ARTICLE |
a Division of Pediatric Dentistry, College of Dental Medicine
b Department of Biostatistics, Mailman School of Public Health
c Division of Periodontics, College of Dental Medicine
d Department of Pediatric-Endocrinology, Naomi Berrie Diabetes Center
e Department of Medicine-Endocrinology, Naomi Berrie Diabetes Center
f Dean, College of Dental Medicine, Columbia University Medical Center, New York, New York
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
METHODS. Tooth eruption status was assessed for 270 children with diabetes and 320 control children without diabetes. Data on important diabetes-related variables were collected. Analyses were performed using logistic regression models.
RESULTS. Children with diabetes exhibited accelerated tooth eruption in the late mixed dentition period (10–14 years of age) compared to healthy children. For both case patients and control subjects the odds of a tooth being in an advanced eruptive stage were significantly higher among girls than boys. There was also a trend associating gingival inflammation with expedited tooth eruption in both groups. No association was found between the odds of a tooth being in an advanced stage of eruption and hemoglobin A1c or duration of diabetes. Patients with higher body mass index percentile demonstrated statistically higher odds for accelerated tooth eruption, but the association was not clinically significant.
CONCLUSIONS. Children with diabetes exhibit accelerated tooth eruption. Future studies need to ascertain the role of such aberrations in dental development and complications such as malocclusion, impaired oral hygiene, and periodontal disease. The standards of care for children with diabetes should include screening and referral programs aimed at oral health promotion and disease prevention.
Key Words: children diabetes tooth eruption dental development oral health
Abbreviations: HbA1c—hemoglobin A1c OR—odds ratio
Dental eruption is the gradual movement of a tooth from its formative position in the osseous crypt through alveolar bone and into functional occlusion in the oral cavity. Tooth emergence is the first appearance of a tooth in the mouth and is often synonymous with eruption. Although many theories have been presented, specific mechanisms that are responsible for tooth eruption remain largely unknown. Several factors ranging from molecular signaling to osteoclastic activity, root development, nutrition, and hormonal influences have been implicated.1,2 Disturbances in dental development (ie, timing or sequence of eruption) may contribute to a chain of complications such as malocclusion, crowding, impaired oral hygiene, periodontal disease, and associated dental and orthodontic treatment needs.3–10
The developing occlusion during the mixed dentition period (ages 6–14 years) is characterized by a specific chronologic sequence of deciduous tooth exfoliation and concurrent permanent tooth eruption.11 These events are shown to be influenced by gender, race, and ethnicity but are unaccounted for in established dental growth and development charts.10,12 Hence, deviations >6 months from these accepted norms are not unusual but may indicate an underlying local or metabolic disturbance,10 as in the case of diabetes mellitus.
Although the role of hyperglycemia-associated periodontal destruction is well documented in the medical and dental literature,13 very little and dated information is available about the effects of diabetes on tooth eruption. Studies on this subject by Adler et al14 and Bohátka et al15 in 1973 reported accelerated dental development in children who were younger than 11.5 years and had diabetes, whereas older children with diabetes exhibited a delay in dental development. These findings were attributed to local and systemic effects of the disease and possibly a "prediabetic state" influencing tooth eruption. These studies were in agreement with White,16 who had previously observed a similar "biphasic" effect of the diabetic state on dental development. In contrast, Ziskin et al17 reported a small and nonsignificant influence of diabetes on dental development.
The intention of this study was to examine tooth eruption patterns in children with and without diabetes. In addition, the effects of gingival inflammation, hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c), duration of diabetes, and BMI percentile on dental development were studied.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Study Population
The total cohort in this study was 700 children in the age range of 6 to 18 years (350 patients with diabetes and 350 healthy control subjects). Of this total, data from 590 children in the mixed dentition stage, ages 6 to 14 years, were used for these analyses. Children in both groups were excluded when they were undergoing active orthodontic therapy. This subcohort consisted of 270 patients with diabetes, examined at the Naomi Berrie Diabetes Center at Columbia University Medical Center, and 320 children who did not have diabetes and belonged to the same age group examined at the Columbia University College of Dental Medicine.
Oral Examination Protocol
Participants and/or guardians responded to questions related to medical and dental history. All dental measurements were performed by 3 calibrated examiners.
All teeth were evaluated and categorized into 1 of 6 stages of eruption. Specific criteria describing each stage appear in Table 1 and were derived from standard dental development data.18 Stage 1 of eruption was assigned to unerupted permanent teeth that had their primary tooth predecessor present. Stage 2 of eruption was assigned to unerupted permanent teeth with an overlying primary tooth that was exfoliating (mobile). Stage 3 corresponded to an unerupted permanent tooth that had shed its overlying primary tooth. Stage 4 was assigned to permanent teeth that had recently emerged with one fifth of the clinical crown (or cusp tips) visible. Stage 5 was recorded for permanent teeth that were partially erupted and exhibited more than one fifth of their clinical crown but were not yet in occlusion. Stage 6 was assigned to permanent teeth that were fully erupted and/or in occlusion.
|
Diabetes-related Variables
The information collected from medical charts included type of diabetes and duration (years since diagnosis); insulin regimen (multiple daily insulin injections or continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion) and/or oral hypoglycemic medications; mean HbA1c results during the 2-year period preceding inclusion in the study; and BMI percentile, computed using a SAS (SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC) program for Centers for Disease Control and Prevention growth charts.
Data and Statistical Analyses
Each stage of tooth eruption was classified as 1 through 6 (Table 1). Five dichotomized versions of the eruption stages were considered (see Tables 2 and 3). For each dichotomized version, a logistic regression model was used to compare case patients and control subjects. The analysis was adjusted for age, gender, ethnicity, dental examiner, and proportion of bleeding sites. For case patients, the association between the eruption process and diabetes-related variables such as mean HbA1c, BMI percentile, and duration of diabetes was also studied using logistic regression models. In all of the analyses, generalized estimating equation method was used in the parameter estimations to account for correlations among teeth within a patient.
|
|
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
85% (overweight and at risk for overweight) was 101 (38%).
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
These findings suggest a dual complement of mechanisms influencing the intra- and extra-alveolar phases of eruption, the latter being modified in diabetes. Whereas the intra-alveolar phase of eruption is shown to be primarily governed by molecular signals generated by the dental follicle proper, extra-alveolar eruption seems to depend more on root development and bone apposition in the apical region of the erupting tooth.21,22 Although the exact mechanisms responsible for tooth eruption remain unclear, recent findings in murine models demonstrated enhanced tooth eruption by colony-stimulating factor-1, which upregulates the immunoreactivity of bone marrow mononuclear cells to growth hormone receptor and insulin-like growth factor-I.23
Although the growth hormone receptor–insulin-like growth factor-1 mechanism may be modified and account for the effects of diabetes on the developing occlusion, certain local effects of the disease may play a role as well. Gingival inflammation was found to be greater among case patients and correlated with expedited eruption, although the association did not reach statistical significance. This exaggerated inflammatory response to bacterial plaque, a hallmark of hyperglycemia-associated periodontal disease, may contribute to localized osseous changes, resulting in diminished quality and quantity of surrounding bone. It is interesting that in the premolar region, every millimeter of bone overlying the erupting tooth bud corresponds to 4 to 5 months of eruption time (ie, time taken for a premolar to traverse through 1 mm of bone)24; therefore, even the slightest bone loss secondary to periodontal infection would shorten the distance to eruption, thereby accelerating tooth emergence.
More extensive bone loss would contribute to premature loss of the primary tooth, an effect recognized in children with diabetes25; however, no differences in the primary exfoliation status were seen between case patients and control subjects. Radiographic assessments confirming alveolar changes in the primary dentition were not feasible in this study. Conventional clinical measurements of attachment loss are unreliable in the primary periodontium, especially during tooth exfoliation, and were not performed.
Dental decay in the primary dentition was assessed using the dfs caries index (diseased, filled surfaces—primary teeth). The control group exhibited significantly more dental caries in the primary dentition than the case group (OR: 0.30; P < .001). Although our analyses adjusted for dental caries, premature tooth loss secondary to dental decay was not a confounding variable in this study because, as reported already, no differences in primary tooth exfoliation status were noted.
The association of accelerated eruption with age in case patients was noteworthy. Children with diabetes in the late mixed dentition period (ages 10–14) had a higher propensity for advanced tooth eruption than their counterparts without diabetes (Table 3). This dynamic period, marked by puberty and growth, may potentiate the systemic effects of diabetes on expedited dental development. No changes in tooth eruption were seen in the early mixed dentition group (ages 6–10); however, children in the control group were older (10.37 ± 1.97 vs 9.96 ± 2.57). This difference of nearly 4 to 5 months in mean age would further amplify overall eruption time among case patients across all stages of eruption. There were also significant ethnic differences in our sample, with the control group being predominantly Hispanic and the case patents being non-Hispanic. Limited data from previous studies comparing primary dental development in these groups indicated mild acceleration among Hispanic children or no significant differences at all.26,27 All of our regression analyses adjusted for ethnicity and age, although accelerated eruption among Hispanic children would further support our findings.
An additional, fully adjusted formal logistic regression analysis that focused on the sequence of eruption was done. The results revealed statistically significant differences between case patients and control subjects (OR: 1.90; P = .008); however, this outcome is subject to interpretation given the limitations of our cross-sectional study design and warrants additional investigation.
The general, physical growth and development in children with diabetes may also display altered trends. Conflicting reports of increased height at diagnosis in children with type 1 diabetes compared with their peers without diabetes have been published.28,29 Although these children will have normal final heights, some evidence of suboptimal peripubertal growth exists and is not correlated with their metabolic control.30 It is interesting that in this study, case patents with higher height percentiles exhibited higher odds for expedited tooth eruption (OR: 1.007–1.008; P < .05 for all; data not shown). Furthermore, the expedited eruption among case patients with higher height percentile was more pronounced in the older group (OR: 1.014–1.019; P < .001 for all) than the younger group (OR: 1.004–1.005, P < .05 for all).
Last, there was no correlation between eruption disturbances and other diabetes-related parameters such as HbA1c, height, and duration of disease, although a weak association was seen between accelerated eruption and increased BMI percentile. A recent study confirmed this association,31 further suggesting the influence of a prediabetic and "proinflammatory" state on dental development that may precede the onset of clinical parameters of diabetes.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We thank Dr Sid Tucker, Richard Buchsbaum, Johanne Reynoso, and Dr Kenia Martinez for valuable contributions.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Shantanu Lal, DDS, Predoctoral Programs, Division of Pediatric Dentistry, Columbia University College of Dental Medicine, P&S 3-454c, 630W 168th St, New York, NY 10032. E-mail: sl784{at}columbia.edu
The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
| What's Known on This Subject Very limited and dated information is available on the effects of diabetes on dental development in children. Conflicting reports from previous studies, conducted nearly 35 years ago, have reported both delayed and accelerated tooth eruption using data from small cohorts.
|
| What This Study Adds This study clearly establishes the effects of diabetes mellitus on tooth eruption. In addition, several dental markers, BMI, physical growth and diabetes-related variables were studied. The findings reported derive from the largest cohort to date.
|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||