ARTICLE |
Departments of a Psychiatry
b Pediatrics, National Taiwan University Hospital and College of Medicine, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan
c Departments of Child Psychiatry and Pediatrics, Chang Gung Children's Hospital, Chang Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
METHODS. We enrolled 86 children 4 to 16 years old with virus-culture–confirmed enterovirus 71 infection and central nervous system involvement diagnosed 3 to 7 years before the study and 172 control subjects, matched for age, gender, and parents education levels. Their mothers and teachers were asked to report on possible attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder–related symptoms, and their mothers were asked to report on possible internalizing problems. All of the children previously infected with enterovirus 71 received intelligence tests.
RESULTS. Forty-two (49%) of the children previously infected with enterovirus 71 had had viral meningitis; 35 (41%) had severe central nervous system involvement, such as encephalitis, poliomyelitis-like syndrome, or encephalomyelitis; and 9 (10%) had cardiopulmonary failure and central nervous system involvement. The children previously infected with enterovirus 71 had higher scores than matched control subjects on teacher- and mother-rated scales of inattention, hyperactivity-impulsivity, oppositional symptoms, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder index. The rate of elevated attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder–related symptoms among children with enterovirus 71 central nervous system infection was 20%, whereas that rate among matched control subjects was only 3%. They also had more internalizing problems. Their verbal and performance IQs, as well as verbal comprehension indices, were significantly inversely correlated with symptoms of inattention, hyperactivity-impulsivity, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder index scores.
CONCLUSIONS. Enterovirus 71 central nervous system infection may affect long-term regulation of attention and emotion and cause hyperactivity-impulsivity in children.
Key Words: enterovirus 71 central nervous system attention deficit intelligence children
Abbreviations: EV71—enterovirus 71 CNS—central nervous system ADHD—attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder CSF—cerebrospinal fluid WISC-III—Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition CPRS-R:S—Conners Parent Rating Scale-Revised: Short Form CTRS-R:S—Conners Teacher Rating Scale-Revised: Short Form SDQ—Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire ICC—intraclass correlation PIQ—performance IQ VIQ—verbal IQ VCI—verbal comprehension index POI—perceptual organization FDI—freedom-from-distractibility index PSI—process speed index CI—confidence interval
There were large outbreaks of enterovirus 71 (EV71) infection resulting in dozens of deaths in Bulgaria in 1975,1 Hungary in 1978,2 and Malaysia in 19973 and in the largest and most severe EV71 epidemic to date in Taiwan in 1998.4 During the 1998 Taiwan EV71 epidemic, almost all of the patients with cardiopulmonary failure died.4,5 In 2000, to improve survival, we developed a disease management program that was adjusted depending on stage of EV71 infection.6,7 Although this program reduced acute mortality, long-term sequelae, particularly cognitive and mental problems, have remained a great concern.
Neurodevelopment and cognitive function can be affected by central nervous system (CNS) infections, such as tuberculosis meningitis,8 herpes simplex encephalitis,9,10 Japanese encephalitis,11,12 and several bacterial meningitis, including Haemophilus type b meningitis.13–16 Until our follow-up study of 142 children who had survived EV71 CNS infections in 2007, no study had focused on long-term sequelae in this population.17
Children with CNS infection may also suffer from inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity when the prefrontal lobe and its connection to striatum, the parietal lobe, cerebellum, and other circuits are involved18 and from emotional problems when the function of brain areas such as amygdala and nucleus accumbens is affected.19 The likelihood of developing attention deficit is also thought to be increased in children with acquired hearing loss after bacterial meningitis or congenital rubella.20
Although there is strong evidence suggesting that genetic factors play a significant role in the development of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD),21 biological adversity, such as trauma, metabolic derangement, toxin exposure, and CNS infection, may also cause ADHD in some children.8,22 However, few studies have systemically and prospectively examined the consequence of CNS infection on the controls of attention, activity, and impulsivity.8,14,15 Wait et al8 have reported increased rates of ADHD among 21 children who had survived tuberculosis meningitis. However, to the best of our knowledge, no longitudinal study has specifically investigated ADHD-related symptoms and emotional problems as sequelae of EV71 CNS infection. To do this, we prospectively followed up a cohort of children with EV71 CNS infection to assess their ADHD symptoms and other emotional/behavioral problems, compared the prevalence of elevated ADHD-related symptoms in children previously affected by EV71 CNS infection with that of matched control children, and correlated the intellectual factors with ADHD-related symptoms.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
During this study period, 621 patients with EV71 were identified, 534 at Chang Gung Children's Hospital and 87 at National Taiwan University Hospital. A total of 232 had CNS involvement. They were categorized into 3 groups: (1) case subjects with mild CNS involvement, that is, aseptic meningitis; (2) case subjects with severe CNS involvement, such as encephalitis, poliomyelitis-like syndrome, or encephalomyelitis; and (3) case subjects with cardiopulmonary failure after CNS involvement. Aseptic meningitis was defined as having headache, irritability, and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pleocytosis (>5 x 106 leukocytes per L) without an altered level of consciousness or focal signs. Encephalitis was defined as having an altered level of consciousness plus CSF pleocytosis, poliomyelitis-like syndrome as having acute limb weakness and decreased reflex and muscle strength, and encephalomyelitis as having the occurrence of both encephalitis and poliomyelitis-like syndrome. Cardiopulmonary failure was defined as pulmonary edema and/or hemorrhage with decreased ejection fraction of the left ventricle, necessitating inotropic agent support as assessed by echocardiography.
Thirty-nine (16.8%) of these 232 patients died as a result of cardiopulmonary failure induced by brainstem encephalitis during acute illness or either aspiration pneumonia or sepsis during the convalescent stage. Of the remaining 193 patients with CNS involvement (172 at Chang Gung Children's Hospital and 21 at National Taiwan University Hospital), 22 refused the assessment and 29 could not be located, leaving 142 to be enrolled for the assessment of neurodevelopment and cognition, including the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III).17 A total of 107 (aged
4) of the 142 patients with CNS involvement were eligible for the assessment of intelligence and emotional or behavioral problems. Of these 107 children, 21 refused the assessment of ADHD-related symptoms, whereas 86 (80.4%) consented to this study and completed the assessments. There were no significant differences in clinical severity or demographics between the 86 patients whom we assessed for ADHD-related symptoms and the 21 patients whom we did not assess (P = .19 for clinical severity, P = .13 for age of onset, and P = .98 for gender). The mean ± SD interval between the assessment of neurodevelopment/cognition and assessment of ADHD-related symptoms was 1.23 ± 0.85 years (range: 0.00–2.64 years).
Community-Based Controls
Each case subject was matched with 2 neighborhood or school control subjects for age, gender, school performance, and parental educational levels. Children with any history of developmental delay or use of special educational services and children with superior academic performance were excluded from the control group. The final sample consisted of 86 case subject 4 to 16 years old (51 boys and 35 girls) and 172 matched control subject (Table 1).
|
The Chinese versions of the CPRS-R:S and CTRS-R:S have been found to be reliable and valid instruments for measuring ADHD-related symptoms in Taiwan.26 This study used cutoff values of 20 and 17 for the ADHD index of the Chinese CPRS-R:S and CTRS-R:S, respectively, to define a case subject as potentially having ADHD.26 A t score >70 (2 SDs greater than mean score) was also used to define a case subject as potentially having ADHD.
Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire
The Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ), a 25-item behavioral screening questionnaire, is designed to assess a broader area of various behaviors in children and adolescents. Each item is rated on a 3-point scale (0, not true; 1, somewhat true; 3, certainly true).27 The parent form of the Chinese SDQ includes 4 subscales: conduct problem, inattention/hyperactivity, prosocial, and internalizing.28 It has been found to have good test-retest reliability (intraclass correlations [ICCs]) and internal consistency (Cronbach's
) for the prosocial subscale (ICC = 0.90;
= .74) and the internalizing subscale (ICC = 0.85;
= .88), which were used in this study.
Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition
In this study, a child psychologist assessed each child individually by using the WISC-III.29 The WISC-III is composed of 13 subtests to assess cognitive ability by performance IQ (PIQ) and verbal IQ (VIQ). Four factorially derived composite subscales have been created: (1) verbal comprehension index (VCI) (information, similarities, vocabulary, and comprehension); (2) perceptual organization index (POI) (picture completion, picture arrangement, block design, and object assembly); (3) freedom-from-distractibility index (FDI; arithmetic and digit span); and (4) process speed index (PSI) (coding and symbol search).30
Laboratory Data
All of the patient laboratory data were collected during patient hospitalization for treatment of EV71 infection and included glucose, protein, lactate, and white blood cell count (including neutrophils, lymphocytes, and monocytes) in the CSF. We also used estimations of the severity of CNS involvement and findings from electroencephalogram, CNS computed tomography, and CNS MRI during hospitalization and follow-up.
Procedures
The institutional review board of National Taiwan University Hospital approved this clinical study. The child subjects and their parents and teachers received a comprehensive explanation of the purpose and procedure of this study, as well as reassurance of confidentiality. They were informed that participation in this study was completely voluntary and that nonparticipation would not influence their treatment. Written informed consent for all of the enrollees was obtained from their parents. Their parents answered the Chinese CPRS-R:S and SDQ either at the clinic or at home, and their teachers answered the CTRS-R:S at school.
Statistical Analysis
Alpha value was preselected at the level of P < .05. The descriptive results were displayed as frequency and percentage for categorical variables; for continuous variables, results were displayed as mean and SD. To conduct a matched case-control analysis for the continuous variables, we used the linear multilevel model to compare the mean scores and t scores of subscales of the CPRS-R:S, CTRS-R:S, and SDQ between the case and control groups. The t score was defined by multiplying the z score by 10 and adding 50 with a mean of 50 and an SD of 10 [t score = (z score x 10) + 50]. The effect sizes (standardized difference between 2 means) were further computed using Cohen's d.31 We defined small, medium, and large effect sizes as Cohen's d 0.25 to 0.5, 0.5 to 0.75, and >0.75, respectively. We used conditional logistic regression to compare the prevalence rate of children with elevated ADHD-related symptoms and to calculate the odds ratio and 95% confidence interval (CI). Multiple linear regression was used to correlate the cognitive components with the severity of ADHD-related symptoms among affected children. All of the statistical operations were performed by using SAS 9.1 (SAS Institute, Inc, Cary, NC).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
ADHD-Related and Internalizing Symptoms
The children with EV71 CNS infection were found 4 to 5 years later after initial diagnosis to have significantly higher sum scores and t scores on the 4 subscales and total scale of the CPRS-R:S and CTRS-R:S than control subjects. The effect sizes (Cohen's d) varied from small (0.28 for the oppositional subscale of the CPRS-R:S) to large (0.78 for the ADHD index of the CTRS-R:S). In addition, the study population of EV71 case subjects with CNS involvement had a higher score on screening for internalizing problems with small effect size (Table 2). There was no difference in prosocial behaviors.
|
|
|
Neither the clinical severity nor laboratory data collected during the hospitalization for EV71 CNS infection predicted ADHD symptoms (all P > .05). Moreover, we did not find a significant association between age of EV71 infection and severity of ADHD-related symptoms (P = .13–.88).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our finding of increased severity of ADHD symptoms in children with EV71 CNS infection suggests that the infection may involve the prefronto-striatum-subcortical area of the brain or another area related to the core symptoms of ADHD8,18 and that this involvement may not be identified by anatomic changes detected by the kind of structural brain imaging that we used in this study but by the functional changes using the neuropsychological assessment. This study only used mother and teacher reports of standardized behavioral measures. Additional studies using neuropsychological assessment can be conducted to further confirm our findings of increased ADHD symptoms in these children.
We were surprised that we did not find a correlation between age of EV71 infection, any laboratory data, or the severity of CNS involvement and the severity of ADHD-related symptoms among children with EV71 CNS infection. However, we found that intelligence scales were correlated with the severity of ADHD symptoms rather than oppositional defiant symptoms. Consistent with literature, the FDI is related to symptoms of inattention.33 Previous studies, however, do not support our finding that the VCI can predict ADHD-related symptoms.34 Our finding suggests that the ADHD-related symptoms associated with CNS infection may have different behavioral and cognitive manifestations and that EV71 CNS infection may affect a brain area involving both ADHD-related symptoms and verbal comprehension.
We found some evidence of an association between EV71 CNS involvement and increased internalizing symptoms. This finding might be explained by CNS involvement in the brain areas related to emotional regulation,19 concurrence with anxiety/depression in children with ADHD,35 or post-CNS infection adjustment problems. Although our evidence is weak, and more detailed evaluation to confirm the results of increased internalizing symptoms is needed, some attention should be paid to the possible increase in anxiety/depressive symptoms in these children.
This study is the first to investigate the risk for ADHD in a prospective follow-up matched case-control study of children after EV71 CNS infection with a large sample size and use of standardized measures. However, it has some limitations. First, the average age of onset of EV71 CNS infection is
2.5 years old, and there is no suitable behavioral measure for ADHD for children at such young ages. Therefore, we were unable to assess ADHD symptoms before the onset of EV71 CNS infection, which also limited our ability to clearly establish a causal link between the CNS infection and ADHD symptoms. However, because there is no literature showing ADHD as a risk factor for EV71 infection, it can be assumed that children with EV71 infection were not selected from the population at risk of ADHD and that EV71 CNS infection predicted increased ADHD-related symptoms, as well as emotional symptoms in this study. Second, we did not do any neuropsychological studies, which could have validated our behavioral-based findings that EV71 CNS infection may cause the functional impairment in the control of attention, motor, and impulse. Third, because we did not collect information on academic performance, we were unable to test whether EV71 CNS infection, such as H influenzae type B,36 negatively impacts on achievement and cognitive dysfunction in normally intelligent children. Future studies should be conducted using a psychiatric interview to confirm the diagnosis of ADHD and its comorbid mental disorders.
Our findings suggest that, although only some of the children with EV71 CNS infection in this study had obvious ADHD symptoms, it would be advisable to assess symptoms of ADHD regardless of the extent of brain involvement or intelligence test scores, because ADHD symptoms may influence school performance, peer relationships, and at-home behaviors.32,35,37 Early identification of ADHD symptoms may make possible early parental counseling/training and educational intervention and, thus, possibly offset adjustment problems at school and in society and family dysfunction.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Luan-Yin Chang, MD, PhD, National Taiwan University Hospital, Department of Pediatrics, College of Medicine, National Taiwan University, 7 Chung-Shan South Rd, Taipei 100, Taiwan. E-mail: ly7077{at}tpts6.seed.net.tw
The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
This trial has been registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov (identifier NCT00172393).
| What's Known on This Subject Neurodevelopment and cognitive function can be affected by CNS infections such as tuberculosis meningitis, herpes simplex encephalitis, Japanese encephalitis, and several bacterial meningitis infections including Haemophilus type b meningitis.
|
| What This Study Adds EV71 CNS infection may affect long-term regulation of attention and emotion and cause hyperactivity-impulsivity in children.
|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. G. Millichap ADHD Symptoms as a Sequelae of Enterovirus 71 CNS Infection AAP Grand Rounds, November 1, 2008; 20(5): 52 - 53. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||