ELECTRONIC ARTICLE |




* Infectious Diseases Unit, Pediatrics Department, Integrated Unit Hospital Sant Joan de Déu, Hospital Clinic, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
Laboratory Department, Hospital Sant Joan de Déu, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
Catalan Agency for Health Technology Assessment and Research, Catalan Health Service, Department of Health and Social Security, Generalitat de Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods. We conducted a prospective observational study of 127 HIV-uninfected infants who were born to HIV-infected women. Clinical symptoms suggesting mitochondrial dysfunction were analyzed in routine follow-up, and LA and alanine plasma levels were obtained at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months in all patients. Elevated alanine levels, together with hyperlactatemia, suggest chronic mitochondrial injury.
Results. Most (85%) women received highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) during pregnancy (mean duration: 31 weeks) and zidovudine during labor (93%). Most (96%) children received zidovudine alone. Hyperlactatemia with hyperalaninemia was detected in 63 children in at least 1 of the measurements. Mean LA levels were significantly higher in children who were exposed to nucleoside analogue reverse transcriptase inhibitors than in control subjects (2.88 vs 1.61 at 6 weeks, 2.78 vs 1.49 at 3 months, 1.89 vs 1.39 at 6 months, and 1.71 vs 1.24 at 12 months; peak levels: 8.06, 10.1, 7.28, and 4.48 mmol/L, respectively). In 44 patients, LA levels progressed spontaneously to normality within the first year of life. Three girls presented a slight and self-limited delay in psychomotor development, with LA peak levels of 7.3, 4.0, and 4.6 mmol/L. Only the gestational use of didanosine was associated with a higher risk of hyperlactatemia.
Conclusions. In our series, almost half of the children (63 of 127) who were exposed to nucleoside analogues developed benign and self-limited hyperlactatemia. When symptomatic, nucleoside analogueinduced toxicity affected neurologic development.
Key Words: alanine children HAART HIV infection hyperlactatemia mitochondria vertical transmission
Abbreviations: HIV, human immunodeficiency virus ARV, antiretroviral NRTI, nucleoside analogue reverse transcriptase inhibitor LA, lactate HLA, hyperlactatemia HCV, hepatitis C virus HBV, hepatitis B virus ZDV, zidovudine HAART, highly active antiretroviral therapy 3TC, lamivudine d4T, stavudine NVP, nevirapine NFV, nelfinavir ddI, didanosine
Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) vertical transmission rates have been dramatically reduced in developed countries thanks to antiretroviral (ARV) treatments, elective cesarean section, and refraining from breastfeeding.1 The morbidity that ARV may cause in fetal and early life of HIV-uninfected children is still unclear, and thorough research of this condition is warranted.
Nucleoside analogue reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NRTIs) are included in most ARV regimens. These drugs inhibit both HIV reverse transcriptase and DNA polymerase
, an essential protein for mitochondrial DNA replication in human cells.24 Mitochondria are basic for the generation of adenosine triphosphate through oxidative phosphorylation. When this system is disturbed, an altered oxidoreduction status occurs, shifting the pyruvate/lactate (LA) equilibrium in the direction of LA; similarly, an increase in ketone bodies and alanine is observed.5,6 Because mitochondria are ubiquitous, impaired oxidative phosphorylation may affect virtually all organ systems, giving rise to a variety of clinical syndromes.5,7
Inherited mitochondrial diseases may affect infants to different degrees: from a severe multisystemic illness that leads to death in some to an oligosymptomatic syndrome with nonspecific mild symptoms or signs that can easily be associated with other conditions such as prematurity, maternal drug addiction, acute fetal distress, or congenital infections.5,7,8 The latter evolution is more likely to occur in the HIV-uninfected infant, considering that exposure to ARV does not exceed the age of 6 weeks and in light of the reassuring data from large observational studies.9 Therefore, the identification of children who are affected by NRTI-induced mitochondrial toxicity has become a great challenge for pediatricians. Moreover, the potential for long-term adverse effects on a developing organism, especially regarding high-energy-requirement tissues (nervous system or muscle), remains unknown. Although sophisticated diagnostic procedures are often required to confirm a mitochondrial disease, blood LA levels have been used as a screening tool for mitochondrial dysfunction5,8 despite its lack of specificity and its technical and physiologic variability.10
To date, reports concerning NRTI toxicity in children who are exposed perinatally to ARV are contradictory. Although large population-based studies have failed to demonstrate signs or symptoms suggesting mitochondrial injury in NRTI-exposed HIV-uninfected children,9,1113 other authors have reported rare severe neurologic damage consistent with mitochondrial dysfunction14,15 and a higher risk of febrile seizures below the age of 18 months16 in these otherwise healthy patients. The aim of our study was to determine the prevalence, clinical consequences, evolution, and risk factors for hyperlactatemia (HLA) in our cohort of HIV-uninfected infants who were exposed to ARV during gestation, labor, and/or the neonatal period.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Demographic, clinical, and laboratory data were routinely collected on all of our patients. The variables that were relevant to this study included mother's age, third-trimester HIV-RNA viral load and CD4 T-cell count, type and timing of ARV therapy, and history of substance abuse during pregnancy; mother's hepatitis C virus (HCV) and hepatitis B virus (HBV) co-infection; mode of delivery; intrapartum use of zidovudine (ZDV); infant's gender, Apgar scores, gestational age, and birth weight; and vertical transmission of HIV, HBV, and/or HCV and exposure to ARV during the neonatal period.
A complete physical examination was performed, and height, weight, and head circumference were measured at every visit (at birth and at 15 days; 6 weeks; and 3, 6, and 12 months of life). Full blood picture and serum biochemistry, including venous blood gas, pH measurements, and liver enzyme tests, were obtained together with plasma proviral HIV-DNA (Amplicor HIV; Roche, Basel, Switzerland) and HIV-RNA load quantification (CA HIV-1 Monitor; Roche; limit of <50 copies/mL) at every visit.
Infants were eligible for the study when 2 negative results in HIV-DNA molecular tests were available, usually at birth and at the age of 2 weeks; had been exposed to ARV during gestation, labor, and/or the neonatal period; and did not present any other medical condition capable of raising plasma LA levels (eg, congenital heart defects, inborn errors of metabolism, prematurity). Ulterior HIV-DNA and/or HIV-RNA molecular tests were performed in all cases to confirm absence of HIV infection beyond the age of 4 months, in accordance with current guidelines.17
Deproteinized venous blood LA levels (normal range: 0.772.44 mmol/L until the age of 1 year18) were measured by a spectrometric procedure in a Cobas Fara II Analyzer (Roche) at 6 weeks and 3, 6, and 12 months of life. Because of great physiologic variability of LA levels, all samples not obtained under optimal conditions (previous rest for 15 minutes, avoiding tourniquets when possible, and immediate blood flowing after venipuncture) were excluded from the study. Samples were immediately placed on ice and assayed within 20 minutes. Whenever LA values were above the reference range, plasma alanine concentrations (reference range [mean ± SD]: 312 ± 78 µmol/L) were measured by ion exchange chromatography with ninhydrin detection in the same blood sample (Biochrom 20; Pharmacia, Biotech, Cambridge, United Kingdom). Chronic mitochondrial dysfunction leads to HLA and hyperalaninemia; therefore, ARV toxicityrelated HLA was considered only when both LA and alanine concentrations were elevated; otherwise, these were regarded as transient HLA values as a result of blood drawing and excluded from the study as well. Finally, LA levels from infants who were exposed to ARV were compared with LA concentrations, age and gender adjusted, obtained from anonymous blood samples of children who were referred to our laboratory for presurgical routine blood analysis. Analytical procedures and normal gender- and age-matched concentrations for LA and alanine techniques were previously validated in our laboratory and have been reported elsewhere.18,19
Statistical Analysis
Patients were initially defined as HLA or non-HLA. Univariate assessment of risk factors for HLA was conducted using the
2 test for categorical variables and the t test for continuous variables. To measure further the independent association between the exposure to different NRTIs (weeks of exposure) and elevated LA concentrations, we used multiple logistic regression allowing for the repeated measures. Other statistical tests were used when appropriate. All tests were 2-tailed, and P < .05 was considered significant. Statistical analysis was performed with the SPSS 10.0 Program.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
Three female infants developed neurologic symptoms consistent with mitochondrial dysfunction together with HLA. Patient 1 had been exposed to ddI, d4T, and NFV during gestation and intrapartum ZDV at 37 weeks of gestational, and she received ZDV during her first 6 weeks of life. At 2 months of age, she presented with mild axial hypotonia and poor head control and needed early stimulation for 5 months, with good clinical evolution. Patient 2 was exposed to ZDV, 3TC, NVP, and benzodiazepines from the fifth month of gestation, when HIV infection was diagnosed in her mother. She was born at 38 weeks of gestational, with ZDV use during labor, and she also received a 6-week course of ZDV. At 2 months of age, she presented with mild limb spasticity, axial hypotonia, and retention of primitive reflexes, symptoms that had settled down by the age of 6 months. Patient 3 was exposed to 3TC, d4T, and NVP during the whole gestation; her mother was a heavy smoker. Born at 37 weeks of gestational, she also received intrapartum and neonatal ZDV. At 6 months of age, she developed poor head control, was unable to sit unaided, and showed upper limb spasticity and adduced thumbs at physical examination. Additional clinical controls have shown a good clinical evolution toward normalization at the age of 1 year. Cerebral ultrasounds were normal in all cases. Evolution of LA levels for these 3 patients is shown in Fig 1. Additional neurologic evolution and LA levels have been normal in all of them to date (23, 30, and 27 months of age, respectively).
No symptoms consistent with LA acidosis were observed during the study. However, an inverse correlation was found between LA plasma levels and pH values (Pearson correlation test: r = 0.491, P < .0001).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Data regarding NRTI-induced HLA in the pediatric age are still scarce. To our knowledge, only 1 case of LA acidosis in an HIV-infected infant has been described, by Church et al.26 We recently documented a prevalence rate of 17% (14 of 80) for asymptomatic HLA in our cohort of HIV-infected pediatric patients,27 after using the same inclusion criteria for LA measurements. These data are similar to those reported by Desai et al28 (prevalence rate: 32%, 41 of 127 patients) in the other pediatric series in which LA levels have been investigated.
The results in our study are similar to those reported by the only 2 series of HIV-uninfected infants in whom LA plasma levels were documented. Giaquinto et al29 described 17 (85%) of 20 infants who were followed up to a mean age of 7 months with transient asymptomatic HLA (>2.5 mmol/L) at least once during the study, whereas Alimenti et al30 reported a prevalence rate of 92% for HLA in their cohort (35 of 38 infants; LA levels
2.1 mmol/L) that was followed up to the age of 6 months. Both groups of authors described a trend toward normalization of LA levels with time, which has been found to be statistically significant in our cohort. Compared with our series, a higher incidence of HLA is reported; this may be attributable to the more restrictive inclusion criteria that we used. The physiologic and technical variability of plasma LA determination is a widely recognized drawback of this technique. The exclusion of blood samples that were obtained under nonoptimal conditions and the concomitant determination of alanine levels probably minimized this problem in our study. Moreover, the use of a large control group at every age with statistically significant lower LA values compared with those from NRTI-exposed infants strengthens our findings.
It is remarkable that the prevalence for HLA is higher in HIV-uninfected infants who are exposed perinatally to ARV than in HIV-infected pediatric patients on chronic HAART. These findings may be partially explained by a chronic adaptation to NRTI toxicity, similar to that reported in HIV-infected adult patients.22,23,31 However, one could also hypothesize that the higher energy requirements of a developing organism in the first months of life may make these patients more vulnerable to NRTI toxicity. In fact, in our previous study in HIV-infected pediatric patients,27 only a younger age at the beginning of antiretroviral treatment was found to be a statistically significant risk factor to develop HLA.
A recent study by Poirier et al,32 based on a small group of children, demonstrated that infants who are born to HIV-infected untreated mothers have significantly lower mitochondrial DNA content in peripheral blood leukocytes when compared with control subjects. This depletion in mitochondrial DNA persists up to the age of 2 years and is further increased when mothers receive ZDV during pregnancy. Similar genetic findings have been reported in naïve HIV-infected adult patients,33 suggesting that HIV may play a role in mitochondrial damage. Our study confirms a high prevalence of HLA in HIV-uninfected infants who are exposed to ARV. Similarly, 3 patients in our cohort still showed elevated LA levels at the age of 2 years. These genetic and biochemical findings strongly hint at the possibility of a clinical syndrome caused by NRTI toxicity, despite the population-based studies that have failed to demonstrate signs or symptoms suggesting mitochondrial injury in these patients.9,1113
In adult patients, several NRTI-associated adverse effects have been recognized: myopathy,34 LA acidosis,20,21 osteopenia,35 neuropathy,36 fat maldistribution, and dyslipidemias37 are the most important and frequent of these. The few articles regarding NRTI-induced toxicity in the pediatric age mainly describe neurologic symptoms similar to those of inherited mitochondrial diseases5,7,8: developmental retardation, seizures, and HLA. In the French cohort,14,15 which included 2644 HIV-uninfected NRTI-exposed infants, the 18-month incidence for demonstrated mitochondrial dysfunction was 0.26%. Most of these patients presented neurologic symptoms (mainly delay in cognitive development, motor abnormalities, and seizures), abnormal cerebral magnetic resonance imaging, and HLA, either with a typical histologic pattern or a deficit in the enzymologic study of the respiratory chain complexes; 2 deaths were described.14 The same authors reported a higher incidence of first febrile seizure in HIV-uninfected children who were younger than 18 months and had been exposed to ARV drugs.16 Finally, neurologic symptoms (spastic gait and a generalized developmental regression) appeared 5 months before LA acidosis was identified and steadily improved after discontinuation of NRTIs in the only case of LA acidosis in a pediatric HIV-infected patient reported to date.26
According to the classification of probability level for the diagnosis of a mitochondrial respiratory chain deficit by Barret et al,15 analogous to that used for inherited mitochondrial diseases, the 3 patients that we report would be classified as "possible" mitochondrial dysfunction cases (symptoms compatible with those described in inherited mitochondrial diseases plus persistent significant HLA). Our prevalence rate of "possible" mitochondriopathy was 2.4% (95% confidence interval: 0%5.1%), whereas the prevalence rate in the French cohort for "established" plus "possible" mitochondriopathy was 1.05% (28 of 2644 patients).15 However, the French authors excluded 61 children with self-limited symptoms consistent with mitochondrial dysfunction, about whom complementary investigations were not available. These latter patients exactly match our girls who were affected with developmental retardation, except for the systematic determination of LA plasma values. In any case, the transient nature of elevated LA levels and the benign evolution of the infrequent HLA-associated neurologic syndrome in our series should be emphasized.
In our study, HLA was associated with gestational exposure to ddI but not to other NRTIs or ARV regimens, neither during pregnancy nor later. However, it should be kept in mind that these results are based on a small group of patients. It seems plausible that an additive or synergistic effect from different NRTIs contributes to mitochondrial toxicity in the fetus. Actually, only 1 of the 3 girls who developed neurologic symptoms had been exposed to ddI, and HLA was also documented in 2 infants who had been exposed to ZDV only in the neonatal period. A control group of HIV-uninfected infants who were not exposed to NRTIs or were exposed to NRTI monotherapy probably would have enhanced our study, but these were not available. Current guidelines17 discourage the use of ddI in HIV-infected pregnant women because of several reports describing maternal mortality secondary to LA acidosis/hepatic steatosis in patients who receive long-term ddI and d4T.38,39 This recommendation is reinforced by our findings.
The benefit obtained from ARV in preventing HIV vertical transmission has been well demonstrated in recent series similar to ours, with HIV mother-to-child transmission rates <2%.40 This success outweighs the potential toxicity of these agents in the newborn, and HAART should continue to be used in pregnant HIV-infected women. However, additional investigations regarding the efficacy and safety of ARV therapies in the neonate are warranted, and an effort to choose the least toxic therapeutic regimen in every single case is mandatory. In our opinion, plasma LA may provide some benefit in both the etiologic identification and the evolution of children who develop a clinical syndrome. Moreover, long-term follow-up is recommended, with special attention paid to neurologic symptoms and cognitive and behavioral development.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We are very grateful to Josep Maria Martin for skillful technical assistance.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Reprint requests to (C.F.) Servei de Pediatria, Hospital Sant Joan de Déu, Passeig Sant Joan de Déu 2, 08950 Esplugues (Barcelona), Spain. E-mail: cfortuny{at}hsjdbcn.org
This work was partially presented at the 10th Conference on Retrovirus and Opportunistic Infections; Feb 1014, 2003; Boston, Massachusetts (abstract no. 777); and the 9th European AIDS Conference; Oct 2529, 2003; Warsaw, Poland (abstract no. F 10/5).
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
5 years of age, Pediatric Spectrum of HIV disease project (PSD), USA.
Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2000;918
:236
246
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||