnosis may not have been made. Fourth, we diagnosed several patients referred with 2 cell line abnormalities with a bone marrow failure syndrome or aplastic anemia. We acknowledge that some patients with bone marrow failure syndromes may initially present with isolated mild to moderate thrombocytopenia and require continued serial blood count monitoring for progression to additional cytopenias. Finally, we do not have a systematic referral system in place in which all thrombocytopenia cases in Alabama are referred to a pediatric hematologist–oncologist at UAB. Therefore, we would expect that several case patients with isolated mild to moderate thrombocytopenia were not referred to us by their primary care providers. However, we expect that the majority of those missing cases would have resolved rather than progressed without referral. Therefore, this missing data are unlikely to change our findings.
The study shows that few patients with isolated mild to moderate thrombocytopenia require interventions from a pediatric hematologist. Interestingly, the majority of patients who needed an intervention after referral for mild to moderate thrombocytopenia received treatment from subspecialties other than hematology. Sixty percent of patients with mild isolated thrombocytopenia and 50% of patients with moderate thrombocytopenia resolved. Among those patients with resolved thrombocytopenia, ∼90% resolved within 2 months. We also identified autoimmune disorders or drug-induced thrombocytopenia as potential diagnoses in patients with persistent mild to moderate thrombocytopenia. Repeat serial histories, physicals, and complete blood counts can be used to differentiate an acute versus chronic course of thrombocytopenia. These measures are needed to rule out progressive cytopenias, macrocytosis, and organomegaly as well as to assess for any clinical manifestations of thrombocytopenia.
We acknowledge Lisa Allred, RN, for her amazing job leading our referral service and keeping excellent referral records.
- Accepted April 19, 2018.
- Address correspondence to Jeffrey Lebensburger, DO, MSPH, University of Alabama at Birmingham, 1600 7th Ave South, Lowder 512, Birmingham, AL 35223. E-mail:
FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
FUNDING: Dr Lebensburger is funded by the National Institutes of Health (5K23HL127100) and an American Society of Hematology Scholar Award for research in sickle cell nephropathy that is not relevant to this article. Funded by the National Institutes of Health (NIH).
POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST: The authors have indicated they have no potential conflicts of interest to disclose.
- Arnold DM
- Hagan JF,
- Shaw JS,
- Duncan PM
- Dubansky AS,
- Boyett JM,
- Falletta J, et al
- Copyright © 2018 by the American Academy of Pediatrics