



* Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Francisco, California
Departments of Psychology
Family and Human Development, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design. Participants were 666 females, aged 18 to 22 years, from 4 major ethnic groups in Arizona (non-Hispanic white, black, Latino, and Native American). All women included in the sample had experienced a pregnancy in their teens or early 20s. Participants completed a self-administered questionnaire that inquired about their timing of menarche, sexual initiation, first alcohol use, and age at first pregnancy. A mediating model predicting age at pregnancy was tested by using path modeling.
Results. Early puberty was found to be associated with earlier age of alcohol use and sexual initiation, which in turn predicted early pregnancy. Age at first sexual intercourse and age at first substance use significantly mediated the relation between age at menarche and age at first pregnancy. The results did not vary by ethnic group.
Conclusions. Girls who mature early are more likely to engage in early substance use and sexual intercourse, which in turn puts them at greater risk for adolescent pregnancy. It is important that health care providers are sensitive to the risks associated with early maturation among young girls and provide preventive screening, education, and counseling related to alcohol use and sexual initiation for this group.
Key Words: adolescent pregnancy adolescent sexual behavior early-onset puberty age at onset adolescent health
Abbreviations: RMSEA, root-mean-square error of approximation SRMR, standardized root-mean-square residual CFI, comparative fit index
The United States has the highest rate of teenage pregnancy among developed nations, with
822000 pregnancies occurring among women aged 15 to 19 years in 2000.1 Early onset of pubertal development consistently has been identified as a significant risk factor for early pregnancy as well as a host of other negative outcomes such as conduct problems,2 depression,3 early substance use,4 poor body image,5 and early sexual initiation.6 This study focuses on early initiation of alcohol use, sexual intercourse, and pregnancy. These outcomes are troublesome, because they may lead to longer-term trajectories that impede an early-maturing girl's success over her lifetime. In particular, a combination of alcohol use and sexual initiation at early ages may increase the risk for pregnancy, which in turn affects a girl's opportunities for attaining higher educational goals, decreases income-earning potential, and limits future options.7,8
Approximately 10% to 15% of young girls currently mature earlier than their peers and potentially suffer negative consequences as a result.9 Moreover, in the United States today, girls are entering puberty earlier than in the past; breast and pubic hair development occur up to 1 year earlier among preadolescent females than in the 1950s, and recent evidence suggests that the average age of menarche has decreased as well.10,11
| EARLY PUBERTY AS A RISK FACTOR |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Despite evidence of the direct links between early puberty and early substance-use initiation,4,19,20 early sexual intercourse,6,21,22 and early pregnancy,23,24 no studies have looked at the role that alcohol may play in terms of the timing of sexual intercourse and pregnancy among early maturers.
| EARLY INITIATION OF ALCOHOL USE |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| EARLY INITIATION OF SEXUAL INTERCOURSE |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| THE COMBINATION OF EARLY ALCOHOL USE AND SEXUAL INITIATION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| COMBINED RISK AMONG EARLY MATURERS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| OUR STUDY |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The study was based initially on a select subsample of 791 women who had experienced a pregnancy. However, preliminary analyses revealed that 125 women had experienced at least 1 of the proposed mediators (ie, initiation of sexual intercourse and/or alcohol use) before menarche. These women were eliminated from analyses. In addition to raising an issue of temporal precedence, these participants were qualitatively different. Two thirds of the women who experienced sexual intercourse before menarche reported that this sexual experience was unwanted (compared with 26% of those who experience sex after menarche), and 60% reported having been raped in their lifetime (compared with 26% of those who experienced sex after menarche).
Biases that may have emerged as a result of eliminating these participants were examined by comparing the 125 who were excluded to the 666 women who were included. Comparisons of demographic data indicated that there were no significant differences in terms of demographics. However, there were significant differences between the groups for the primary study variables: age at menarche [t(789) = 5.17; P < .001], age at first sexual intercourse [t(789) = 13.77; P < .001], and age at first alcohol use [t(789) = 12.20; P < .001]. On average, women who were included in the sample experienced these events earlier than those who were excluded. These differences were expected given the selection criteria for this sample.
The final sample for the study included 666 women whose ages ranged from 18 to 22 years (mean: 20.22; SD: 1.46). The ethnic breakdown of the sample was 13.8% black (N = 92), 28.7% non-Hispanic white (N = 191), 31.4% Latino (N = 209), 23.9% Native American (N = 159), and 2.0% other (N = 13). Two women (0.3%) were missing ethnicity data. Of the women, 57% lived in urban areas and 43% lived in rural areas. Nineteen percent were married, 31% were not married but were cohabitating, 7% were divorced or separated, 42% had never married, and <1% were widowed. Forty percent reported less than a high school education, 25% graduated from high school, and 35% had a college education. Ten percent of the sample had never worked, 62% were currently employed, and 28% were unemployed.
Procedure
Women were recruited at 44 different sites (eg, health clinics, colleges, private providers, shelters) in urban and rural areas throughout Arizona as well as on reservations. At each site, women in the target age group were approached by a female affiliated with the project who explained the purposes of the study, the anonymity of responses, and participants' rights. Participants subsequently completed an anonymous questionnaire, which was available in English or Spanish.
Measures
Age at Menarche
Age at menarche was assessed by using 1 question: "How old were you when you had your first menstrual period?" Response choices ranged from "8 years old or younger" to "17 or older," with each answer choice between these values representing a single year (9, 10, 11, etc). Although menarche occurs relatively late in the pubertal process, it is often used as a proxy for the onset of puberty. Self-reports of age at menarche have proven to be accurate across ages and birth cohorts, and retrospective reports of menarche are reliable up to several decades later.44,45
Age at First Pregnancy
Age at first pregnancy was assessed by using 1 question: "How old were you the FIRST time you became pregnant?" Note that this question refers to first pregnancy rather than first live childbirth. This item was followed up with questions about the result of the first pregnancy (eg, delivered, abortion), which further clarified the intent of the question. Response choices ranged from "13 or younger" to "22 years old," with each choice between these values representing a single year.
Age at First Sexual Intercourse
Age at first sexual intercourse was assessed by using 1 question: "How old were you when you first had sex?" Response choices ranged from "8 or younger" to "22 years old," with each value in between representing a single year.
Age at First Alcohol Use
Age at first alcohol use was assessed by using 1 question: "How old were you when you first began to drink alcoholic beverages (not including religious ceremonies)?" Responses ranged from "9 or younger" to "18 years old."
Ethnicity
Ethnicity was measured by using a 1-item self-report measure: "Which of the following best describes you?" Answer choices included (1) Anglo or non-Hispanic white, (2) African American or black, (3) Hispanic, Latino, or Chicano, (4) Native American or American Indian, and (5) other.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
2 test of fit, the root-mean-square error of approximation (RMSEA), the standardized root-mean-square residual (SRMR), and the comparative fit index (CFI). Based on these indices, results from our analyses indicate that the overall fit of the model was good [
2(2) (N = 666) = 3.12; P = .21; RMSEA = .03; SRMR = .02; CFI = 1.00]. As shown in Fig 1, standardized path coefficients, which are equivalent to ß weights in multiple regression, were significant (at P < .001) and in the expected directions. Age at menarche related to both age at first alcohol use (ß = .26; z = 6.91) and age at first sex (ß = .16; z = 4.63). Age at first alcohol use directly and positively related to age at first sex (ß = .40; z = 11.14), which in turn had a significant path to age at first pregnancy (ß = .56; z = 17.59). On the basis of Sobel's test of mediation,48 the mediated (or indirect) effects for menarche on age at first sex (z = 5.87) and age at first pregnancy (z = 6.62) were also significant, supporting the inclusion of the mediators. In addition, the squared multiple correlation for age at first pregnancy was .32, which represents the proportion of variance accounted for in age at first pregnancy and is reflective of the indirect effect of menarche on pregnancy through the proposed mediators.
Testing Across Ethnic Subgroups
The path model was examined across the 4 ethnic groups for configural invariance, which tests whether the model form varies across groups (ie, without constraining the path coefficients to be invariant). The proposed mediational model provided a good overall fit across ethnic groups [
2(8) = 11.85; P = .16; RMSEA = .05; CFI = .99]. The model then was tested for pattern invariance, whereby the path parameters were constrained across groups, which provides a test of whether the model form and the values of the path coefficients are equivalent across groups. Overall fit indices suggested that when path values were constrained, the model continued to provide a good fit across groups [
2(20) = 22.74; P = .30; RMSEA = .03; CFI = .99], indicating that the relations seem to operate similarly regardless of ethnicity.
Secondary Analyses
Because menarche serves as a proxy measure of pubertal timing (and occurs rather late in the pubertal process), secondary analyses were conducted that included the 125 women who experienced intercourse and/or alcohol use before menarche. These women had experienced significantly earlier sexual intercourse and alcohol use than their counterparts. The results were consistent with primary findings. The mediating model provided a good overall fit [
2 (2) (N = 761) = 7.72; P = .02; RMSEA = .06; SRMR = .03; CFI = .98], and all paths were significant (at P < .001) and in the expected directions: menarche to alcohol use (ß = .13; z = 3.79); menarche to sex (ß = .20; z = 6.02); alcohol use to sex (ß = .33; z = 10.09); sex to pregnancy (ß = .46; z = 14.46).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Early sexual initiation has been found to relate to multiple sexual partners before adulthood, higher rates of sexually transmitted disease, increased emotional distress, and higher rates of pregnancy termination, pregnancy complications, and preterm delivery.8,34,35 Moreover, it is conceivable that risk for these outcomes is further enhanced when sexual behavior is initiated in combination with early alcohol use. Pregnancy at a young age also predicts a host of more distal problem outcomes including increased high school drop-out rates, poorer employment rates, and emotional distress/depression.7 Thus, early identification of girls who are more likely to engage in high-risk behaviors, including early sex and early alcohol use, is critical to better focus teen pregnancy-prevention efforts.
Clinical Implications
Results from our study have strong implications for clinical practice. Early maturation serves as a significant stressor for young girls and puts them at risk for multiple problems during adolescence and, potentially, into adulthood. These findings underscore the importance of informing clinical providers of the risks associated with early pubertal development. Because pediatricians are typically the first to identify signs of early maturation, they are in the best position to provide early intervention by informing and educating young girls about their changing bodies and talking with parents about related health and behavioral risks. In addition, providers should consider screening for alcohol use among early-maturing girls as a means to better focus preventive efforts.
In terms of sexual behavior, it is important to note that early maturers are unlikely to receive effective or timely intervention in the school setting, which makes pediatrician intervention even more critical. Schools tend to begin sexual education in senior high school, potentially long after early maturers have initiated problem behaviors. Moreover, the models of abstinence (for substances and sex) typically presented in schools as effective intervention tools have not been validated empirically by recent research. Intervention efforts tend to intervene in 1 domain (eg, DARE for drugs, abstinence programs for sex) rather than comprehensively addressing multiple problem behaviors that are clearly linked. Pregnancy-prevention efforts among clinicians should include a focus on alcohol use in an effort to help young girls and their parents understand how related behaviors, in combination with early sexual activity, increase risk for early pregnancy. Clinicians should inform parents also about the problems of relying on school-based intervention when it comes to informing their early-maturing daughters about sexual development, safe sex, and the consequences of early sexual behavior. Moreover, it is important to consider the cognitive developmental level of young adolescents when intervening.
Limitations
Only women who experienced a first pregnancy by their late teens or early 20s were included in this study; therefore, there are likely to be characteristics or patterns that are specific to this group of females. Caution should be used when generalizing these findings to a broader population of adolescents. All measures in this study were self-reported, retrospective, and subject to social desirability; however, past studies have found that women report the age at first menarche with relative accuracy.44,45 Finally, these data are cross-sectional and provide no way of establishing either the temporal proximity or order of the behaviors studied.
Future Research Directions
In terms of prevention science and social policy, it is important to promote research that investigates empirically sound prevention methods for early sexual behavior and alcohol use among early-maturing youth. Additional theory development is necessary to better understand the complex sequence of events initiated when girls experience early puberty. There is a strong need for prospective studies to assess more rigorously the sequence of events initiated by early puberty. Through the use of daily diaries, one might elucidate how these events unfold and their respective timing. The adolescent population presents an interesting challenge in terms of obtaining accurate and consistent reporting of problem behaviors. Perhaps by using handheld electronic devices, our technically savvy generation of teens would be more likely to self-record daily behaviors, providing closer estimates of the timing of events.
In future studies, it also will be crucial to incorporate multiple measures of pubertal timing to better understand which pubertal changes trigger certain emotions and behaviors. Measurement batteries should include subjective (eg, self-report of Tanner stages) and objective (eg, hormonal assays) reports as well as measures from significant others (eg, clinical providers, parents). In addition, a more complex exploration of psychological mediators is warranted. Of particular interest for future studies are the individual psychological processes (eg, self-esteem, reactions to menarche) and interpersonal processes (eg, peers, family) that may influence these relations. Also of interest are the potentially variable effects across specific contexts (eg, all-girls' schools versus mixed-gender schools, ethnic homogeneity in schools).
Our study lays a foundation for future studies to explore targeted points of intervention for diverse ethnic groups. Although findings indicated that relations between the variables hold across ethnic groups, "1-size-fits-all" interventions will not necessarily be uniformly effective for girls from all backgrounds. The need for cultural sensitivity and cultural relevance when developing interventions is already recognized at a national level. Toward this aim, we need to step back and explore processes that are most salient for teenage girls and attempt to decipher common sequences or patterns across ethnic/social groups and contexts. Results from this study are significant in confirming the link between early menarche and a cluster of problem behaviors that can potentially put girls at risk for negative long-term outcomes. Focus groups with early-developing females would help us better understand these processes and how they may vary. In particular, with careful sampling across ethnic, geographic, and socioeconomic backgrounds, potential group differences in girls' experiences may emerge.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We gratefully acknowledge Mary Davis and Jenn-Yun Tein for assistance with this manuscript, as well as the participation of the cooperating agencies and the women who contributed to this research.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Julianna Deardorff, PhD, Department of Psychiatry, Health Psychology Program, University of California, 3333 California St, Suite 465, Box 0848, San Francisco, CA 94118. E-mail: jdeardor{at}itsa.ucsf.edu
No conflict of interest declared.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||