a Department of Radiology, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts
b Child Development Unit, Department of Pediatrics, University Children's Hospital, Geneva, Switzerland
c Psychiatry
e Radiology
f Neurology, Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts
d Department of Pediatrics, Washington University, St Louis, Missouri
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
METHODS. Twenty-three preterm infants appropriate for gestational age without magnetic resonancevisible brain injury underwent MRI twice at 32 and at 42 weeks postmenstrual age. Fifteen term infants were scanned 2 weeks after birth. Brain tissue classification and parcellation were conducted to allow comparison of regional brain tissue volumes. Longitudinal brain growth was assessed from preterm infants serial scans.
RESULTS. At 42 weeks postmenstrual age, gray matter volumes were not different between preterm and term infants. Myelinated white matter was decreased, as were unmyelinated white matter volumes in the region including the central gyri. The gray matter proportion of the brain parenchyma constituted 30% and 37% at 32 and 42 weeks postmenstrual age, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS. This MRI study of preterm infants appropriate for gestational age and without brain injury establishes the influence of early birth on brain development. No decreased cortical gray matter volumes were found, which is in contrast to findings in preterm infants with brain injury. Moderately decreased white matter volumes suggest an adverse influence of early birth on white matter development. We identified a sharp increase in cortical gray matter volume in preterm infants serial data, which may correspond to a critical period for cortical development.
Key Words: magnetic resonance imaging preterm infants regional brain development parcellation segmentation
Abbreviations: UMWMunmyelinated white matter MWMmyelinated white matter PMApostmenstrual age AGAappropriate for gestational age ICVintracranial volume MRmagnetic resonance SPGRspoiled gradient recalled CSFcerebrospinal fluid CGMcortical gray matter SGMsubcortical gray matter CPARcerebral parenchyma STAPLESimultaneous Truth and Performance Level Estimation ANCOVAanalysis of covariance
Preterm infants are at risk for adverse neurodevelopmental outcome and functional disabilities because of increased vulnerability of the brain before and after premature birth.1,2 Brain injury, seen as white and gray matter signal abnormalities and enlarged ventricles, can be clinically recognized with MRI.3,4 Providing high-resolution images of the living subject, this modality has also become a major tool for preterm brain research. MRI research has provided insight into the morphology and etiology of white matter injury and gray matter abnormalities.3,4 MRI-visible brain injury has been linked to hypoxic-ischemic incidences,5 and the severity of the injury has been shown to depend on epidemiologic factors, such as perinatal infection6,7 and hypotension with use of inotrope medication.8
Recently, image postprocessing including segmentation9 and parcellation10 has contributed to the understanding of the relationship between brain injury and quantitative morphologic changes of the major brain tissue compartments. Several conditions, such as periventricular leukomalacia and fetal growth restriction, have been found to affect white and gray matter development in preterm infants when compared with healthy term infants.1015 Whereas most investigations compare total brain tissue volumes, studies assessing regional changes are few in number.10,16
Investigations in preterm infants also offer the opportunity for the study of longitudinal brain development. In this context, an important indicator of brain development is the process of myelination. Early myelination is seen in preterm MRI as altered signal intensity, for example, high signal intensity on T1-weighted images in localized regions in the internal capsule and brainstem.17 The segmentation approach used in this study is based on MRI signal intensity contrast between brain tissues. This technique enabled the segmentation of 2 different tissue classes for unmyelinated (UMWM) and myelinated white matter (MWM).18
Infants who are born before 28 weeks' postmenstrual age (PMA), whose birth weight is <1000 g, or who suffer from fetal growth restriction seem at higher risk for brain injury. However, the majority of preterm infants are of moderate gestational age (>28 weeks' PMA) and moderate birth weight (>1500 g).19,20 Their risk for brain injury is recognized as low.21,22 However, research on these low-risk preterm infants' brain development is still very scarce. The limited existing studies report moderate developmental delay.23,24
The aim of this study was to investigate by MRI the brain's appearance in a group of preterm infants born at 28 to 33 weeks' PMA, appropriate in growth for gestational age (AGA) at birth and without known risk factors for altered brain development. Preterm infants were scanned at 42 weeks' PMA, and the scans were compared with age-equivalent healthy term infants' scans. Postprocessing of the MRI acquisitions included segmentation of brain tissues into 5 gray and white matter compartments and parcellation of the intracranial cavity (ICV)25 to identify regional differences in brain tissue volumes. In addition, an early scan was acquired for each preterm infant soon after birth. This provided the opportunity to describe longitudinal brain development during the third trimester outside the womb. It was the aim of this study to define changes in the tissue composition of the brain and to investigate whether growth occurs at different rates in different regions.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Preterm infants' selection criteria included gestational age at birth 28 to 33 weeks' PMA, 5-minute Apgar score
7; AGA for weight and head circumference at birth (>10th percentile for both); normal cranial ultrasound and baseline MRI; and <72 hours of mechanical ventilation and vasopressor medication. Exclusion criteria were congenital and chromosomal abnormalities, congenital and acquired infections, prenatal brain lesions (eg, cysts and infarctions), and neonatal seizures. Parents' selection criteria included absence of major medical and psychiatric illness, long-term medication treatment (eg, insulin, steroids, antidepressants, and anticonvulsants), and absence of a history of substance abuse, including tobacco and alcohol. Written, informed consent was obtained from all of the parents before enrollment into the study. Identical imaging study protocols were used across institutions after obtaining permission from each of the institutions review boards for research with human subjects.
MRI Acquisitions
Preterm infants were scanned at a 1.5-T magnetic resonance (MR) system (General Electric Signa, Milwaukee, WI, or 1.5 T Marconi Philipps Medical Systems, Andover, MA) after birth as soon as they were judged to be in stable condition. The mean PMA for the preterm infants' first scan was 33.3 ± 1.6 weeks acquired at 13 ± 6 days after birth. Scanning was repeated at 41.7 ± 1.7 weeks' PMA. Term infants were scanned at 41.7 ± 0.7 weeks' PMA. High-resolution (0.7 x 0.7 x 1.5-mm coronal slices) T1-weighted three-dimensional Fourier transform spoiled gradient recalled (SPGR) images were obtained (18-cm field of view, 1.5-mm contiguous slice thickness, repetition and echo times of 40 ms and 4 ms, matrix 256 x 256, flip angle = 20°) requiring a scan time of 20 minutes. T2-weighted and proton density-weighted images were acquired using a dual echo fast spin echo sequence (echo train length: 8; 3-mm skip interleave; 2 acquisitions; repetition time: 4000; echo times: 160 and 80 ms; matrix: 256 x 256; field of view: 18 cm; number of excitations: 1; coronal slices: 0.7 x 0.7 x 3 mm; scan time: 6.4 minutes). Before scanning, infants were fed, wrapped securely in warm blankets, outfitted with ear protection, and placed into the scanner on a vacuum pillow.
A neonatologist and/or NICU staff nurse responsible for the infants' transfer to the MR scanner also stayed with them in the scanner room during scanning to monitor their electrocardiography and pulse oximetry. All of the scans were performed without sedation. Five scans were excluded from the study, because motion artifacts were judged to interfere significantly with image postprocessing. After exclusion of these cases, 23 preterm and 15 term infants remained in the study. At each center, a pediatric neuroradiologist reviewed the infants' scans, and no abnormalities were identified.
Image Processing
For each acquisition, the following image analysis steps were applied to obtain a tissue classification and a parcellation. The scans from the different centers were processed centrally by the same expert.
Because artifacts from MR field inhomogeneity pose a greater challenge in the processing of newborn brain images than in those of adults because of the reduced gray matter/white matter contrast seen in newborns, intensity nonuniformity effects, subsequent to the field inhomogeneity, were removed using a retrospective method that minimizes the entropy of the image.28,29 Subsequently, edge-preserving adaptive diffusion filtering30 was used to reduce noise in the SPGR images while preserving subtle structures and boundaries. Rigid intrasubject registration was performed by application of an algorithm based on mutual information. The T2-weighted and proton density-weighted images were registered and upsampled to the higher resolution of the SPGR sequence.31
Segmentations of the ICV, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), and 4 tissue classes (cortical gray matter [CGM], subcortical gray matter [SGM], UMWM, and MWM) were obtained using a semiautomatic segmentation method.9 Sample voxels were selected interactively, and optimal estimation of the distribution of MRI signal intensities associated with each type of tissue was conducted. An anatomic template was aligned with the ICV of the subject and used to disambiguate the segmentation of tissues that have overlapping signal intensity characteristics but nonoverlapping spatial distribution. Different anatomic templates were provided for the scans obtained at 32 and at 42 weeks' PMA. The sum of CGM, SGM, UMWM, and MWM defined the total volume of the cerebral parenchyma (CPAR).
The segmentation method described has been successfully applied in previous studies.13,14,3234 An expert conducted 5 repeated segmentations of 5 infants' MRI scans to assess the accuracy of the segmentation approach. An algorithm called Simultaneous Truth and Performance Level Estimation (STAPLE)35 was then applied to estimate for each tissue class the probability of the true segmentation of each voxel based on the repeated segmentations. The posterior probability represents the probability that a voxel truly is a particular tissue class when the segmentation states it is. The coefficient of variation of the posterior probability of the repeated segmentations was estimated to provide an indicator of the reproducibility of the method (Table 1).
|
|
Statistical Analyses
Analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) with SPSS (SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL) was used to test for differences between tissue volumes in the scans acquired at 42 weeks' PMA in preterm versus term infants. Model testing with ICV, CPAR, and age as covariates and 2-way interactions was conducted for all of the tissue classes. Models covarying for ICV or volume of the total CPAR showed highest significance; age as a second covariate did not account significantly for variation in the model.
When Levene's test39 and residual statistics showed evidence for heteroscedasticity, a heteroscedasticity-consistent SE estimator for small sample sizes, called HC3, was applied to manage heteroscedasticity of an unknown form.40,41 The theory and application of the HC3 method has been described elsewhere.42
When testing group differences for 7 tissue classes for total and regional volumes and 16 single parcels, it is essential to correct for multiple significance tests. Benjamini and Hochberg43 developed a method to control the probability of the family-wise error rate44 by computing the false-discovery rate, which controls the expected proportion of falsely rejected hypotheses. We applied the false-discovery rate and chose a hierarchical approach to minimize the number of simultaneously tested hypotheses. Group differences for total volumes and regions were analyzed first. Only for those regions that proved to show significant differences, the right and left side and the individual parcels were subsequently tested to further characterize the specific nature of the group differences. The number of hypotheses tested (probability level, 2-tailed: P < .05) was counted separately for each of the 7 segmented tissue types to allow a separate statement to be made regarding the appearance of each segmented class.
Linear regression was applied to determine absolute and relative longitudinal brain changes from 32 weeks' PMA to 42 weeks' PMA in preterm infants' serial MRI (Pearson's coefficient [r]). Regression models that correlate tissue volumes with PMA at the time of the scan and CPAR had similar significance. Reported results are based on a regression model that correlates with CPAR with the exception of the analysis of CPAR itself, which was correlated with PMA. Predicted values at 32 and 42 weeks' PMA were computed to describe total and regional rate of growth.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A high accuracy was found for the parcellation method and the segmentation method using STAPLE35 on repeated parcellations and segmentations (Table 1). Intrarater variability was low, with a coefficient of variation of 4.0% and 5.4% of the posterior probability for the parcellation and the segmentation method, respectively (Table 1).
Comparison of Brain Tissue Volumes in Term and Preterm Infants at Term: Analysis of the Relationship Among ICV, CPAR, and CSF
Twenty-three preterm infants and 15 term infants were included in the analysis. Differences in the population mean for total and regional volumes of all of the tissue classes were first tested with ICV entered as covariate. When CSF was found to be significantly larger in preterm infants' frontal region, an analysis of head size and cerebral volume was conducted. Total and regional volumes of the ICV, CSF, and CPAR were alternately analyzed as a function of PMA at scan, ICV, and CPAR (Table 2). Total and frontal CSF and ICV were significantly larger in preterm infants when covaried with CPAR or age (Table 2). Regardless if CPAR was correlated to ICV or age, it was not different between the 2 groups. Visual inspection of a midaxial and a midsagittal slice of the infants revealed head shape differences, consistent with biparietal flattening of the skull in the preterm population. The preterm infants' heads were dolichocephalic narrow and elongated. Their frontal skull and brain appeared rounder and more prominent with a frontal accumulation of CSF, when compared with term infants (Fig 2).
|
|
Comparison of Brain Tissue Volumes at Term Correcting for CPAR
Total and regional volumes of CGM, SGM, and cerebellum did not differ significantly between preterm (n = 23) and term infants (n = 15; Table 3). Significantly increased CSF in preterm infants was found for total volume, for the frontal and precentral region, and for all 4 of the sides and all 4 of the upper parcels.
|
In a next step, the ratio of MWM/CPAR and UMWM/CPAR was computed to express the MWM fraction and UMWM fraction of the total cerebral volume. The relation between the MWM and UMWM fractions as an indicator of WM maturation was then investigated carrying out analysis of covariance for total, central, and occipital volumes. In this analysis, the MWM fraction was expressed in relation to the UMWM fraction for preterm versus term infants. The MWM fraction was found to be significantly decreased in preterm infants (Ptotal < .005; Pcentral < .005; Poccipital < .01). This indicates a smaller ratio of MWM versus UMWM in preterm infants. Moreover, in term infants, a smaller fraction of UMWM was related to a larger fraction of MWM, but in preterm infants, for a smaller fraction of UMWM, the fraction of MWM did not increase (Fig 3). This altered correlation was found for total MWM, as well as for the volume of MWM in the central and occipital region.
|
|
The composition of the cerebral tissues changed between the 2 time points at which the infants were scanned (Fig 4). At 32 weeks' PMA, the UMWM represented 57% of the CPAR. At 42 weeks' PMA, UMWM accounted only for 47% of the CPAR (49% in term infants). Average MWM remained stable, forming 2.2% and 1.7% (2.1% in term infants) of total CPAR at 32 and 42 weeks' PMA, respectively. The portion of CGM increased from 30% to 39% of total CPAR between the 2 time points. The percentage of SGM of the total CPAR decreased slightly from 5.8% at 32 weeks' PMA to 4.8% at 42 weeks' PMA. At 32 weeks' PMA, the cerebellum accounted for 4.4% of the total CPAR, and at 42 weeks' PMA, the percentage was increased to 6.3% (Fig 4).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
However, in the current study, gross assessment of the infants' MRI revealed biparietal narrowed and fronto-occipital elongated heads in the preterm population accompanied by regionally increased CSF volumes. Biparietal flattening occurs in response to external compression force exerted during sleep position in incubators and cribs48 during the first days after preterm birth.4951 Mode of delivery does not implicate flattening of the skull.52 In normal infants, head circumference as assessed in ultrasound biometry serves as a good indicator for brain size. However, if the head shape is abnormal and head growth is accelerated, this is not the case.53,54 Thus, other measures are suggested for preterm infants, such as the cerebellar diameter, which reliably measures adequate growth even when the infant exhibits an unusually shaped head.55,56
Studies using MRI biomarkers such as tissue volumes are sparse. Duncan et al57 found head circumference measured in fetal imaging to be a poor indicator for brain size in infants with fetal growth restriction. Several investigations in preterm infants with brain injury have identified an association between increased CSF volumes and decreased cerebral volumes.11,13,47 The current study provides the first evidence to suggest that, in low-risk preterm infants, those selected to have a head circumference appropriate for their PMA, cerebral volume is normal, yet CSF volume is increased. Considering that an appropriate head circumference between the 10th and 90th percentile corresponds with 33- to 38-cm head circumference measured at birth, this gives a broad range of variable brain tissue and CSF volumes, which may obscure true group differences in a small cohort. Results from the longitudinal analysis, which show a distinct growth pattern for the CSF volume and the slower increasing cerebral volume, support the findings of the comparison between preterm and term infants. Future work is needed to investigate the association between changes in preterm infants' head shape and tissue volumes and to identify the effect that this might have on the reliability of a landmark-based parcellation.
Effects of Premature Birth on Gray Matter Volumes
Quantitative MRI studies, which investigated preterm infants with white matter injury, those born very early, and those with fetal growth restriction, have found decreased gray matter volumes in preterm infants.14,32,47 These changes have been further associated with impaired neurodevelopmental outcome.32 During late gestation, after the migration of neurons into the cortex is completed, decreased gray matter volumes may be caused by atrophy and neuronal loss, disruption of the formation of neural connectivity and of dendrite growth during synaptogenesis.5860 The undisturbed gray matter development found in the preterm sample of the current study might explain the only moderate neurodevelopmental differences otherwise reported in low-risk AGA preterm infants.23,24,61
Effects of Premature Birth on Total and Regional White Matter Volumes
Although statistical analyses identified significant differences of regional white matter volumes between preterm and term infants, testing of single parcels failed to reach statistical significance. This underlines the importance of regional assessment when investigating brain development but also points to the limitations of measuring regional and therewith often very small volumes.
Reduction in statistical power makes interpretation of such results difficult, especially given the relatively small sample of the current study, which consisted of 23 preterm and 15 term infants after exclusion of 5 infants because of motion artifacts. An alternative definition of parcels may also improve sensitivity to differences in myelination, because myelination follows an anatomically specific developmental process.62
Similar to the current study, Peterson et al47 reported findings of decreased white matter in the central region, which includes the sensor-motor system, as well as the auditory processing areas of the frontotemporal lobes. In addition, the preterm infants in that study displayed decreased white matter volumes in the parieto-occipital regions when compared with term infants. A possible explanation for the differences between the results of Peterson et al47 and the current study is the fact that the preterm infants in the study by Peterson et al47 experienced several clinical complications, such as periventricular leukomalacia and bronchopulmonary dysplasia treated with postnatal steroids, which are known to affect brain development. It is likely that, therefore, the preterm brains in the study by Peterson et al47 were impaired to a more extended degree.
The current study suggests an alteration in the course of myelination for the preterm infants studied. In these infants, a decrease of UMWM fraction was not always accompanied by an increase in the myelinated fraction. Whether these observations are caused by unidentified injury, delay, or an alteration of fiber tract development cannot be answered with the present study. New techniques, such as the analysis of diffusion tensor imaging, have been applied recently to preterm and term MRI.63 Initial findings show promising results for the analysis of white matter maturation. Evidence has been found recently for underlying delay in white matter maturation in preterm infants with brain injury,64,65 as well as in AGA preterm infants without brain injury.26
Longitudinal Brain Development in Preterm Infants
Growth of Total Cerebral Tissues
Literature on fetal biometry was reviewed to compare postnatal measures from this study to reference values from fetal imaging. Fetal MRI and ultrasound6669 have been used to estimate fetal brain volumes in normal pregnancies, and best-fit regression equations have been reported. Postprocessing methods range from estimation of brain volume to an exact labeling of the boundaries in each slice to outline the brain.68 Daily increase in cerebral tissue volume has been reported in a number of publications6669 with a range of 2.3 to 3.6 mL and a mean of 3.1 mL. Whereas the current study's methods were not directly comparable, because postprocessing methodology differed, daily growth rate was similar with 3.2 mL per day. This should be encouraging for future investigations, which may use data from low-risk uncomplicated preterm infants as a model for the investigation of brain development.
Single Brain Tissue Development and Tissue Composition of the Brain
Longitudinal analysis of the brain tissue composition suggested that the developmental period studied seems to be a critical period for cerebral gray matter growth. One possible explanation is that because neural migration itself gradually ends by the beginning of the third trimester, the pronounced increase in gray matter volume may indicate the increasingly rich axonal branching and developing connectivity between neurons, as well as synaptogenesis.7072 CGM volume is further influenced by cortical folding, which increases markedly during the studied period between 32 and 40 weeks. Cortical folding is more prominent in the occipital lobe than in the frontal lobe, which is reflected in the higher growth rate for CGM volume in the occipital lobe than in the frontal lobe.
Another consideration is that cortical thickness as measured by MRI is influenced by tissue characteristics, such as water content. During cortical development, inner layers of the cortex have higher water content, which might lead to a falsely thin cortical rim on MRI and, consequently, to an underestimation of the cortical volume by the proposed segmentation techniques. Myelination leads to decreased water content followed by signal intensity changes of the white matter and the adjacent gray matter. The rapid gray matter volume change in the preterm infants' cortex observed in the current study might, thus, be related to a physiologic decrease in the water content during ongoing white matter maturation,17 leading to an overestimation of the increase in gray matter volume.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We acknowledge the time and efforts of the Murdoch Childrens Research Institute of Melbourne, Australia, affiliated with Dr Inder, in helping to achieve the MR acquisitions and Joao Fernandes in helping to achieve segmentations of the infants MRI scans.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Andrea U.J. Mewes, MD, Department of Radiology, Brigham and Women's Hospital, 75 Francis St, Boston, MA 02115. E-mail: mewes{at}bwh.harvard.edu
The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. J. Rivkin, P. E. Davis, J. L. Lemaster, H. J. Cabral, S. K. Warfield, R. V. Mulkern, C. D. Robson, R. Rose-Jacobs, and D. A. Frank Volumetric MRI Study of Brain in Children With Intrauterine Exposure to Cocaine, Alcohol, Tobacco, and Marijuana Pediatrics, April 1, 2008; 121(4): 741 - 750. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. T. Constable, L. R. Ment, B. R. Vohr, S. R. Kesler, R. K. Fulbright, C. Lacadie, S. Delancy, K. H. Katz, K. C. Schneider, R. J. Schafer, et al. Prematurely Born Children Demonstrate White Matter Microstructural Differences at 12 Years of Age, Relative to Term Control Subjects: An Investigation of Group and Gender Effects Pediatrics, February 1, 2008; 121(2): 306 - 316. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||