eLetters to:

ARTICLE: Cheryl Hemingway, John M. Freeman, Diana J. Pillas, and Paula L. Pyzik The Ketogenic Diet: A 3- to 6-Year Follow-Up of 150 Children Enrolled Prospectively Pediatrics 2001; 108: 898-905 [Abstract] [Full text] [PDF]

eLetters: Submit a response to this article

eLetters published:

Diet Survey

Thivakorn Kasemsri   (15 October 2001)

Untitled

John M Freeman   (17 October 2001)

Ketogenic Diet and Vitamin B9

Urs W. Bosshard   (6 March 2002)

Diet Survey 15 October 2001
Thivakorn Kasemsri, Intensivist Covenant Children's Hospital Send letter to journal: Re: Diet Survey tkasemsri{at}home.com Thivakorn Kasemsri	Interesting information on a "cultish" medical practice. Is this what one calls an anecdote of an anecdote? I can only shake my head in awe at how this type of therapy "works". I am also humbled by how we learned and scientific physicians constantly employ therapies that we have very little mechanistic understanding. I suppose that is the "art" of medicine. As for the article itself, of course, I wished that there was a control group of patients not on the diet so that I may see if they would have had similar results with there seizures over the same period. Finally, of course, I am wary of survey results from people who may report compliance whether there was actual compliance to a regimented diet or not. The world is full of similar testimonials from people who champion one diet or another for weight loss.
Untitled 17 October 2001
John M Freeman, Physician Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions Send letter to journal: Re: this article Jfreeman{at}jhmi.edu John M Freeman	The ketogenic diet is NOT a "cultish" therapy. This aproach has been independantly reviewed and approved by the Blue Cross/Blue Shield Technology Assessment Center. It is now an accepted alternative approach for children with difficult to control seizures. We allso wish that we knew how the therapy works. Many are now beginning to work on its mechanisms of action. We are lookidng at the 3-6 year outcomes of children who did not stay on the diet. Perhaps they will provide a control group. Thank you for your insights.
Ketogenic Diet and Vitamin B9 6 March 2002
Urs W. Bosshard, Research Send letter to journal: Re: Ketogenic Diet and Vitamin B9 urs.bosshard{at}gmx.net Urs W. Bosshard	It is since jears well known, that e.g. LAMICTAL (Lamotrogin) is a Antagonist of Vitamin B9 (Folsäure). So, Ketogenic Diet and reduction of B9 will do the same.