Published online December 1, 2005
PEDIATRICS
Vol. 116
No. 6
December 2005, pp.
1604
(doi:10.1542/peds.2005-2197)
Left-Hemispheric Hydranencephaly With Less Favorable Findings: In Reply
Stephan Ulmer, MD
Olav Jansen, MD, PhD
Section of Neuroradiology,
University Hospital of Schleswig-Holstein,
24105 Kiel, Germany
In Reply.—
We appreciate the interest of Altschuler et al in our recent article. It is interesting to see that in hemihydranencephaly there seems to be a proclivity for absence of the left hemisphere as pointed out by Altschuler et al. Reviewing the other published cases,1–6 only 1 patient suffered from a lesion of the right hemisphere,1 which raises the question of hemispheric dominance and whether right-hemispheric hemihydranencephaly is less favorable in the clinical outcome. However, the reported patient who suffered from an absent right hemisphere1 only demonstrated mild mental retardation and contralateral hemiparesis and therefore presents a favorable outcome compared with the others. Which hemisphere is affected seems to be irrelevant to long-term outcome and survival, because reasonable outcome was also reported in the patient with the absent right hemisphere1 and demonstrated in our case7; however, 3 of the patients suffering from left-hemispheric hemihydranencephaly died in the follow-up period (personal communications with the author groups listed in refs 1–6, 2005) as a result of bronchopneumonia or related pulmonary problems. It cannot be answered, however, if right-hemispheric hemihydranencephaly is more reasonably unlivable.
The remarkable findings in our 36-year-old patient are his motor skills, which enable normal independent living. Impairment is the result of deficits in fine motor control as demonstrated in the Wolf Motor Function Test and the inability to perform the Perdue Pegboard. No aphasia could be found, and intellectual capacities, although not specifically tested, enabled the patient to complete school and vocational training.
As demonstrated in our case, the human immature brain is able to compensate for brain damage, if it occurs in very early childhood, to a remarkable outcome. All the reported patients demonstrated contralateral hemiparesis of various degrees. Our patient presented with strong mirror movements that also seem to become apparent in the Altschuler et al case as well. Mirror movements have been found in congenital hemiparetic patients with projections innervating both-sided motoneuron pools simultaneously by using transcranial magnetic stimulation8; however, mirror movements are physiologic until the age of 10 years and decrease with age9 but have been found in healthy adults during forceful complex movements10 demonstrating ipsilateral projections. As demonstrated by our patient with hemihydranencephaly,7 predefined motor areas such as the precentral gyrus seem to have the capacity to adopt similar or contralateral functions, which are executed by ipsilateral pathways; however, quality of motion and precision differs.
We strongly encourage Altschuler et al and other groups who are managing patients with hemihydranencephaly to join an international work group that we started when reviewing the literature. Because of the rare occurrence of this disorder, studies should be coordinated to answer questions of human brain development in a standardized manner, especially in these patients, giving the opportunity to examine the meaning of hemispheric dominance.
REFERENCES
- van Doornik MC, Heenekam RC. Hemi-hydranencephaly with favourable outcome.
Dev Med Child Neurol. 1992;34
:454
–458[Medline]
- Moser RP, Seljeskog EL. Unilateral hydranencephaly: case report.
Neurosurgery. 1981;9
:703
–705[Medline]
- Suzuki M, Seki H, Yoshimoto T. Unilateral hydrocephalus combined with occlusion of the ipsilateral internal carotid artery.
Surg Neurol. 1985;24
:27
–30[CrossRef][Medline]
- Ohtsuka H. A rare patient with a false median cleft lip associated with multiple congenital anomalies.
Ann Plast Surg. 1986;17
:155
–160[Medline]
- Porro G, Wittebol-Post D, de Graaf M, van Nieuwenhuizen O, Schenk-Rootlieb AJ, Treffers WF. Development of visual function in hemihydranencephaly.
Dev Med Child Neurol. 1998;40
:563
–567[Medline]
- Greco F, Finocchiaro M, Pavone P, Trifiletti RR, Parano E. Hemihydranencephaly: case report and literature review.
J Child Neurol. 2001;16
:218
–221[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Ulmer S, Moeller F, Brockmann MA, Kuhtz-Buschbeck JP, Stephani U, Jansen O. Living a normal life with the nondominant hemisphere: magnetic resonance imaging findings and clinical outcome for a patient with left-hemispheric hydranencephaly.
Pediatrics. 2005;116
:242
–245[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Carr LJ, Harrison LM, Evans AL, Stephens JA. Patterns of central motor reorganization in hemiplegic cerebral palsy.
Brain. 1993;116
:1223
–1247[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Mueller K, Kass-Iliyya F, Reitz M. Ontogeny of ipsilateral corticospinal projections: a developmental study with transcranial magnetic stimulation.
Ann Neurol. 1997;42
:705
–711[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
- Mayston MJ, Harrison LM, Stephens JA. A neurophysiological study of mirror movements in adults and children.
Ann Neurol. 1999;45
:583
–594[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
PEDIATRICS (ISSN 1098-4275). ©2005 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
Related articles in Pediatrics:
- Left-Hemispheric Hydranencephaly With Less Favorable Findings
- Eric Lewin Altschuler, Brittany Matsumura, Jaishree Capoor, Karen Weinshelbaum, and Hema Ghuznavi
Pediatrics 2005 116: 1603-1604.
[Extract]
[Full Text]
