




* Division of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Department of Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Science, Neuropsychiatric Institute, University of California, Los Angeles, California
Behavioral Sciences Department, La Rabida Childrens Hospital, Chicago, Illinois
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods. One hundred four adolescents, ages 12 to 20 years (mean: 15.7; SD: 2.1), completed and returned the University of California, Los Angeles, PTSD Index for the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. All participants were at least 1 year post-initial transplant and were fluent speakers of English and/or Spanish.
Results. More than 16% of the adolescents met all symptom criteria for PTSD, and an additional 14.4% met 2 of 3 symptom-cluster criteria. Regression analysis indicated no effect of gender, ethnicity, age at interview, organ type, time since transplant, or age at transplant.
Conclusions. As has been found with other life-threatening pediatric conditions, solid organ transplantation can precipitate symptoms of posttraumatic stress. Symptoms are not predicted by what would be considered objective factors increasing life threat, suggesting a greater salience of subjective appraisal of threat, as has been seen in studies of childhood cancer survivors.
Key Words: transplant psychological impact PTSD adolescents Hispanic American
Abbreviations: PTSD, posttraumatic stress disorder UCLA, University of California, Los Angeles DSM, Diagnostic Statistical Manual OR, odds ratio
Improvements in immunosuppression and surgical innovations such as use of partial livers have radically changed the prognosis for pediatric solid organ transplant recipients over the past 2 decades and led to the creation of transplant centers across the United States. In 2003, the 3-year survival rate ranged from 95% to 97% for pediatric kidney recipients, 76% to 80% for liver transplant recipients, and 74% to 79% for heart transplant recipients.1 However, despite the improved survival, pediatric organ transplantation is not without risks and costs, both physical and psychological. The major surgical procedures leave large and permanent scars, and the daily immunosuppressive medications serve as a lifelong reminder of the brush with death.
The threat to life that is inherent in organ transplantation has raised the question of whether organ transplantation could be experienced by pediatric recipients as a traumatic event. Before the mid-1990s, it was believed that posttraumatic stress symptoms only occurred in response to extraordinary events such as war, child abuse or molestation, or exposure to natural disaster. However, over the past 10 years, there has been a growing body of literature demonstrating that a small but significant number of children and adolescents report posttraumatic stress responses to medically life-threatening situations such as cancer and diabetes.26
Symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are categorized by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) of Mental Disorders, Version 4,7 in 3 symptom clusters: reexperiencing, avoidance, and arousal. Reexperiencing symptoms include recurrent and distressing recollections of the event, repeated distressing dreams of the event, acting or feeling as though the traumatic event were recurring (flashbacks), intense psychological distress at exposure to reminders, and physiologic reactivity to reminders. Avoidance symptoms consist not only of efforts to avoid thoughts or places associated with the traumatic event but also inability to recall important aspects of the event, diminished interest in activities, feelings of detachment from others, restricted range of affect, and a sense of foreshortened future. Increased arousal is characterized by difficulty falling or staying asleep, irritability, difficulty concentrating, hypervigilance, and exaggerated startle response. Clearly, many of these symptoms are seen in other psychiatric conditions. The diagnosis is only made if the individual has (1) experienced, witnessed, or confronted an event involving actual or threatened death or serious injury to self or others, (2) reacted to the event with intense fear, helplessness, or horror, (3) experienced at least 1 reexperiencing symptom, 3 avoidance symptoms, and 2 increased arousal symptoms for >1 month, and (4) the symptoms cause clinically significant distress or functional impairment.
To date, there are only 3 published studies that examine traumatic stress symptoms in pediatric organ transplant recipients. Two included only liver transplant recipients, and all 3 looked at very small samples. Shemesh et al8 reported on a pilot study of 19 pediatric liver transplant recipients referred for nonadherence to medical regimens. Six of 19 patients met criteria for PTSD. Three of these 6 patients (and none of the others) were considered significantly nonadherent by the panel of clinicians. Treatment of the posttraumatic stress symptoms resulted in improvements in the adherence. Walker et al9 studied 18 liver transplant recipients between 7 and 16 years old and found that they reported significantly more symptoms of posttraumatic stress than a comparison group of children who had a chronic life-threatening illness or had undergone a routine surgical operation. Wallace et al10 evaluated 64 renal transplant recipients, 6 to 21 years of age, with self-report measures and art-based assessments. They found that 36% of the study population had symptoms consistent with depression and/or posttraumatic stress.
Studies of adult organ transplant recipients have also suggested that transplantation might be experienced as a traumatic event. In a study of 158 adult heart transplant recipients and 142 family caregivers, 10.5% of the recipients and 7.7% of the caregivers met full criteria for PTSD. An additional 5% of the recipients and 11% of the caregivers were considered to be probable cases of PTSD.11
Here we report on the first large investigation to assess symptoms of posttraumatic stress in a nonreferred sample of pediatric liver, heart, and kidney transplant recipients. Building on the studies discussed above, the specific objectives of this descriptive study were to (1) assess prevalence of self-reported PTSD symptoms in adolescent kidney, heart, and liver transplant recipients, (2) compare the prevalence of PTSD symptoms in liver, heart, and kidney transplant recipients, and (3) examine the relationship of specific demographic and medical variables to the severity of PTSD symptoms reported.
Hypotheses to be investigated included the following:
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Subject Recruitment
A list of 282 patients who conformed to the age and postsurgical interval criteria was generated from a comprehensive list of all pediatric heart, liver, or kidney transplants performed at UCLA between 1980 and 1999. This list was reviewed by members of the transplant teams, who excluded 53 recipients who had died and 22 who should not be contacted about the study for other reasons (including living in another country, unsuccessful transplant surgery, and significant developmental delay or learning disorder). Invitations to participate in the study were mailed to the remaining 207 eligible adolescents (and their caregivers, when the potential participants were under the age of 18). Forty-seven adolescents could not be located and were thus considered lost to follow-up. Of the remaining 160 adolescents, 49 refused participation and 111 agreed to participate in the study (69% response rate). Seven subjects had incomplete data sets, yielding a total analyzable sample of 104 adolescents.
Those who indicated their refusal to participate via postcards included with the invitation letter were not contacted again. Transplant recipients who expressed interest in the study and those who had not declined after a 2-week period were contacted by telephone. Trained members of the research team described the study to the adolescent and parent and assessed their interest in participating. In accordance with the UCLA Institutional Review Board, informed consent was obtained from participants
18 years of age and from parents of participants <18; assent was obtained from all participants <18 years of age. Adolescents who agreed to participate were interviewed by trained research assistants using standardized instruments. Attempts were made to schedule in-person interviews before or after scheduled visits to UCLA outpatient transplant clinics for patient and family convenience. When participants did not have an upcoming appointment, telephone interviews were arranged. In those cases, adolescents were first mailed the questionnaires in a sealed envelope and instructed not to open them until the time of the interview. Parents were asked not to open the envelopes (which were addressed to the adolescents) and not to listen in while the adolescent was on the phone doing the interview. Both in person and by telephone, the interviewer read a portion of the questions (demographic form and open-ended questions) to the adolescent and recorded the participants answers. Adolescents filled out the remaining questionnaires with the assistance of the interviewer when needed. Participants received 2 movie passes as compensation for their time and participation.
Assessment of PTSD Symptoms
The UCLA PTSD Index for the DSM12 was completed by each adolescent transplant recipient. The UCLA PTSD Index for the DSM is a well-established, 22-item self-report instrument used to measure symptoms of PTSD in adolescents ages 1220. The current version is designed to correspond to the items and symptom clusters used in the diagnostic criteria for PTSD as defined by the DSM.7
This measure is currently the most commonly used self-report tool for assessing posttraumatic stress in children and adolescents and has been translated into many languages. Versions of this measure have been used over the past 15 years to study symptoms in children traumatized by various stressors around the world including a sniper attack on a school playground,13 witnessing a sexual assault,14 a school shooting,15 an earthquake,16 the Gulf War,17 a SCUD missile attack,18 cancer,7 the bombing of the Oklahoma City Federal Building,19 and pediatric liver transplant.8 The reaction index for this study was translated and back-translated by native Mexican Spanish speakers for consistency to the intent of the original wording of the measure. Six of the 104 adolescents preferred to complete the measure in Spanish. These adolescents were interviewed in Spanish by native speakers using the Spanish version of the measure.
The PTSD Index assesses 7 avoidance, 5 hyperarousal, and 5 reexperiencing symptoms. Each item is rated in frequency experienced in the last month: 0 indicates "none"; 1, "a little" (twice a month); 2, "some" (twice a week); 3, "much" (3 times per week); or 4, "most of the time." Participants who endorsed a minimum of 1 reexperiencing item, 2 avoidance items, and 3 hyperarousal items at a severity level of at least 3 ("much") per item were classified as "full PTSD likely." Participants who met criteria for 2 of 3 symptom clusters were classified as "partial PTSD likely." A continuous measure of severity of each posttraumatic stress symptom cluster was obtained by summing severity ratings for each item (04).
Potential Predictors of PTSD
Demographic variables included gender, ethnicity, age at interview, age at transplant (before or after the age of 6), time since transplant, and type of transplant (heart, liver, or kidney). Data for the illness-related variables were collected by chart review. Specific aspects of each childs transplant and illness-related medical histories were coded into categories based on onset and course. Although the general distinctions among the categories remain consistent across services, slight variations in the definition were permitted to accurately represent the nature of the diseases of each particular organ system. Acute onset was characterized as the sudden onset of life-threatening illness, with time between diagnosis and transplant typically being brief (<3 days for liver, <3 months for heart, and immediate need for dialysis for kidney). Chronic onset was characterized by an illness that progresses over time, a condition that may have been present from birth, and a time between diagnosis and transplant of usually >1 year.
A chart review was also used to measure severity of the subjects medical condition over the 2 years before the date of interview for this study. The severity rating was mild or moderate to severe and was based on specific factors: (1) number of hospital days; (2) number of intensive care unit days; (3) retransplantation (yes/no); and (4) return to dialysis (yes/no).
Data Analysis
Descriptive data are reported for prevalence of PTSD symptoms. Univariate analysis of variance was used to examine severity of symptoms as a function of individual demographic and illness-related variables. Binary (full PTSD likely versus none) logistic-regression analysis with backward elimination was used to identify predictors of PTSD status from the potential demographic and illness-related variables. To examine the reliability of variables to predict groups meeting 2 or 3 symptom criteria or none, analyses were repeated with a more liberal criteria (PTSD-symptomatic versus none) and with linear regression for a 3-level outcome: "full PTSD likely" (met all symptom criteria), "partial PTSD likely" (met 2 symptom cluster criteria), or "no symptoms." Exploratory analyses were also undertaken to examine the relationships between predictor variables and the severity of each symptom cluster.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
However, contrary to our hypothesis, the type of transplant, with the corresponding difference in prognosis, did not predict the presence of significant PTSD symptoms. That is, although dialysis offers a life-saving alternative for kidney transplant recipients in case of rejection, the kidney transplant recipients did not report significantly fewer symptoms in response to the transplant experience than the heart or liver transplant recipients, which seems to reflect the greater salience of subjective appraisal of threat, compared with the "objective data" of statistical reports. In fact, it was the adolescents with mild, rather than moderate or severe complications of the transplant, who were more likely to report symptoms of posttraumatic stress. These findings are consistent with findings from the study of childhood cancer survivors, in which the majority of the variance was accounted for by the individuals trait anxiety and their perception of life threat, not by more objective measures of severity of illness or complications.6 Additional study is needed to determine if these are also salient elements of the medical experience for pediatric transplant recipients.
As hypothesized, adolescents with an acute onset of the illness that precipitated the need for the transplant were more likely to report symptoms of posttraumatic stress. This is consistent with clinical observations that previously healthy children with abrupt organ failure experience organ transplants as more intrusive and life changing than those who have organ transplants as a result of congenital or chronic illnesses. In practical terms, children in the acute situation were less healthy and had to take more medications after the transplant than they had in their usual life before the transplant, whereas in the more chronic cases children felt better and took fewer medications after the transplant. Moreover, this difference in response seems to be long-lasting, because this is seen in children who are varied numbers of months and years posttransplant. Although this finding will have to be replicated, it could be useful in identifying children and families at risk for psychological problems.
There are some obvious limitations to this study. The adolescents studied had received their transplants at varying ages and in different years. The specific techniques and immunosuppressant medications used in transplantation changed between 1980 and 1999, and children of different ages understand the experience of the transplant differently depending on their developmental levels. However, it is somewhat surprising that no significant independent impact on outcome was found for the age and time variables, "time since transplant" or "age at time of transplant."
Another limitation is the lack of a well-established Spanish-language version of the PTSD Reaction Index. The version we used was translated and back-translated specifically for this study. It has subsequently been used by other research groups but has not undergone formal validity testing. However, given the large number of pediatric organ transplant recipients who are primarily Spanish speaking at this center, it seemed important to include them in this study. Larger studies will allow additional exploration of language as a variable in PTSD.
The use of hospitalizations, intensive care unit stays, or retransplantation as a proxy for medical complications is a rough approximation and may not be a valid measure of this variable. A study is now ongoing to investigate the utility of this type of assessment using prospective data with a larger transplant population.
Clinical Implications
Identification of children who have responded to medical procedures such as organ transplantation with posttraumatic stress is not purely of academic interest. There is a growing body of literature that suggests that PTSD can have "a cascading negative effect on childrens development and functioning."23 A study of 59 traumatized children and adolescents found that there was substantial clinical impairment and distress for both those who met criteria for all 3 symptom clusters and those who met the criteria for only 2.24 In a recent study of young adults who are survivors of childhood cancers, posttraumatic stress was related not only to poor psychological adjustment but also to significantly lower function in areas such as school, work, and personal relationships.25 Additional research will be needed to establish the relationship of posttraumatic stress symptoms to academic and social functioning in organ transplant recipients. However, there are already provocative data to suggest a relationship between nonadherence to medications and posttraumatic stress in pediatric liver transplant recipients.8 Although replication is needed, this would represent an important insight into a significant clinical problem.
This study demonstrates how difficult it is to predict which child or adolescent will respond to solid organ transplantation with posttraumatic stress symptoms. Studies of childhood cancer suggest that the childs appraisal of threat to their life bears little or no relationship to the appraisal of prognosis by the physician.6 Current clinical efforts are under way to prevent the development of posttraumatic stress responses in medical settings through "trauma-aware" care, which focuses on decreasing the helplessness and fear that transforms a stressful procedure or event into a traumatic one. Much of this involves education and support for parents, who generally serve as the indicator for children of the degree of danger.6 Studies of mothers of bone marrow transplant patients and cancer survivors demonstrate the consistently higher percentage of mothers who report symptoms consistent with a diagnosis of PTSD.2,26 As in so much of pediatric care, effective interventions to treat or prevent PTSD must start with the families.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Reprint requests to (M.L.S.) 760 Westwood Plaza, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute, Los Angeles, CA 90024-1759. E-mail: mstuber{at}mednet.ucla.edu
No conflict of interest declared.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||