a Department of Pediatrics, Evanston Northwestern Healthcare Research Institute, Evanston, Illinois
b Department of Pediatrics, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
METHODS. In-depth, semistructured, qualitative interviews were conducted in 2 cities with a subsample of fathers who were participating in the national Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study. The 32 fathers who participated in our study come from a nested qualitative study called Time, Love, and Cash in Couples with Children. Fathers in our study reside in Chicago or Milwaukee and were interviewed about health care issues for 1.5 hours when the focal child was 3 years of age. Questions focused on the father's overall involvement in his child's health care, the father's attendance and experiences at the doctor, health care decision-making between mother and father, assessment of focal child's health, gender/normative roles, and the father's health. The open-ended questions were designed to allow detailed accounts and personal stories as told by the fathers. Coding and analysis were done using content analysis to identify themes. Particular themes that were used for this study focused on ideals of father involvement and dis/satisfaction, barriers to, and experiences in the health care system.
RESULTS. Of the 50 fathers from the Time, Love, and Cash in Couples with Children study in the 2 cities, 3 had moved out of the state, 6 were in jail, 7 had been lost in earlier follow-up, and 1 had died, leaving 33 eligible respondents. Of those, 1 refused to participate, resulting in a final sample of 32 fathers and an adjusted response rate of 97%. The mean age was 31 years, and the sample was 56% black, 28% Hispanic, and 15% white; 53% were nonmarried. Only 2 fathers had attained a college degree or higher, and 84% of the fathers were employed at the time of the interview. The majority (53%) had attended a WCV and 84% had been to see a doctor with their child in the past year. Reasons for attending a WCV included (1) to gather information about their child, (2) to support their child, (3) to ask questions and express concerns, and (4) to gain firsthand experience of the doctor and the WCV. Fathers reported positive and negative experiences in their encounters with the health care system. The 3 main contributors to fathers' satisfaction with health care professionals were (1) inclusive interactions with the physician, (2) the perception of receiving quality care, and (3) receiving clear explanations. The negative experiences were often specific instances and noted along with positive comments. The negative experiences that were mentioned by the fathers included feeling viewed suspiciously by health care staff, being perceived as having a lesser emotional bond with their child than the mother, and the perception that they were receiving a lower quality of service compared with the mother. Major barriers to attending WCVs include employment schedules as well as their relationship with the focal child's mother. For example, some fathers stated that they did not attend WCVs because that was a responsibility that the mother assumed within the family. Other fathers lacked confidence in their parenting skills, which resulted in lower involvement levels. Also mentioned were health care system barriers such as inconvenient office hours and a lack of access to their child's records. Despite the presence of several barriers that seem to prevent fathers from attending WCVs, many fathers (20 of 32;63%) mentioned "situational flexibility," which enables them to overcome the stated barriers and attend doctor visits. For example, some fathers viewed the seriousness of the visit such as "ear surgery" as a reason to rearrange their schedules and attend a doctor visit with their child.
CONCLUSION. The majority of fathers from our sample have attended a WCV, and most have been to their child's doctor in the past year; WCVs and doctor appointments are ways in which fathers are involved in their child's health care. Fathers detailed specific reasons for why they attend WCVs, such as to support their child, ask questions, express concerns, and gather information firsthand. The fathers reported more positive than negative experiences with the health care staff, and, overall, they are satisfied with their experiences with the health care system. Reasons for satisfaction include feeling as though their questions had been dealt with seriously and answered appropriately. However, the fathers in our study did report a variety of barriers to health care involvement, including conflicting work schedules, a lack of confidence in their parental role, and health care system barriers. Professionals who care for children and families need to explore creative ways to engage fathers in the structured health care of their children. For example, pediatricians can stress the benefits of both parents being involved in their child's health care while reframing the importance of WCVs. Understanding that many fathers have situational flexibility when it comes to health care encounters may encourage physicians to suggest more actively that fathers attend WCVs. Pediatricians can also support existing public policies such as the national 2003 Responsible Fatherhood Act that provides grants and programs that promote the father's role in the family and advocate for additional policies that would foster quality father involvement. Continued collaboration among families, physicians, and other health care professionals is essential to support father involvement and ensure positive health outcomes for children.
Key Words: fathers medical home parenting pediatric well-child visit
Abbreviations: AAPAmerican Academy of Pediatrics WCVwell-child visit TLC3Time, Love, and Cash in Couples with Children
The expansion of the father's role in the family in the past several decades is the result of societal and economic shifts that challenge the long-held belief that fathers are merely providers and disciplinarians.16 Fathers are spending more time with their children, and their involvement can assume a broad range of roles and responsibilities.7,8 There are many positive socioemotional, cognitive, and developmental child outcomes associated with father involvement, such as improved weight gain in preterm infants, improved breastfeeding rates, higher receptive language skills, higher academic achievement, higher self-esteem, lower depression and anxiety, and lower delinquent behaviors.922 The importance of father involvement is implicit in recent American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) Policy Statements that promote family-centered, preventive care in a medical home and anchored in the community with physicians who promote father-friendly practices.6,2326
Despite beneficial evidence, fathers remain underrepresented in most research compared with mothers. For example, in the National Survey of Early Childhood Health study, parental input came from the parent or guardian who was identified as being the most responsible for the child's medical care, resulting in only 11% of respondents' being fathers.27 Often when fathers are considered, data on their involvement are obtained from the mother's report.10,13,28 In addition, much of the earlier research focused on white, middle- to upper-class fathers,2933 with few recent studies examining more diverse populations of fathers in health care.3436 These recent studies have made important contributions by identifying predictors and some barriers to father involvement in generally older children's care, but they either focused on homogeneous racial/ethnic groups (eg, African Americans35 or Mexican Americans36) or used convenience samples that were recruited primarily from health clinics, a potential source of bias because these fathers are already in the health care system.34,35 If the objective is to understand and improve father participation in the health of their child and the health care system, then experiences from a diverse sample of fathers from outside the system are essential. Furthermore, a more diverse sample better represents the estimated 66.3 million fathers in the United States who vary by marital status, race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and occupation.37
Well-child visits (WCVs) are opportunities wherein fathers can become involved in their child's health care and become comfortable in their child's medical home. WCVs are ideally positioned for fathers to learn about the growth and development of their child, expand their parental role, and meet and communicate with the child's doctor. Our study gathered information from a diverse nonclinical-based population of fathers from 2 major metropolitan cities. Using qualitative methods, we explored and examined fathers' experiences in, satisfaction with, and barriers to attending WCVs. Understanding these aspects of father participation in the health care system in the fathers' own words can help clinicians to address disparities in paternal involvement in WCVs and ultimately lead to improved health care engagement with fathers.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
3 years of age. The fathers were given a nominal cash payment for their participation. Interviews covered the following domains: (1) father's overall involvement in his child's health care, (2) father's attendance and experiences at visits to the doctor, (3) health care decision-making between mother and father, (4) assessment of focal child's health, (5) gender/normative roles, and (6) father's health and medical care. The interview protocol covered normative views of fathers in health care as well as the individuals' experience. We designed the interview questions on the basis of literature review, previous qualitative interview protocols in the TLC3 study, and pilot interviews with fathers who were not in the study. Questions were deliberately open ended allowing the fathers to provide detailed accounts and personal stories. We audiotaped and transcribed all interviews; our Institutional Review Board approved the study.
We used content analysis methods to analyze the presence and the meaning of concepts and themes within the transcripts.38 After reviewing the transcripts, we created a code book to aid in identifying themes. The code book began with our initial, preordained codes (based on the interview protocol and literature review) and developed with emerging codes (derived from iterative interview reading, team discussions, and investigator triangulation). These codes gave way to emerging themes. For example, after coding 7 interviews, we noticed that a number of fathers were reluctant or fearful in performing certain tasks (ie, changing diapers, administering medicines) for their child. As a result, the new code "FAFEAR" was established to account for this theme, and all past and future transcripts then were coded for this theme. Codes were inputted and analyzed using Atlas.ti. 5.0.39 For this study, we examined themes surrounding ideals of father involvement and dis/satisfaction, barriers to, and experiences in the health care system.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
WCVs are key components of the pediatric health care system; they are designed to relay important information about growth and development in a timely manner while addressing unique concerns for individual patients and families. Important topics to discuss include diet, breastfeeding, immunizations, infant sleep position, medications, and psychosocial issues.27,41 Whereas most previous research enlisted the mother's perspective, our study shows that fathers have definite and well-articulated interests in being involved in their child's WCV. Pediatrics has a growing appreciation of the role that families and parents play in the health of their children, identifying them as "the most central and enduring influence in children's lives"42; incorporating fathers seems only natural. A present and engaged father along with the mother gives pediatricians the opportunity to observe family and parental functioning, the root of family pediatrics.
The AAP recognizes that pediatricians are well positioned to communicate with fathers during a WCV, thereby encouraging involvement, informing the father of his child's health and development, and providing anticipatory guidance for the child.6,41 According to the AAP statement, doctors can make intentional efforts to foster father involvement through providing helpful information, directing conversation to the father, and answering questions that are certain to be posed. As father involvement is on the rise7,8 and parents strive to balance work and home responsibilities, addressing the need for paternal parity in health care involvement is of increasing importance. This necessitates understanding the perceived and real barriers to involvement as well as considering ways to encourage or facilitate involvement.
Fathers generally were satisfied with the care that they received and felt respected as parents (Table 5). A major reason for why fathers felt satisfied was because they often perceived that their child was receiving quality care. This is an important finding, especially in light of health disparity research that reports that low-income and minority children receive lower quality of health care in comparisons with middle- to high-income and white children.43,44 Additional research in this area could better inform the experiences of these populations within the health care system. To its credit, few barriers within the health care system itself were reported in the present study. Nevertheless, barriers to attending WCVs for some fathers are present. Some of these barriers seem easy to overcome, such as by offering copies of medical cards or immunization records to each parent; others seem more complex, such as extending office hours into evenings and weekends. Still others seem insurmountable; a frank inability to leave work or a poor relationship with the child's mother can discourage even the most well-intentioned parent. Yet 63% of fathers mentioned "situational flexibility" in their ability to participate in the health care system despite barriers, suggesting that pediatrics could reframe WCVs to increase father attendance.
|
Whether because of employment, relationships, or some other paternal barrier, many mothers will continue to be the primary contact for the pediatrician. This study reminds pediatricians that concerned and interested fathers who are unable to make an office visit frequently are awaiting health information from that visit later at home. Pediatricians therefore can work to improve information sharing between doctor and parent and between parents. First, an initial discussion with the child's mother or the child's mother and father together about how they plan to deal with parental responsibilities for child health may set up some ground rules regarding how information might be shared, especially among nonmarried, noncohabiting parents. The pediatrician's role in facilitating parental involvement (eg, writing a note from the doctor to the employer explaining the parent's necessary absence) could be part of that discussion. Second, to help parents share information, written notes from the visit highlighting important issues around growth and development, behavior, safety, and any new medications would be useful. Many electronic medical records have this capability built in. Third, if fathers are unable to attend WCVs, then encouraging them to submit their questions or concerns may help them to feel included. Finally, consider using technology (eg, cell phones, e-mail) to improve information exchange and encourage involvement. These strategies may be useful for including fathers in the medical home but are equally helpful for including any of the child's major caregivers (eg, grandparents).
As advocates for children and families, pediatricians can also promote public and employment policies that support father involvement. On a national level, the US Senate enacted the Responsible Fatherhood Act of 2003 to compliment past task forces that were initiated by the US Senate, Congress, governors, and mayors47 to support and encourage greater father involvement through the allocation of grant funds, the development of media campaigns, and the promotion of community resources that assist fathers. Also in 2003 (and recently extended), Illinois adopted a similar act, entitled the Illinois Council on Responsible Fatherhood, which strives to establish support structures that enable fathers to develop and maintain relationships with their children and to promote ways to reduce negative outcomes for children who are affected by divorce, separation, and disputes concerning custody and visitation.48 Of the 2 states in our sample, only Illinois has a School Visitation Rights Act (established in 1992), which provides parents with a total of 8 unpaid hours during any school year to attend a parent conference or related school activity,49 and neither state offers policies to encourage attending WCVs. In 1998, Massachusetts established the Small Necessities Leave Act,50 which allows employees to have 24 hours of unpaid time off per year to participate in a child's school-related activity and to accompany a child to a routine medical appointment, such as a WCV. Pediatricians therefore can support the creation of similar laws to the Small Necessities Leave Act in their states.
There are limitations to our study. Our study is qualitative, which is exploratory in nature and draws on a small sample size. Although our sample is diverse and comes from 2 metropolitan areas, these findings may not generalize to other urban fathers. Because these were father self-reports of involvement, there is a possibility of social desirability bias. Interviews were conducted without mothers or others present in hopes of reducing this potential bias. We believe that the benefit of hearing from this generally underrepresented population in their own words outweighs the limitations. Finally, the fathers in our study had to exhibit an initial level of involvement at birth to be recruited; that is, fathers whose involvement ended before the child's birth are not in our sample. We cannot comment on the important issues for this subpopulation. However, from a clinical perspective, our study focuses on the population of fathers who potentially could be more engaged in their children's health care.
| CONCLUSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Craig Garfield, MD, MAPP, Department of Pediatrics, Evanston Northwestern Healthcare Research Institute, 1001 University Ave, Evanston, IL 60201. E-mail: c-garfield{at}northwestern.edu
The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
This work was presented in part at the annual meeting of the Pediatric Academic Societies; May 16, 2005; Washington, DC.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. E. Edwards, B. A. Neville, E. F. Cook Jr, S. H. Aldridge, V. Dussel, and J. Wolfe Understanding of Prognosis and Goals of Care Among Couples Whose Child Died of Cancer J. Clin. Oncol., March 10, 2008; 26(8): 1310 - 1315. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. F. Garfield, E. Clark-Kauffman, and M. M. Davis Fatherhood as a Component of Men's Health. JAMA, November 15, 2006; 296(19): 2365 - 2368. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||