“A Guide to Gutsy Living”: Patient-Driven Development of a Pediatric Ostomy Toolkit
- IBD —
- inflammatory bowel disease
- ICN —
- PAC —
- Patient Advisory Council
- QI —
- quality improvement
As patients (J.G.D. and A.J.) who have lived with pediatric-onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) since 12 and 9 years of age, respectively, and who underwent ostomy surgery at 19 and 15 years of age, respectively, we experienced a lack of psychosocial education about our surgeries. This negatively impacted our ability to adjust postoperatively to having an ostomy. For example, we had to learn how to explain our ostomies to friends and how having an ostomy might impact our clothing choices. The education we received about our ostomy surgery was brief and focused only on basic skills regarding caring for an ostomy, including changing and emptying the bag, but did not address concerns we had about living with ostomies as part of our everyday lives. This educational void placed the burden on us as patients to find resources on our own, decide if the information was appropriate, and determine if it was reliable and accurate.
In this article, we describe how we, as patients, harnessed the capacity of a collaborative chronic care network1 and were supported to develop a resource that patients needed.
The ImproveCareNow (ICN) Network is dedicated to improving the health and health care of children and adolescents with IBD. Formed in 2007, the network is presently composed of 107 pediatric IBD centers in the United States, Europe, and the Middle East.2,3 One of ICN’s central values is coproduction, in which participants (patients, families, clinicians, and researchers) work together to plan, develop, and create health care services.4 Coproduction is of growing interest in the medical field, in which there is an explicit need for medical professionals to work with patients to create more effective services. In ICN, patients, clinicians, and researchers collaborate to coproduce health care services, systems improvement, and research.
The ICN Patient Advisory Council (PAC) is a national council for patients with IBD who are patient advocates and contribute to the continuous evolution and improvement of ICN by serving as leaders across the full range of ICN’s activities. PAC members work to identify needs of the patient community and help patients self-organize to develop interventions, tools, and resources to improve care and outcomes of patients cared for across the network. At the time this project was conducted, the PAC was composed of 2 cochairs (J.G.D. was 1 cochair), 2 patient scholars (ie, vice chairs) (A.J. was 1 patient scholar), and 11 general members and was supported by 1 ICN staff member.
Planning the Intervention
Our project evolved from the ongoing work of the PAC within the network. After noting a shared need in our own experiences living with IBD and ostomies, we, as members of the PAC, made ourselves available as mentors to clinical teams within ICN that were interested in having pediatric patients with IBD available to their patients who were facing ostomy surgery. After serving as peer mentors, we quickly realized our capacity to provide individual mentorship would be insufficient for the demand given the limited number of PAC members with ostomies and the time involved to repeatedly provide virtually identical ostomy mentorship to each individual patient. We hypothesized that a printed resource could serve as continuing education and support in lieu of a 1-time verbal mentorship session and better serve the network’s patients, parents, and clinicians. For these reasons, we identified the pediatric ostomy toolkit as a high-priority project for our PAC to develop.
We started a national task force of interested patients and parents who had experiences with ostomies to develop a pediatric ostomy toolkit. The task force was composed entirely of patients and parents and consisted of 7 patients and parents (previous and current pediatric ostomates and their parents; 6 young women and 1 young man), including 5 pediatric patients with IBD and 2 female parents, and was led by 1 of our PAC co-chairs who had an ostomy. We worked together over e-mail to allow our members from across the United States to contribute. We also took advantage of the ICN Exchange (www.icnexchange.org), which is a resource-sharing Web site that is open to all ICN community members for sharing information, documents, and resources. It is also a place where ICN community members can post research and quality improvement (QI) questions or comments. We posted about the pediatric ostomy toolkit development and asked clinicians to recruit any interested patients and parents to join our patient- and parent-led group and share their contact information for project communication.
Identification of Topics Relevant to Ostomy Education and Postoperative Adjustment
Our self-organized group of patients and parents, all individuals either living with IBD and ostomies or parents of such an individual, reviewed IBD resource Web sites to identify current resources for pediatric patients with ostomies. We were unable to find any developmentally sensitive education resources that used appropriate images.
Our task force searched the medical literature for studies in which researchers described the needs of ostomy education. Adolescents who undergo ostomy surgery for IBD experience a broad impact on their lives, including having to cope with a range of adjustment issues related to body image and autonomy.5 Clinicians who care for adolescents also face the challenge of providing supportive education that promotes psychosocial resilience. Pediatric ostomy education differs from adult ostomy education because of the need to adapt education to the developmental stages of the pediatric patient and family.6,7 Helping the child be comfortable and odor-free at school and participate in normal childhood activities such as playing sports, continually encouraging the child’s confidence in self-care, and the eventual transfer of responsibility from caregivers to the child are all important issues to be addressed.8 Adolescents with ostomies often express concerns about the impact on clothing, acceptance from peers, returning to favored activities, traveling, and pursuing education.8
After reviewing this information, we asked task force members to identify questions and topics related to living with an ostomy, including questions members had preoperatively, immediately postoperatively, and in the extended time since their surgeries. From this prompt, our group generated a list of topics all patients and parents agreed on based on the shared concerns, insights, or questions our task force members had around ostomy surgery. For example, 1 member was an athlete and wanted the toolkit to include insights about playing a contact sport with an ostomy, whereas another had traveled abroad and sought to include her thoughts about travel advice with an ostomy. We chose to develop the toolkit to be of use across the pediatric developmental span, from a 10-year-old child to a 17-year-old adolescent, so that it would be an accessible resource both at the time of surgery as well as while the child matured. Our group chose to structure the topics as a series of general questions (eg, “How do I tell my friends about my ostomy?”) and quoted responses to imitate mentoring, ensure the resource provided appropriate insights without suggesting a “right” way to cope with an ostomy, and to reiterate the resource being developed by and intended for pediatric patients with IBD.
Production of the Toolkit
With the list of generated topics, our task force worked iteratively to condense topics where possible (eg, incorporating high school and college into 1 topic) to produce a finalized topic list. Once the list of topics was finalized, our members contributed to at least 2 topics by writing down their insights regarding the question in an answer format. This approach ensured a diversity of responses that would make the toolkit representative of our collective experiences. We then designed a first draft of a toolkit, complete with images provided by members. We ensured that the toolkit was written at a fifth-grade literacy level. To help address accessibility of the resource, we obtained a creative commons license for the pediatric ostomy toolkit. It has been made freely available for download on ICN’s Web site as of July 8, 2016.9
Toolkit Evaluation by Clinicians
To address medical accuracy, our task force took advantage of the network infrastructure to facilitate medical review by network clinicians, including nurses, doctors, and psychologists. After the creation of the toolkit, we reached out to clinicians to provide clinical review. Our task force then approached ICN clinicians and circulated the toolkit for critique to a group of clinicians who had previously referred patients for ostomy mentoring. We also brought the toolkit to the national ICN network meeting to give clinicians the opportunity to provide feedback on the toolkit in person, including a workshop session led by the chair of the task force (J.G.D.).
We then created an online survey with questions relating to the theorized utility of the ostomy toolkit, current barriers to ostomy education, and perceived levels of ostomy preparedness. Working with the ICN coordinating center and QI team, our task force recruited clinicians from the network to participate in the survey and circulated it with an electronic copy of the toolkit. By using the ICN listserv, 15 clinicians (9 physicians, 6 nurses) were recruited to review the toolkit and complete the online survey. On the basis of the quantitative and qualitative feedback, we decided to maintain the focus of the pediatric ostomy toolkit on children and adolescents and chose not to include an insert for caregivers, although all task force members agreed this feedback had merit for a future project aimed at caregivers of a child or adolescent with an ostomy. Following feedback from clinicians and additional ideas from the task force, we decided to adjust the color scheme, add sections on “take down” surgery, and add a blank notes page.
Our final 19-page, colorful toolkit included topics relating to friends, school, travel, ostomy supplies, clothing, playing sports, using humor to cope, emergency kits, educational issues (eg, 504 plans), “Gastronauts” (Gastronauts are freely available puppets with ostomies), and ostomy medical language. To demonstrate the question and answer style, we give the following examples from the travel and clothing sections of the toolkit. From the travel section, the prompt question states, “Does having an ostomy make it harder to travel?” with 1 reply from a 23-year-old woman with Crohn disease and a permanent ileostomy as follows:
Have ostomy, will travel!. . . When I travel, I make sure to have plenty of spare supplies (especially if I’m going to an international destination) and ensure I keep them on my person (i.e., in my carry-on and not in my checked luggage if I’m flying). . . . I have a card that says I have an ostomy, but you could also get a note from your doctor so that airport security will allow you to use the special line without hassle.In the clothing section, the prompt question reads, “Do I have to wear different clothing with an ostomy?” with a response from a 17-year-old boy with Crohn disease and a permanent ileostomy as follows:
Clothing for me is really easy. I only wear three types of clothes, t-shirts, athletic shorts, and athletic pants, and both the pants and the shorts have the same exact feeling and function. To incorporate my bag into my outfit is a two-step process. I first decided whether to tuck my bag into my pants or to let it hang out of my pants. My second and final step was to wear slightly too large shirts to keep everything well covered. Without a bag, I would be wearing Adult Mediums; since I have the bag, I wear Adult Larges. If your outfit is more extravagant than mine, my only advice would be to wear things that are comfortable and cover up your ostomy bag. Other sample responses can be found in Table 1.
The pediatric ostomy toolkit was posted on the ICN Exchange platform, where it has been downloaded 85 times and viewed 106 times as of August 15, 2017. We obtained feedback on the medical information presented in the toolkit from the clinicians who reviewed it to produce an accurate resource. Clinician survey responses were extremely positive. Over 90% (n = 14) reported fully approving the current design format of the toolkit. Qualitative feedback was extremely enthusiastic (eg, “I think you have done a fantastic job and are providing a well-needed service. Congratulations to all who took part in this. ICN and the PAC rock!,” “Excellent Job. This is an awesome resource for providers to provide their patients and families,” and “[G]reat job. Maybe a more formal insert for parents only?”).
We found that a collaborative network of patients, families, clinicians, and researchers provided the organizational infrastructure to enable our self-organized team of youth and parents with IBD to work together and to work with clinical teams to coproduce a resource for ostomy patients. We took advantage of the ICN community to self-mobilize patients and parents into a task force, work together as patients by using QI methods, find and consult clinicians as advisors, revise the tool, and make it immediately available to the network via an electronic platform. We developed the toolkit in response to a need perceived by patients like ourselves and built on our motivation to contribute by enabling other patients to thrive with their illnesses.
The patient-driven approach described here differs from how traditional top-down development of clinical education resources usually takes place. The traditional model is one in which patients and families may only be consulted during or after the resource is developed. The “bottom-up” approach we describe here began with a need identified by patients and parents who then self-organized, developed the educational resource, and consulted clinicians. We drew on the support and QI education we received as full and equal participants in the network to draft this article according to the SQUIRE guidelines.
The pediatric ostomy toolkit has potential utility both preoperatively and postoperatively for pediatric patients facing ostomy surgery. This is a unique and important quality of the pediatric ostomy toolkit that moves ostomy education away from a single time point and toward a malleable and personalized education schedule. Additionally, the physical resource allows pediatric patients to interact with the toolkit through underlining notable lines, writing questions, and making use of the notes section of the resource. The resource allows patients like ourselves who have IBD and ostomies to return to the toolkit as needed (for example, when transitioning to college and interested in learning more about living with an ostomy in college). Thus, our pediatric ostomy toolkit can be used to address the psychosocial needs we have felt as patients as well as clinician-reported barriers by providing a resource filled with appropriate medical and psychosocial information, thereby extending the period of education to address surgical-time pressure and delivering developmentally sensitive information to pediatric patients and their families to acclimate them to talking about ostomies. In addition, as patients we feel strongly that having this resource available to pediatric patients with IBD who are having ostomy surgery would address many of the concerns we had around the time of our own surgeries without the need for patients and parents to independently search for reliable medical information.
Previous research on ostomy education has included encouraging clinicians to provide educational pamphlets to patients and families, demonstrating putting an appliance on a favorite toy for children, directing patients and families to online support groups,10 videos to teach patients to independently change their ostomy appliances,11 and guidelines for teaching adults with ostomies how to care for their appliances.12,13 In a systemic review of educational interventions for individuals with ostomies, researchers identified 7 studies (2 randomized control trials, 5 cohort studies) in which all of the educational interventions were delivered by ostomy nurses and were exclusively designed to minimize stoma-related complications.3
There have been barriers to achieving optimal ostomy education for pediatric patients, including the lack of a standardized approach to medical and psychosocial education, outdated information, and minimal information on developmentally appropriate topics (eg, school). To the best of our knowledge, our project is the first one in which patients and parents led the coproduction of a resource for pediatric patients undergoing ostomy surgery that addresses medical and psychosocial information on the basis of needs perceived by the patient community.
There are several limitations of our study, including the potentially unique voices of the patient advocates who created it and limited evaluation of the resource. It is conceivable that the insights and topics identified by our task force do not fully represent the needs of pediatric patients with IBD and their parents. The patients and parents engaged in our task force certainly have a high level of motivation to participate. This observation is consistent with ICN’s previous ethnographic research in which a subgroup of patients was identified who would be highly motivated to contribute as an important segment of the population.14 In his extensive research, von Hippel15 suggests that such “lead users” may have insights into how to create innovative approaches to products and services and that such individuals anticipate the needs of others. We believe our task force represents individuals who may have well-developed insights into how to live effectively and purposefully with physical limitations given the personal experiences of all task force members. Thus, it is possible that by selecting for individuals who are willing to innovate, we have contributed knowledge and insights that may be absent in traditional educational resource development projects. The favorable reviews by clinicians and staff suggest that our insights as patients and parents were not only medically appropriate but also useful from a clinical perspective. This question will require further study and confirmation.
Our toolkit has not yet been evaluated prospectively to assess whether using the toolkit as part of clinical care improves psychosocial outcomes for pediatric patients with IBD after surgery. We hope this will be an opportunity for future research and further engagement of patients in the “bottom-up” design and execution of research so that it answers the questions that are most meaningful to patients, parents, and clinicians alike. We firmly believe that this is a valuable approach to patient-led coproduction in pediatric chronic illness care and that the structure of our process may be a useful example for other projects.
This project provided us as patients with a number of insights about patients’ roles in coproducing medical care with clinicians in a network. We as patients came to appreciate how the network culture and processes thoughtfully encourage and respect the unique perspectives of patients and parents and set the norm that these insights are valuable. Our positive experience of initiating collaboration with clinicians served as a useful example and deepened the appreciation across ICN participants (patients, families, clinicians, and researchers) about the potential for patients and parents to contribute meaningfully to the care system and help to shape future initiatives. The experience also helped us learn about using network communication infrastructure to address the challenges of communication across barriers of geography and time. The network’s QI capability enabled us to work efficiently and to iterate and improve the ostomy toolkit. We used what we learned about QI to build a complete first draft, approach clinicians for an evaluation of the toolkit, and integrate feedback into a revised version of the toolkit in an interactive way.
The patient-driven “bottom-up” approach we used overcomes the limited capacity of the health care delivery system, which imposes a significant constraint in the production of useful medical and psychosocial education for children and youth. In our example, we demonstrate how patient and parent-led coproduction of patient education can expand capacity and directly infuse resources back into a network as well as generate solutions to problems experienced by patient communities. In addition, the lack of psychosocial support after ostomy surgery in pediatric patients with IBD had been a significant void for our population. In our toolkit, this need is recognized and addressed.
In our patient- and parent-led toolkit project, we demonstrate how patients and families can self-organize and ask clinicians to consult to create needed resources within a network. Our approach to coproduction offers the potential to increase capacity and relevance within the health care system. Understanding the potential and challenges of this model deserves future research. Most importantly, the implications of this project suggest that patients have the motivation and ability to work together to inform clinical pediatric practice and to increase the integration of patient perspectives into medical and psychosocial education.
We thank Kristen Buckingham, Ethan Fitter, Sharon Fitter, Bianca Siedlaczek, and Cinda Lemont for their contributions to the pediatric ostomy toolkit. We are grateful to the community that has been created as part of the ICN Pediatric IBD Learning Health System. Participating care centers can be found at www.improvecarenow.org. We also thank the ICN clinicians and staff who provided useful insights into the development of the work described here. The ICN community received support from the many participating care centers, the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, and the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute to create the community that made this work possible.
- Accepted December 6, 2017.
- Address correspondence to Jennie G. David, MS, Department of Psychology, Drexel University, 3141 Chestnut St, Stratton Hall, Office 215, Philadelphia, PA 19104. E-mail:
FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
FUNDING: The ImproveCareNow Network received support from participating care centers, the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (grant R01DK085719), and the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (grant PPRN-1306-01754) to create the community that made this work possible. Funded by the National Institutes of Health (NIH).
POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST: The authors have indicated they have no potential conflicts of interest to disclose.
- Margolis PA,
- Peterson LE,
- Seid M
- Batalden M,
- Batalden P,
- Margolis P, et al
- Patient Advisory Council for the ImproveCareNow Network
- Copyright © 2018 by the American Academy of Pediatrics