 |
|
 |
|
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ARTICLE |
a Division of Endocrinology/Diabetes, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
b Department of Pediatrics, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
 |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
 TOP ABSTRACT INTRODUCTIONMETHODSRESULTSDISCUSSIONCONCLUSIONSREFERENCES |
|---|
STUDY DESIGN. The design consisted of chart review of all diagnostic fasting tests conducted over a 3-year period (n = 151). A normal growth hormone level was defined as 
7.5 ng/mL, and a normal cortisol level was defined as 18 µg/dL.
RESULTS. During the fasting tests, 84 children (median age: 1.3 years [2 days to 14.3 years]), became hypoglycemic, with blood glucose 
50 mg/dL. Diagnoses included normal, ketotic hypoglycemia, hyperinsulinism, fatty acid–oxidation defects, glycogen-storage disease, and late dumping hypoglycemia. A total of 70% had growth hormone and cortisol levels less than the "normal" thresholds regardless of diagnosis. Of various factors (age, diagnosis, fast duration, duration blood glucose level of <60 mg/dL, and blood glucose nadir), only age was positively associated with cortisol, and none were consistently related to growth hormone.
CONCLUSIONS. A singe low growth hormone or cortisol value at the time of fasting hypoglycemia has poor specificity for the respective diagnoses of growth hormone deficiency and adrenal insufficiency.
Key Words: hypoglycemia • children • fasting test • growth hormone deficiency • adrenal insufficiency
Abbreviations: GH—growth hormone • GHD—growth hormone deficiency • BG—blood glucose
|
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
TOPABSTRACTINTRODUCTIONMETHODSRESULTSDISCUSSIONCONCLUSIONSREFERENCES |
|---|
Growth hormone (GH) and cortisol measurements have also conveniently been included in the "critical" sample obtained at the time of hypoglycemia during a fasting test as a means to exclude deficiencies of these hormones.10 This practice is based on the insulin-induced hypoglycemia of the insulin-tolerance test, a potent stimulus for GH11 and cortisol12,13 secretion. Moreover, because GH is "tonically elevated" in the newborn period, experts recommend that GH be measured in the neonate with hypoglycemia and that concentrations of <20 µg/L suggest GH deficiency (GHD).14,15
However, clinical experience suggests that, at the time of hypoglycemia, GH and cortisol concentrations are frequently not above the thresholds defined as normal for provocative studies. The purposes of this study were to (1) determine whether GH and cortisol concentrations during fasting hypoglycemia are commonly low in the absence of true hormone deficiencies and (2) identify clinical factors that might influence GH and cortisol at the time of hypoglycemia.
|
METHODS |
|---|
|
TOPABSTRACTINTRODUCTIONMETHODSRESULTSDISCUSSIONCONCLUSIONSREFERENCES |
|---|
50 mg/dL were included in the final analyses. All GH and cortisol data, final diagnosis, age, duration of fast, BG nadir, medications, and growth were extracted from patient charts. The duration of time BG was 60 mg/dL before it reached 50 mg/dL was also recorded as a marker of tempo and rapidity of hypoglycemia onset; some children linger with BG in the 50s, whereas others have fairly long fasting durations with a BG level of >70 mg/dL and then acutely have hypoglycemia. GH data were excluded for octreotide treatment. Cortisol data were excluded for oral glucocorticoid treatment.
Fasting Tests
All patients were admitted to the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. The fast start was defined as the time a feed or meal was completed. Bedside BG levels were measured frequently on a SureStep meter (Lifescan, Milpitas, CA). Blood ketone levels were measured at the bedside by using the Precision Xtra BG and ketone monitoring system (Abbott, Alameda, CA). The test was terminated for BG levels of 50 mg/dL (verified in the laboratory), for blood ketone levels of 2.5 mM, or if the child was able to fast for a defined period of time (age <1 month 12 hours; 1 month to 1 year 18 hours; 1–3 years 24 hours; and age >3 years 36 hours). At the termination of the test, blood was drawn to test BG, GH, cortisol, insulin, free fatty acids, β-hydroxybutyrate, and lactate; glucagon-stimulation testing was performed for BG levels at 50 mg/dL. Testing for acylcarnitine profiles and urine organic acids was performed.
A child who became hypoglycemic was considered normal if he or she was able to fast for the predefined period before becoming hypoglycemic and had normal fasting adaptation as defined by serum β-hydroxybutyrate 2.5 mM, a free fatty acids level of >1 mM, lactate at <2 mM, normal acylcarnitine and urine organic acid levels, and no response to glucagon. Ketotic hypoglycemia is essentially normal but shortened fasting adaptation in the setting of normal growth; this "diagnosis" is made when other diagnoses have been excluded.
Definitions
Hypoglycemia was defined as a BG level of 50 mg/dL. GH concentrations 7.5 ng/mL excluded GHD; this threshold is based on GH responses established as normal for standard GH-provocative studies.16 Similarly, a normal cortisol level was defined as 18 µg/dL17–20 on the basis of thresholds established for insulin-tolerance and standard corticotropin-stimulation tests.17–20
Statistical Analyses
Means and SDs or medians and ranges, depending on normality, were used to summarize continuous variables; proportions were used for categorical variables. Continuous data were compared by using t tests or the Wilcoxon rank-sum test. The 
2 test was used to compare binomial proportions. Two-sided tests were used, and P < .05 was considered significant. Nonnormally distributed continuous data were transformed to improve fit. Linear regression was used to identify factors important for GH and cortisol responses by using Stata 9 (Stata Corp, College Station, TX).
The protocol was approved by the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia Institutional Review Board.
|
RESULTS |
|---|
|
TOPABSTRACTINTRODUCTIONMETHODSRESULTSDISCUSSIONCONCLUSIONSREFERENCES |
|---|
50 mg/dL. Characteristics of children with GH (n = 68) and cortisol (n = 76) data available are shown in Table 1. Most were infants and young children. The majority were diagnosed as normal or as having ketotic hypoglycemia or hyperinsulinism. Two children with Nissen fundoplications had late dumping syndrome (postprandial hypoglycemia). Diagnoses among children <4 weeks of age varied: normal (n = 1), Glycogen storage disease type 1 (n = 1), and hyperinsulinism–congenital (n = 5) and perinatal stress-induced (n = 1). Formal GH-provocative studies were performed for 4 children; their final diagnoses included GHD (n = 1), ketotic hypoglycemia (n = 1), and hyperinsulinism (n = 2). Formal tests of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis were performed for 8 children; the final diagnoses included normal (n = 2), hyperinsulinism (n = 4), isolated GHD (n = 1), and isolated corticotropin deficiency (n = 1).
|
The median BG level at test termination was 45 mg/dL, with 23 children having BG levels of 40 mg/dL. Fasting duration was varied. A total of 50% of children fasted for <14.5 hours, and 4 children fasted only 10 minutes. Once BG levels were at <60 mg/dL, 50% of children became hypoglycemic within an hour.
GH at the Time of Hypoglycemia
GH was obtained at the time of hypoglycemia in 68 children. GH was not obtained because of octreotide treatment (n = 9) or previously normal GH levels at the time of hypoglycemia (n = 6) or during stimulation studies (n = 1).
A total of 70% of the children in whom GHD was not previously excluded had GH concentrations of <7.5 ng/mL at the time of hypoglycemia (specificity of a low GH for GHD = 30%). Only 1 child, however, had GHD. Moreover, GH levels of <7.5 ng/mL were not limited to specific diagnoses (Fig 1). Children with normal fasting adaptation, ketotic hypoglycemia, hyperinsulinism, fatty acid–oxidation defects, glycogen-storage disease, and dumping would be diagnosed as having GHD if based exclusively on GH levels at the time of hypoglycemia. In fact, despite limiting analyses to normal or ketotic children (n = 31), 80% had GH levels of <7.5 ng/mL. Two of 4 children who became hypoglycemic within 10 minutes of fasting had GH levels of <7.5 ng/mL. Nine of 16 children with BG levels of 40 mg/dL had GH levels of <7.5 ng/mL, and GH with a BG nadir at 40 mg/dL (11.3 ± 13.6 ng/mL) was not significantly different from GH when the BG nadir was at >40 mg/dL (5.6 ± 6.2 ng/mL) (P = .13).
|
40 mg/dL (P = .09). The percentage with GH levels of <7.5 ng/mL was not different between hypoglycemic and nonhypoglycemic groups (P = .5).
|
Cortisol concentrations of <18 µg/dL at the time of hypoglycemia were found in 61% of children (the specificity of a low cortisol level for adrenal insufficiency is 40%). Only 1 child had documented adrenal insufficiency (isolated corticotropin deficiency). Cortisol levels of <18 µg/dL were not limited to specific diagnoses (Fig 1). Inclusion of only normal or ketotic diagnoses reduced the percentage of children with cortisol concentrations of <18 µg/dL to 47%. Three of the 4 children who became hypoglycemic within 10 minutes of fasting had cortisol concentrations of <18 µg/dL. Eleven of 23 with BG levels of 40 mg/dL had cortisol concentrations of <18 µg/dL, and cortisol concentrations did not differ between the subset of hypoglycemic children with nadir BG levels of 40 mg/dL (17.9 ± 10.7) and those with nadir BG levels of >40 mg/dL (17.4 ± 10.5) (P = .85).
The impact of patient-specific factors on cortisol responses was examined (Table 2). Age was positively associated with cortisol (P = .006) even after exclusion of 2 outliers. This relationship persisted with restriction of data to those from children diagnosed as normal or ketotic. Congenital hyperinsulinism predicted lower cortisol but after adjustment for age, neither hyperinsulinism (P = .18) nor age (P = .07) was significant. For the entire group, duration of fasting was positively associated with cortisol. However, after adjustment for age only, the relationship between age and cortisol persisted (P = .04), likely reflecting the tendency toward longer fasting durations in older children because they frequently have normal fasting adaptation or ketotic hypoglycemia.
No relationship was found between GH and cortisol or with either of these outcomes and BG nadir or duration of BG levels <60 mg/dL. Three patients with GH levels of <7.5 ng/mL had GH obtained 30 to 70 minutes after hypoglycemia; all remained at <7.5 ng/mL. None had nadir BG levels of 40 mg/dL. In contrast, 2 of 4 children, in whom repeat sampling was performed 10 to 70 minutes after hypoglycemia, had cortisol levels of >18 µg/dL; 1 had a BG nadir at 40 mg/dL.
|
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
TOPABSTRACTINTRODUCTIONMETHODSRESULTSDISCUSSIONCONCLUSIONSREFERENCES |
|---|
Because most children did not undergo formal provocative studies to exclude either GHD or cortisol deficiency, the possibility exists that some children with values below the threshold defined as normal did, indeed, have deficiencies of these hormones. Misclassification is primarily a concern here for the children diagnosed with ketotic hypoglycemia because this "diagnosis" is made when other etiologies have been excluded. Because outside the neonatal period a child's growth provides an important clue to the diagnosis of GHD, GH results are interpreted in light of the child's growth. Growth was normal in the ketotic cohort except in 1 child in whom GHD was subsequently excluded through provocative studies. Normal growth renders GHD in this subset of children highly improbable. In addition, normal growth is reassuring in the context of a low cortisol level because corticotropin deficiency in the absence of GHD is rare. Adrenal insufficiency attributable to exogenous glucocorticoid is an obvious exception. Children on oral glucocorticoids were excluded from this study, and children treated with inhaled glucocorticoids underwent provocative studies to exclude adrenal insufficiency. Addison's disease is also unlikely to be missed, because children with this disease do not typically present with isolated hypoglycemia but with a constellation of findings and symptoms including hyperpigmentation, weight loss, nausea, electrolyte abnormalities, and hypotension.
A number of other limitations deserve mention. Because the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia is a major referral center for congenital hyperinsulinism, our sample represents a significant referral bias and is not a simple random sample of all children with hypoglycemia. In fact, many children with hypoglycemia attributable to GHD and/or adrenal insufficiency would never be referred to Children's Hospital of Philadelphia but would be diagnosed and treated locally. On the other hand, our normal and ketotic children are a representative sample of children with hypoglycemia because they were referred from the local community. Another issue is that GH and cortisol testing was not repeated for children who had had previously documented normal GH (n = 6) or cortisol (n = 3) levels at the time of hypoglycemia. Even with inclusion of these children, however, 65% of children would be misdiagnosed as having GHD and 58% would be misdiagnosed as being adrenally insufficient.
The basis for inadequate GH responses to hypoglycemia remains in question. The vagaries of GH-provocative studies are well known; 25% of children without GHD will have an abnormal GH response to a single GH-provocative study. In 1969, discrepant responses to arginine and insulin-provocative studies were recognized: 13 children with short stature had subnormal GH responses (<7 ng/mL) during an insulin-tolerance test, but 8 of them had normal responses to an arginine-provocative test performed on a separate day. One interpretation of these results is that hypothalamic sensitivity to different stimuli varies; perhaps for the children in the current study, hypoglycemia was not a potent stimulus. In addition, patients with recurrent hypoglycemia may be desensitized and unable to mount a GH response to hypoglycemia. The finding of GH levels at <7.5 ng/mL regardless of diagnosis argues against this desensitization as the sole explanation. Children who are considered normal and those who are ketotic have only occasional hypoglycemia but were just as likely to be misdiagnosed as having GHD as children with untreated congenital hyperinsulinism, a condition with which hypoglycemia is frequent.
Moreover, according to the consensus guidelines for the diagnosis of GHD published by the Growth Hormone Research Society in 2000, GHD in a neonate is suggested by a random GH level of <20 ng/mL.14 This threshold is much higher than the one adopted for this study, and applying this threshold to our neonates would have led to the diagnosis of GHD in all but 1. Other studies have suggested that a random GH level of <20 ng/mL may be found in neonates with GHD,21,22 consistent with our findings. Nonetheless, whereas GH concentrations are tonically elevated in the newborn period,23,24 a consistent association between age and GH at the time of hypoglycemia was not found in our population. In fact, no relationship was found between age and GH even in the children who did not become hypoglycemic, suggesting that fasting is not a potent stimulus for GH secretion. These findings echo those of Nitzan et al2 in 1 of the first studies of fasting adaptation in children: plasma GH obtained at the time of fasting ketosis was <7.5 ng/mL in 11 of 12 children and did not differ from GH values obtained in the well state. The findings in our study differ somewhat from reports of adequate GH in neonates with hyperinsulinism but inadequate responses in older children with various forms of hypoglycemia.25
With respect to age and cortisol, the pituitary-adrenal axis matures postnatally.26 In support of a developmental component is the finding that age was positively associated with the "critical sample" cortisol. However, a cortisol level of <18 µg/dL at the time of hypoglycemia was observed in both neonates and older children, consistent with a previous report.25 These findings suggest that blunted cortisol responses to hypoglycemia are not attributable solely to hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis immaturity.
In response to hypoglycemia induced by an insulin-tolerance test, cortisol and GH levels peak at 60 minutes but can peak as early as 30 and as late as 90 minutes.27 Thus, the possibility that hormonal responses are delayed and consequently not identified by the critical sample should be considered. This retrospective review was not designed to study the possibility of delayed GH and cortisol peaks. The finding that 2 of 3 children with cortisol concentrations of <18 µg/dL had values above this threshold in delayed samples is noteworthy. To resolve this specific issue, cortisol has been measured every 10 minutes for 50 minutes after hypoglycemia in neonates with hyperinsulinism.25 Cortisol concentrations at these delayed times remained below the defined normal threshold. Similarly, although some older children displayed enhanced responses 10 to 50 minutes after hypoglycemia, at least 4 had abnormal responses.22 Given that insulin-tolerance test data in children who showed peak cortisol levels may not occur for 60 to 90 minutes,27 additional evaluation of cortisol at these delayed times is warranted.
In contrast to the gradual onset of hypoglycemia that occurs with fasting in normal individuals, the insulin-tolerance test evokes a rapid decrease in BG. Thus, poor responses may reflect the prolonged BG decline before hypoglycemia.28 Nonetheless, children with hypoglycemia within 10 minutes of fasting still had GH and cortisol concentrations below the defined normal thresholds, and responses were not associated with fast duration.
Another difference between insulin-tolerance and fasting tests is BG nadir. A BG nadir of 40 mg/dL or a 50% decrease in BG from baseline is required during the insulin-tolerance test to provoke GH and cortisol responses, and maximal stimulation of cortisol during an insulin-tolerance test may only occur below 40 mg/dL.27 Because hypoglycemia has been defined as a BG level of 50 mg/dL, fasting tests were terminated once this threshold was met. BG levels were 40 mg/dL in 25% of the fasts, however, and BG nadir was not related to GH or cortisol response. In fact, inadequate GH and cortisol levels were present in 50% of children with BG levels at 40 mg/dL.
Inadequate responses in hyperinsulinism have been hypothesized to arise from (1) a direct effect of insulin on the hypothalamic-pituitary axis or (2) hyperinsulinism-causing mutations disrupting hypothalamic glucose-responsive cells.25 Given that nearly 50% of our study population had ketotic hypoglycemia or was normal, these responses are unlikely to be a significant contributor to suboptimal responses.
The recommendation to measure GH and cortisol as part of the fasting test is worth reviewing. Fasting tests are designed to evaluate whether the mechanisms responsible for fasting adaptation (glycogenolysis, gluconeogenesis, fatty acid oxidation, and ketogenesis) are intact. Although hormonal regulation of these pathways is critical, at the time of hypoglycemia, an insulin level is not sensitive for the diagnosis of hyperinsulinism,7 and GH and cortisol levels are not specific for deficiencies of these hormones. Whereas suppressed ketones and free fatty acids at hypoglycemia are indicative of hyperinsulinism, hypopituitarism in the neonate can mimic hyperinsulinism. A glucagon-stimulation test may help differentiate the two. In the older child, hypopituitarism resembles ketotic hypoglycemia (normal but shortened fasting adaptation). Thus, other assessments of GH sufficiency such as growth and growth factors are recommended in older children. The utility of measuring GH and cortisol during other times of the fasting test, such as early morning (when cortisol is known to peak) or an hour after sleep onset (when GH is known to peak) or after administration of glucagon (a known stimulant of GH secretion), is not known. In the absence of such data and a formal prospective study, measuring GH and cortisol levels at the time of hypoglycemia in children in whom sufficiency of these hormones is in question may still be helpful. GHD and adrenal insufficiency could be excluded in 30% to 40% of children by simply adding GH and cortisol measures to blood testing that is already being performed. This maneuver could prevent the need for more labor-intensive provocative studies in the subset of children for whom these diagnoses remain in question.
|
CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
TOPABSTRACTINTRODUCTIONMETHODSRESULTSDISCUSSIONCONCLUSIONSREFERENCES |
|---|
|
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
|
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Andrea Kelly, MD, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Division of Endocrinology/Diabetes, 8416 Main Building, 34th and Civic Center Boulevard, Philadelphia, PA 19104. E-mail: kellya{at}email.chop.edu
The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
| What's Known on This Subject Insulin excess and deficiencies of GH and cortisol are important causes of pediatric hypoglycemia. Measures of insulin, GH, and cortisol are recommended at the time of hypoglycemia for diagnostic purposes, but the utility of GH and cortisol levels have not been established.
|
| What This Study Adds Despite the recommendation that GH and cortisol be measured at the time of hypoglycemia, these measures are not reliable in diagnosing deficiencies of either of these hormones. This study establishes that fasting hypoglycemia is not an adequate diagnostic test for sufficiency of these hormones.
|
|
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
TOPABSTRACTINTRODUCTIONMETHODSRESULTSDISCUSSIONCONCLUSIONSREFERENCES |
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 |
||
|
||
Home | My Pediatrics | Journal Information | Current Issue | Past Issues | Subscriptions & Services | Contact Us Click here for faster international access © 2008 American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. |
||
|
||
