Joshi P, Mofidi S, Sicherer SH. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2002;109:1019–1021
Purpose of the Study.
Food allergen avoidance is the mainstay of current therapy for food allergy and food-allergic consumers depend on the ingredients labels of the commercial products. This study sought to determine the accuracy of label reading among parents of food-allergic children.
Parents of food-allergic children followed at the food allergy referral center.
Parents of children on restricted diets were asked to review a group of 23 food labels taken from widely available commercial products. For each label, each parent/parent pair was asked to indicate whether the product was safe for the allergic child and, if it was not, which foods restricted from the child’s diet were in the product.
There were 91 participants. Peanut was the most commonly restricted food (82 children), followed by milk, egg, soy, and wheat (60, 45, 27, and 16 children, respectively). Identification of milk and soy was the most problematic: only 4 (7%) of 60 parents correctly identified all 14 labels that indicated milk, and only 6 (22%) of 27 parents correctly identified soy protein in 7 products. Peanut was correctly identified in 5 products by 44 (54%) of the 82 parents restricting peanut. Wheat (10 labels) and egg (7 labels) were correctly identified by most parents (14/16 and 42/45, respectively). Correct label identification was associated with prior instruction by a dietitian.
With current labeling practices, most parents are unable to identify common allergenic food ingredients. These results strongly support the need for improved labeling with plain-English terminology and allergen warnings as well as the need for diligent education of patients about reading labels.
Accidental food allergic reactions are common in children and many of them result from unknowing ingestions in the processed foods. This study emphasizes that complex ingredient terminology (eg, casein and whey for milk) and label ambiguities (eg, natural flavor and may contain peanut) compromise the ability of food-allergic patients/their parents to determine the safety of particular products. Simplified labeling is urgently needed. Until then, the patients and their parents need to be educated as to how to read labels to identify problematic foods.