ARTICLE |
a Departments of Pediatrics
d Neurology and Biochemistry, Rush Children's Hospital at Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, Illinois
b Center for Craniofacial and Dental Genetics, Division of Oral Biology
f Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, School of Dental Medicine
e Department of Human Genetics, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
c Department of Human Genetics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
METHODS. Dermatoglyphic pattern type frequency, left/right symmetry, and genotype/phenotype correlation were assessed for 33 individuals with PHOX2B-confirmed congenital central hypoventilation syndrome and compared with published control data.
RESULTS. Dermatoglyphic pattern type frequencies were altered in congenital central hypoventilation syndrome cases versus controls. In particular, there was an increase of arches in females and ulnar loops in males, with the largest differences for the left hand and for individuals with both congenital central hypoventilation syndrome and Hirschsprung disease. Dissimilarity scores between the congenital central hypoventilation syndrome and congenital central hypoventilation syndrome + Hirschsprung disease cases were not significantly different, nor were dissimilarity scores between all of the female and all of the male cases. No significant association was found between the number of polyalanine repeats in the PHOX2B genotypic category and dermatoglyphic pattern frequencies in the congenital central hypoventilation syndrome study groups.
CONCLUSIONS. These results represent the first report describing specific dermatoglyphic patterning in congenital central hypoventilation syndrome and suggest a relationship between PHOX2B and the expression of dermatoglyphic pattern types. An expanded congenital central hypoventilation syndrome data set to include the full spectrum of PHOX2B mutations is necessary to further delineate the role of PHOX2B in dermatoglyphic patterning.
Key Words: dermatoglyphics PHOX2B gene Hirschsprung disease
Abbreviations: CCHScongenital central hypoventilation syndrome ANSautonomic nervous system HDHirschsprung disease SIDSsudden infant death syndrome
Children with congenital central hypoventilation syndrome (CCHS) characteristically present in the neonatal period with alveolar hypoventilation "in the absence of primary neuromuscular, lung, or cardiac disease, or an identifiable brainstem lesion."1 They demonstrate attenuated/absent responses to hypoxemia and hypercarbia, and related evidence of autonomic nervous system (ANS) dysfunction/dysregulation that may include Hirschsprung disease (HD) and/or tumors of neural crest origin.1 Children with CCHS are heterozygous for a polyalanine expansion mutation in the paired-like homeobox (PHOX)2B gene,27 although a subset of patients has unique mutations in PHOX2B. Recently, a characteristic facial phenotype in CCHS has been described,8 with a pattern compatible with the developmental expression of PHOX2B. Long thought to be a rare disorder, CCHS is being diagnosed with increased frequency, since genetic testing for the PHOX2B mutation became clinically available in 2003.2 As a result, general pediatricians may be caring for affected children in their practice.
The PHOX2B gene encodes a highly conserved homeobox domain transcription factor3 with an early embryologic action as a transcriptional activator in the promotion of pan-neuronal differentiation in the ANS and a separate role wherein it represses expression of inhibitors of neurogenesis.913 PHOX2B is considered to regulate the sympathetic noradrenergic phenotype in vertebrates.10,14 Sympathetic innervation has been hypothesized to affect the development of dermatoglyphic pattern types in primates, including humans,15,16 with dermatoglyphics defined as the study of the morphology and distribution of ridged skin patterns on the palmar surface of the hands and feet. We sought to more fully characterize the phenotype of CCHS by evaluating dermatoglyphics, an accessible phenotypic measure of embryologic development. We hypothesized that individuals with PHOX2B-confirmed CCHS would have characteristic dermatoglyphic patterning and that these pattern differences would vary with the clinical severity of CCHS (characterized by the presence or absence of HD) and the disease-defining PHOX2B genotype.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Printing Technique and Dermatoglyphic Protocol
Fingerprints were obtained using a standard inkless technique18 using INFA-PRINT Inkless Imprint Wipes (Kansas City, MO). Three trained raters (E.S.T., N.M.S., D.E.W-M.) independently categorized the dermatoglyphic prints as arch, ulnar loop, radial loop, or whorl.19 Figure 1 provides examples of each of these print types. Data sets were then merged, and any disagreements were reevaluated. Determination was made of each pattern frequency by specific study group (expressed as percentage of total digits evaluated in the group), by identification of subjects who are arch positive (
1 arch on either hand), and by identification of subjects with
4 arches. These 3 determinations were conducted to allow for comparison to the control group data, as well as to the literature.
|
2 analysis was used to compare pattern frequencies for cases versus published control data,17 grouped by CCHS status (all CCHS, isolated CCHS, or CCHS + HD), then stratified for gender and hand (left or right). Asymmetry was measured by dissimilarity scores, which were calculated by comparing prints on the paired homologous fingers of the left and right hands (eg, left index finger compared with right index finger). Paired fingers with dissimilar dermatoglyphic pattern types were given a score of 1, whereas paired fingers with the same pattern types were given a score of 0. Scores were then summed across all 5 finger pairs, thus, dissimilarity scores may range from 0 (having no dissimilarity) to 5 (having all 5 pairs of fingers dissimilar). The results were compared using the Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test. In addition, PHOX2B repeat number was compared with frequency of pattern type using linear regression with the continuous repeat number and logistic regression with repeat number divided into 2 categories: <29 repeats and
30 repeats. Dissimilarity scores were also compared between the 2 categories of PHOX2B repeat number using a Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test.20 Results were considered significant if P < .05. | RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
1 digital arch) was seen in 30% of cases, with 60% of the arch-positive cases being female. Multiple arches (
4, no case had 3 arches) were identified in 12.1% of cases, with 75% of these being female.
Isolated CCHS
Arch positivity was seen in 25% of cases, with 57.1% of the arch-positive cases being female. Multiple arches were identified in 7.1% of cases, with 50% of these being female.
CCHS+HD
Female cases had a higher arch frequency versus male cases (both hands: 40.0 vs 0, P = .002; left hand: 40.0 vs 0, P = .025; right hand: 40.0 vs 0, P = .025). Arch positivity was seen in 60% of cases, with 66.7% of the arch-positive cases being female. Multiple arches were identified in 40% of cases, with 100% of these being female.
Dissimilarity Scores
Dissimilarity scores between the CCHS and CCHS + HD cases were not different (1.11 and 0.75, respectively), nor were dissimilarity scores between all of the female cases and all of the male cases (mean: 1.0 and 1.13, respectively). Control values for dissimilarity scores are unavailable, thus, no comparisons to controls could be made.
Genotype/Phenotype Correlation
No significant association was found by linear regression or by logistic regression between the PHOX2B genotypic category (<29 polyalanine repeats versus
30 polyalanine repeats on the affected allele) and dermatoglyphic pattern frequencies in the CCHS study groups (all CCHS cases, isolated CCHS, and CCHS + HD).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
30 polyalanine repeats). Likewise, no significant association was found between the PHOX2B genotypic category and dermatoglyphic pattern frequencies.
Dermatoglyphics have been studied in children with isolated constipation and isolated HD,2125 both symptoms compatible with ANS dysregulation/dysfunction and both often reported among children with CCHS.26 Gottlieb and Schuster21 reported arch positivity in 53% of patients and
4 arches in 27% of patients with early onset constipation (<10 years of age) (vs 13% and 2% of controls, respectively). Staiano et al22 demonstrated arch positivity in 38% of patients with constipation (vs 11% of controls) but no relationship between HD and digital arches. Drongowski and Coran23 identified arch positivity in 33% of cases with functional chronic constipation, 32% of cases with anatomic chronic constipation (including HD), and 30% of control cases with inguinal hernia. Jackson et al24 demonstrated arch positivity in 13% of constipated cases (vs 7% of controls). Goshima et al25 demonstrated arch positivity in 28% of constipated patients (vs 24% of controls). The published results describing arch positivity in constipated patients are in keeping with our current results in children with CCHS. The published results describing arch positivity in patients with HD, however, are distinctly different from our findings in children with CCHS + HD. These differences may be because of an intrinsic difference in the etiology and genetic basis of idiopathic HD versus syndromic HD.27 Taken together, these findings extend the understanding of a relationship between dermatoglyphic patterning and functional/anatomic bowel disease, conditions that fall within the rubric of ANS dysregulation and will be encountered by the general care pediatrician.
The embryologic timing of the ridge pattern formation, between weeks 10 and 24 postfertilization, is associated with the type of dermatoglyphic pattern development. Early ridge formation is associated with whorls, late formation with arches, and intermediate formation with loops. Clinical syndromes that have arrested embryologic development and decreased developmental maturation tend to have more arches and fewer whorls.28 For example, an increase in arch and ulnar loop frequency and a decrease in whorl frequency have been reported in nonsyndromic female Filipinos with cleft lip and/or cleft palate.29 Likewise, an increased incidence of arches30,31 and cleft lip and/or cleft palate32 has been reported in fetal hydantoin syndrome. Interestingly, female white sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) victims have an increased arch frequency compared with the same control population we used.33 Furthermore, male SIDS infants with dysmorphic features or anatomic anomalies presented with more ulnar loops and fewer whorls, not dissimilar to the most affected cases with CCHS + HD in our study. Recognizing that children with CCHS have ANS dysregulation and that infants who have succumbed to SIDS also have ANS dysregulation,3442 the finding of altered dermatoglyphic patterning in CCHS and SIDS supports a relationship between the developing systems that regulate dermatoglyphics and altered embryologic development of the ANS. These interrelationships indicate that the study of dermatoglyphics provides an accessible means by which the pediatrician can probe the origin of complex diseases.
Although dermatoglyphic formation has been associated with many factors, including skeletal growth,27 and volar pad topography,43,44 most interesting for the current study is that dermatoglyphic fingerprint patterns have been associated with the sympathetic innervation of the hand.15,16 We anticipate that the PHOX2B gene, as a regulator of the sympathetic noradrenergic phenotype in vertebrates,10,14 has a role in the determination of dermatoglyphic patterning, just as it has a role in the embryologic development of the enteric nervous system.10,45,46 This possibility is supported by our previous observation that 43% of children with CCHS have severe constipation, 21% of children with CCHS have HD,26 and our current finding of an increased arch and ulnar loop frequency that is highest among children with PHOX2B-confirmed CCHS + HD. Our results here provide tentative support for the hypothesis that polyalanine expansion mutations in PHOX2B impact dermatoglyphic pattern formation, in addition to gut motility.
Also of interest is the noted gender difference in the pattern frequency analysis. These differences are notable in light of the well-recognized male predominance of isolated HD.47 Recently, a common noncoding RET variant mutation within a conserved enhancer-like sequence has been identified as a contributing factor to the differences in susceptibility to HD by gender.48 Most likely, the gender differences in frequency distribution of dermatoglyphics in CCHS are a result of the multifactorial inheritance of dermatoglyphic patterns, similar to HD. This is a more likely explanation for gender variation than a direct influence of the PHOX2B mutation, because we are unaware of other identified gender differences in the CCHS phenotype.
We have identified 2 potential limitations of this study. First, we relied on the published control data set17 including 720 white children aged 7 years (360 females) rather than recruit individual age-matched controls. This technique was used because it represents a better approximation of the population norms than a smaller set of matched controls. Furthermore, dermatoglyphic patterns do not change during an individual's postnatal life, unlike other phenotypic features, such as facial characteristics, which have the potential to change with increasing age. Because of the data set used, we were not able to compare
1 or
3 to 4 arches with controls, which would have been useful in comparing our results with existing literature. Likewise, dermatoglyphic raters were not blinded to case versus control group, although it should be noted that the raters were blinded within CCHS clinical grouping. The second limitation is the small sample size of CCHS subjects. This may have reduced the ability to generalize our findings, but also may have contributed to the lack of significance when evaluated by PHOX2B genotype. In particular, the limited number of cases with higher numbers of polyalanine repeats (only 5 cases with 30 to 33 repeats) may have precluded detection of a significant correlation between the number of polyalanine repeats and frequencies of dermatoglyphic patterns.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We thank Kelly Dearing Roollen and Indentiseal/Infra-Print for their gracious donation of the inkless fingerprinting materials to make this study possible. We also thank Foster Lewin for the preparation of the DNA, Chinton Desai and Ronak Lahkia who assisted with PCR assays, and the children with CCHS who graciously shared their DNA and their fingerprints.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Debra E. Weese-Mayer, MD, Rush University, Pediatric Respiratory Medicine at Rush Children's Hospital, 1653 West Congress Parkway, Chicago, IL 60612. E-mail: Debra_E_Weese-Mayer{at}rsh.net
The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||