a Department of Pediatrics, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
b Behavioral Research Unit, Alberta Childrens Hospital, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
c Pediatric Psychology
d Clinical Health Psychology, University of Tilburg, Tilburg, Netherlands
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
METHODS. Examined were 108 neonates who were born to mothers with low maternal free thyroid hormone (fT4 concentrations; <10th percentile) at 12 weeks gestation (case patients) and 96 neonates who were born to women whose fT4 values were between the 50th and 90th percentiles, matched for parity and gravidity (control subjects). Newborn development was assessed at 3 weeks of age using the Neonatal Behavioral Assessment Scale. Maternal thyroid function (fT4 and thyrotropin hormone) was assessed at 12, 24, and 32 weeks gestation.
RESULTS. Infants of women with hypothyroxinemia at 12 weeks gestation had significantly lower scores on the Neonatal Behavioral Assessment Scale orientation index compared with subjects. Regression analysis showed that first-trimester maternal fT4 but not maternal TSH or fT4 later in gestation was a significant predictor of orientation scores.
CONCLUSIONS. This study confirms that maternal hypothyroxinemia constitutes a serious risk factor for neurodevelopmental difficulties that can be identified in neonates as young as 3 weeks of age.
Key Words: neonatal outcome thyroid disorders
Abbreviations: fT4free thyroid hormone TSHthyrotropin hormone NBASNeonatal Behavioral Assessment Scale TPO-Abthyroid peroxidase antibodies EPDSEdinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale RDCResearch Diagnostic Criteria STAIState-Trait Anxiety Inventory ANOVAanalysis of variance ADHDattention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder
Hypothyroxinemia is a common condition in pregnant women. It is characterized by low maternal free thyroid hormone (fT4) concentrations with thyrotropin hormone (TSH) concentrations in the normal range. This condition has long been regarded as being without consequences for mother and fetus. Recent findings by Pop et al1,2 and very recently by Vermiglio et al3 restimulated an earlier debate that originally was started by Man et al46 regarding to what extent maternal hypothyroxinemia in early pregnancy constitutes a risk factor for impaired infant development. On the basis of the idea that hypothyroxinemia reflects a condition in which the mother may produce enough T4 for her own needs but cannot meet fetal T4 demands to preserve normal neurodevelopment, Pop et al1 investigated the relationship between maternal plasma fT4 concentration during pregnancy and infant neurodevelopment in an iodine-sufficient area. They found that in otherwise normal pregnancies, maternal fT4 concentrations
10th percentile at 12 weeks gestation but not at 32 weeks gestation were associated with developmental delays at 10 months of age as measured with the Dutch version of the Bayley Scales of Infant Development.7 Subsequently, a prospective 3-year follow-up study of children of mothers with fT4 concentrations at the lowest 10th percentile demonstrated cognitive and neuromotor delays at both 1 and 2 years of age2 compared with children of mothers with gestational fT4 levels between the 50th and 90th percentiles. However, for minimizing the influence of the postnatal environment when determining the impact of gestational hypothyroxinemia, it would be desirable to evaluate children as close as possible to the time of birth.
The current report, therefore, used the Neonatal Behavioral Assessment Scale (NBAS),8 administered at 3 weeks of age, to examine the neurobehavioral profile of neonates as a function of maternal fT4 status measured at 12, 24, and 32 weeks gestation. It was hypothesized that low scores on the NBAS, indicating less mature behavior, would be associated with low maternal fT4 concentrations at 12 weeks gestation but not at 24 or 32 weeks gestation.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Of the remaining 226 women who completed the study, thyroid parameters at 24 and/or 32 weeks were not obtained in 22 women. Therefore, data analysis refers to 204 mothers and their children (108 case patients and 96 control subjects), none of whom had serious complications during pregnancy or delivery. As shown in Table 1, no differences in descriptive characteristics, for both mothers and newborns, were observed between case patients and control subjects. Mothers and children were white, with the mothers ranging in age from 21 to 40 years (mean: 31.4 years; SD: 3.3). The sample did not differ from the eligible cohort of 1361 women on any of the characteristics listed in Table 1. The study was approved by the medical ethical committee of the St Joseph Hospital (Veldhoven, Netherlands).
|
Scores on the NBAS were reduced to the following 7 clusters: (1) habituation: the ability to respond to and inhibit discrete stimuli while asleep; (2) orientation: includes the ability to attend to visual and auditory stimuli and the quality of overall alertness; (3) motor: measures motor performance and the quality of movement and tone; (4) range of state: a measure of infant arousal and state lability; (5) regulation of state: measures the infants ability to regulate his or her state in the face of increasing levels of stimulation; (6) autonomic stability: records signs of stress related to homeostatic adjustments of the central nervous system; and (7) reflexes: the total number of nonoptimal responses (Table 2).
|
Thyroid Parameters
TSH (reference range: 0.152.0 mIU/L) was measured using a solid-phase, 2-site chemiluminescent enzyme immunometric assay (Immulite Third Generation TSH; Diagnostic Products Corporation, Los Angeles, CA). The fT4 concentration (reference range: 8.719.6 pmol/L) was also measured with a solid-phase immunometric assay (Immulite Free T4). The Immulite AntiTPO-Ab kit was used to determine antibodies against TPO. The anti-TPO assay is standardized in accordance with the International Reference Preparation for anti-TPO MRC 66/387. An antibody concentration of
35 IU/mL was regarded as elevated. A concentration of >100 IU/mL was regarded as clearly elevated. As part of the nationwide screening of congenital hypothyroidism, thyroid function (total T4) was assessed in all neonates between days 5 and 7 postpartum.
Maternal Depression and Anxiety
Information on maternal depression and anxiety was obtained to control statistically for their potential influence on infant development. Depressive symptoms were measured at 24 weeks gestation using the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS). The EPDS is a 10-item self-report scale that measures the intensity of depressive symptoms but does not provide a syndromal diagnosis. The Dutch translation of the EPDS has been found to have good psychometric properties,13 with a Cronbachs
of .82.
The diagnosis of an episode of major depression during early postpartum (3 weeks) was made using a semistructured interview applying the Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC).14 The RDC evaluates the occurrence of a depressive disorder in the 2 weeks before the interview and discriminates between major and minor depression.
Anxiety at 24 weeks gestation was measured by the general anxiety scale of the Symptom Check List-90,15 Dutch version.16 The internal consistency of the Dutch version was found to be high, with Cronbachs
of .91 for the anxiety subscale.17
Anxiety was also measured at 32 weeks gestation by self-report using the Dutch State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI).18 The STAI19 consists of 2 subscales, each containing 20 items. The state anxiety subscale measures anxiety at the moment of scoring; trait anxiety measures dispositional anxiety, or anxiety in general. Higher scores on the STAI indicate a higher intensity of anxiety.
Statistical Analyses
The statistical analyses were performed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences 12.0 (SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL). Initial data analyses involved comparing case patients and control subjects on various demographic and pregnancy-related factors, using analysis of variance (ANOVA) for continuous variables and
2 tests of association for categorical variables. Between-group comparisons on the NBAS cluster scores used a series of ANOVAs and analysis of covariance to control for potentially confounding factors. The final phase of the analysis involved an examination of predictors of scores on the orientation cluster of the NBAS, using both a multiple regression and a logistic-regression approach.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2[1, N = 204] = 8.25, P = .004; and TSH first trimester, F1,202 = 15.94, P < .0001). It is to be noted that although higher in the case patients than in the control subjects, the TSH levels of both groups were clearly within the normal reference range. No significant group differences were found for TSH or fT4 levels in the second and third trimesters. There were also no significant differences between case patients and control subjects for the total T4 level in infant heel blood samples or in the SD of heel blood samples compared with all infants who were born that day in Holland.
|
NBAS Cluster Scores
NBAS cluster scores are reported in Table 4. A series of ANOVAs were used to compare case patients and control subjects on each of the cluster scores for the NBAS. A significant group difference emerged for only 1 cluster: the orientation cluster score (F1,189 = 4.19; P = .042). Control subjects scored significantly higher than case patients. The 2 groups did not differ significantly on the remaining cluster scores.
|
Maternal Depression and Anxiety
There was no group difference in the prevalence of depression in the third week postpartum as measured by RDC criteria; none of the control subjects met criteria for major depression, although 4 (3.8%) case patients did. Because of those 4 case patients, the analysis was rerun controlling for depression, and the group difference on the orientation cluster remained significant (F1,191 = 4.18; P = .042). Similar results were obtained when meeting criteria for major depression at 24 weeks gestation (measured by the EPDS; P = .040) was used as a covariate. The control group still scored higher than case patients on the orientation cluster. The groups did not differ significantly in terms of maternal state or trait anxiety as measured at 24 weeks gestation by the Symptom Check List-90 Anxiety subscale or at 32 weeks gestation as measured by the STAI.
Predictors of Neonatal Orientation Scores
A multiple regression approach was used to predict the orientation cluster score from various factors related to pregnancy, thyroid functioning, maternal mood, and demographics (Table 5). The overall regression was significant (R2 = 0.108; F10,160 = 1.94; P = .043). Lower orientation cluster scores were associated with lower fT4 levels in the first trimester (P = .024), higher maternal anxiety (P = .028), and younger gestational ages (P = .003). Maternal fT4 levels in the second and third trimesters were not significant predictors of the orientation cluster score.
|
2[1, N = 194] = 8.77; P = .003).
A logistic-regression analysis was conducted to determine the best predictors of scores below the 1-SD cutoff on the orientation cluster. The same factors that were used in the multiple regression mentioned previously were used as predictors (Table 6). The overall regression was significant (
2[10, N = 171] = 26.50; P = .003). An fT4 concentration in the lowest 10th percentile (<10.4 pmol/L) at 12 weeks gestation, younger gestational age, and maternal anxiety at 24 weeks gestation all were related to a low score (below 1 SD of the mean) on the orientation cluster score. None of the other variables listed in Table 5 was related to low orientation cluster scores.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
10th percentile had significantly lower scores on the NBAS orientation index than children of mothers with higher fT4 values. Similarly, regression analysis showed that first-trimester maternal fT4 but not maternal TSH or fT4 later in gestation was a significant predictor of orientation scores. In addition to these statistically significant results, there were some supportive findings, albeit nonsignificant, that were in the expected direction: after controlling for first-trimester maternal TSH levels, case patients and control subjects differed for both the range of state and regulation of state cluster scores (P < .10). These results are in accordance with recent findings by Pop et al1,2 in which maternal hypothyroxinemia in the first trimester of pregnancy was adversely related to child development. However, the children in these reports were between 10 months and 2 years of age, whereas the present study focused on neonatal behavior at 3 weeks of age. Clearly, the value of having such a short interval between birth and assessment is that the possible impact of psychosocial factors that may interfere with infant development is kept to a minimum. Hence, the current findings of early neurodevelopmental delay, albeit subtle, could be more directly attributable to the neurologic consequences of maternal hypothyroxinemia per se.
The association between first-trimester maternal fT4 and neonatal development may have been mediated by other independent factors. Therefore, several pregnancy- and infant-related factors that are known to affect infant outcome either were defined as exclusion criteria (eg, gestational age <37 weeks) or were statistically controlled for in the between-group analyses (eg, anxiety, depression). As a result, the between-group comparisons were clear in regard to the predominant impact of first-trimester maternal fT4. Admittedly, though, the regression analyses did show additional correlations between the NBAS orientation scores and both gestational age and anxiety at 24 weeks gestation.
The association between gestational age and outcome was surprising given that all case patients who were <37 weeks gestational age were excluded from the analyses. Finding an association between gestational age and early neonatal behavior, even with a time window ranging from 37 weeks gestation to full term, not only illustrates the significance of abbreviated gestational age as a neonatal risk factor but also emphasizes the sensitivity of the NBAS as a neonatal assessment tool.
The association between anxiety and low scores on the NBAS orientation cluster as found in the current study should be considered in the light of an ongoing debate as to what extent maternal antenatal anxiety constitutes an independent risk factor for compromised neonatal outcome. The results of initial studies have supported the notion of a relationship between maternal antenatal anxiety and neonatal outcome in terms of low birth weight and preterm delivery. However, these studies were targeted mainly at specific risk groups (eg, teenage mothers, mothers of low socioeconomic status) using small sample sizes. Recently, 1 study of a large (n = 1465) population-based sample20 found no evidence for such a relationship, as neonatal outcome did not deteriorate as a function of maternal antenatal anxiety.
More direct evidence supporting the causal relationships between early maternal hypothyroxinemia and neurodevelopmental outcome comes from Lavado et al.21 Pregnant rat dams (an animal species that shows the closest similarity to humans with respect to placentation and hence the passage of maternal thyroid hormone to the fetus) were put on a low-iodine diet to produce maternal hypothyroxinemia throughout pregnancy. Neuronal migration into the neocortex was found to be affected in the pups that were born to the hypothyroxinemic dams, resulting in permanent alterations in the cytoarchitecture of the somatosensory cortex and the hippocampus. These findings were confirmed in a recent study by the same research group in which pregnant rats were treated with a goitrogen for 3 days at the start of the neocorticogenesis.22 The resulting mild and transient hypothyroxinemia resulted in similar cytoarchitectural changes in the somatosensory cortex and the hippocampus as found by Lavado et al21 but this time with a more strictly controlled protocol. As pointed out by Morreale de Escobar et al,23 these results, when extrapolated to humans, define the first trimester of pregnancy as a critical window in which subtle insufficiency of fT4 may interfere with normal brain development, thereby constituting a potential danger for neurodevelopment.
An important issue worth commenting on concerns the type of assessment used in this study: the NBAS as a measure of early neonatal development. There no doubt is a price to be paid for such an early neonatal follow-up, as results often have limited predictive value for future developmental outcome. This is because early neonatal behavior is inherently unstable and thus difficult to assess in a consistent manner. However, the NBAS, as shown in several studies, has considerable predictive power, especially with regard to its ability to predict neurobehavioral outcome within the first year of life.9 Although the literature is less clear about the long-term predictive power of the NBAS,8,24 the fact that the current results at 3 weeks of age are in accordance with the findings of Pop et al1,2 obtained at 1 and 2 years of age do suggest the start of unfavorable developmental pathways in infants who are born to hypothyroxinemic mothers. Clearly, what is important to assess is whether the neurodevelopmental problems noted in the first 2 years of life persist into childhood and adolescence. So far, there has been only 1 long-term prospective follow-up study3: children who were born to healthy mothers from a moderately iodine-deficient area were compared with control children who were born to healthy mothers from an iodine-sufficient area. By the time children had reached the age of 10 years, 11 (68.7%) of 16 children from the iodine-deficient area had developed attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) versus none of the children who were born in the iodine-sufficient area. Most interesting for the purpose of the present study, however, was the finding that the overall prevalence of ADHD in the iodine-deficient area was significantly higher (P < .01) in children who were born to mothers who had developed hypothyroxinemia with normal TSH, presumably related to iodine deficiency early in gestation. These results, although awaiting confirmation from larger cohort studies, are intriguing as they signal, to our knowledge for the second time in the literature, an association between thyroid deficiency during pregnancy and ADHD. The first time this relationship was reported involved a study by Hauser et al25 in which 70% of children who had a diagnosis of generalized resistance to thyroid hormone were found to have ADHD. Which mechanisms both (iodine-induced) maternal hypothyroxinemia and generalized resistance to thyroid hormone share that could explain the postnatal development of ADHD in both disorders, however, remains a matter of speculation and constitutes an important question for additional research. An additional reason that the connection between first-trimester maternal hypothyroxinemia and childhood ADHD is intriguing relates to the fact that the current finding of low scores on the orientation cluster of the NBAS could be interpreted as an early marker of attention difficulties. For answering this question, the population as seen in the current study should be reassessed for attention difficulties and ADHD symptoms at school age.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Libbe Kooistra, PhD, Alberta Childrens Hospital, 1820 Richmond Rd (SW), Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2T 5C7. E-mail: libbe.kooistra{at}calgaryhealthregion.ca
The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. Moleti, V. P. Lo Presti, M. C. Campolo, F. Mattina, M. Galletti, M. Mandolfino, M. A. Violi, G. Giorgianni, D. De Domenico, F. Trimarchi, et al. Iodine Prophylaxis Using Iodized Salt and Risk of Maternal Thyroid Failure in Conditions of Mild Iodine Deficiency J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., July 1, 2008; 93(7): 2616 - 2621. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. L. Kitzmiller, J. M. Block, F. M. Brown, P. M. Catalano, D. L. Conway, D. R. Coustan, E. P. Gunderson, W. H. Herman, L. D. Hoffman, M. Inturrisi, et al. Managing Preexisting Diabetes for Pregnancy: Summary of evidence and consensus recommendations for care Diabetes Care, May 1, 2008; 31(5): 1060 - 1079. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. M. Casey, J. S. Dashe, C. Y. Spong, D. D. McIntire, K. J. Leveno, and G. F. Cunningham Perinatal Significance of Isolated Maternal Hypothyroxinemia Identified in the First Half of Pregnancy Obstet. Gynecol., May 1, 2007; 109(5): 1129 - 1135. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Hypothyroidism in the pregnant woman DTB, July 1, 2006; 44(7): 53 - 56. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||