

* Department of Pediatrics, Case Western Reserve University/Rainbow Babies and Childrens Hospital, Cleveland, Ohio
Department of Bioethics, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective. To explore maternal beliefs and perceptions about discussing the stress of parenting and depressive symptoms with their childs pediatrician.
Design/Methods. Mothers were recruited from 5 community-based pediatric practices and 1 hospital-based practice to ensure a diverse sample. An experienced, trained facilitator conducted focus groups by using open-ended questions and administered a standard questionnaire. Audiotapes and transcripts of the groups were reviewed for major themes by 3 independent researchers using grounded theory and immersion/crystallization technique.
Results. Seven focus groups (N = 44) were convened. Participants were 70% black and 30% white with a mean age of 27 years; 61% were single; 50% were educated beyond high school; and 43% received public assistance as their main source of income. The mean score on the Psychiatric Symptom Index was 26.3 (high
20). Within 2 overarching domains (maternal and interaction between mother and pediatrician), several themes emerged. Within the maternal domain, dominant themes included 1) emotional health: all respondents indicated that a mothers emotional health greatly affects her childs well being; 2) self-efficacy: mothers believed in the importance of accepting responsibility for monitoring their own well being and that of their child; and 3) support systems: all mothers expressed the need to share parenting experiences, stressors, and depressive symptoms with someone (most preferred to speak with family or friends rather than with their childs pediatrician). Within the interaction domain, 2 themes emerged: 1) communication: open communication with a pediatrician who listens well was perceived by mothers in all groups as very important, and 2) trust: mothers trust pediatricians with their childs health, but many were hesitant to discuss their own stress or depressive symptoms. Mothers in all socioeconomic groups expressed fear of judgment and possible referral to child protection if they talked about such issues. Both of these were mediated by the presence of an ongoing relationship between the pediatrician and mother. Mothers were more likely to discuss their own emotional health if they felt their childs pediatrician "knew them well."
Conclusions. Mothers are aware that their own emotional health has consequences for their children. Although many mothers experienced lacks in their social support systems, many are reluctant to discuss parenting stress and depressive symptoms with their childs pediatrician because of mistrust and fear of judgment. Mothers are, however, generally receptive to the idea of open communication with their pediatricians and are interested in receiving supportive written communication about parenting stress and depressive symptoms from pediatricians. These qualitative data are valuable in developing an intervention to help pediatricians assist mothers at risk.
Key Words: depressive symptoms maternal focus groups pediatric providers parenting stress primary care
Abbreviations: PSI, Psychiatric Symptom Index
Depressive symptoms in mothers are common16 and have serious negative consequences for children,712 yet mothers with depressive symptoms may not be recognized and treated by their own primary care providers.1317 Because depression and depressive symptoms in mothers with young children are prevalent and associated with adverse outcomes in children, pediatricians and other pediatric health care providers have been urged to screen for maternal mental health problems and family stresses.3,18
Pediatric primary care visits may provide a good opportunity for pediatricians to identify mothers with depressive symptoms. Although some mothers may lack primary care providers of their own, mothers interact with pediatricians on a regular basis in bringing their young children for pediatric health care. Pediatric providers who develop an ongoing relationship with mothers often discuss various stresses experienced in parenting children. As such, they are poised to "address family problems" in the context of health supervision, as recommended by both the American Academy of Pediatrics19,20 and Bright Futures: Guidelines for Health Supervision of Infants, Children and Adolescents.21 Screening for maternal and family problems is a promising avenue by which pediatric primary care providers can increase their effectiveness at dealing with and preventing a variety of childhood problems.18,2225
Some studies, however, suggest that pediatricians may not be effective at identifying mothers with depressive symptoms.26,27 A better understanding, therefore, of both mothers and pediatricians perspectives that may impede or enhance discussion of maternal depressive symptoms is essential in developing strategies to improve recognition and management of maternal depressive symptoms within pediatric health care settings. If such interventions are to be incorporated into the existing paradigm of primary care for children, it first must be understood how mothers feel about discussing the stresses of parenting and their own mental health concerns with their childs pediatrician. Little is known about the perceptions mothers have regarding the role pediatricians can and should play in addressing maternal mental health concerns. Therefore, this study used a targeted set of questions to ask mothers of young children about their experiences as mothers and their beliefs and attitudes related to discussing the stress of parenting and depressive symptoms with their childs pediatrician.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sample
Mothers bringing their child for routine pediatric care were recruited from 5 community-based practices and 1 hospital-based practice to participate in a focus-group discussion for mothers of young children. Purposeful sampling of mothers was performed by posting flyers in each pediatric waiting room that announced a research project to explore feelings of mothers with young children. No mention of depressive symptoms was made in the flyer. Although it is possible that selection bias occurred, it was not exacerbated by the text used to recruit mothers to participate. The flyers described the content of the discussions and instructed potential participants to call the study director for enrollment. In addition to the posted announcement, mothers were recruited in person from the hospital-based pediatric practice. This was done to ensure adequate representation of nonwhite, inner-city mothers in the study.
Mothers were screened by telephone to ascertain age, educational level, number of children, and income sources. These data were collected to match participants within each focus group to optimize group cohesiveness and compatibility. Focus groups were conducted at a community-based facility during afternoon and evening hours to accommodate participants. Written, informed consent was obtained at the beginning of each focus group according to the guidelines of our institutional review board. Participants were compensated for their time.
Data Collection
Focus groups were conducted by a trained facilitator with extensive experience in moderating focus groups and conducting in-depth interviews. The questions asked in each group were standardized using a guidebook (Table 1) that was developed a priori and adapted slightly after the first focus group to include the "ice breaker": "What do you enjoy most about being a mother?" This strategy of starting with a nonthreatening, general question and progressing to more-specific areas of inquiry has been recommended as a way to encourage trust among group members.38 Questions were developed to query 2 overarching domains: those inherently related to the mother and her personal beliefs, perceptions, and coping mechanisms and those that capture the pediatrician-mother interaction as it relates to discussion of a mothers well being. Each group was audiotaped and subsequently transcribed verbatim with little to no data loss. Transcriptions were reviewed for accuracy and clarity by the focus-group facilitator.
|
20 represents a "high" level of symptoms and suggests a high likelihood that the respondent had significant distress and depressive symptoms. Although not diagnostic of depression, a PSI score of
20 reflects a mother at risk.39
Data Analysis
Analysis was overseen by a researcher experienced in coding and analyzing qualitative data using immersion/crystallization techniques.4042 The immersion aspect of this technique was conducted by reviewing the transcript for each focus group and listening to the audiotape to enhance the written word by the nuance and tone conveyed on the audiotapes. For each focus group, facilitator notes were also reviewed. These notes had been made contemporaneously during each focus-group session by the principal investigator and captured affective responses such as head nodding and facial expressions not picked up by audiotape. Transcriptions were coded by beginning with the first question and continuing question by question until all responses to each question (including noted nonverbal responses) were written down. Within the 2 predetermined domains (ie, maternal and pediatrician-mother interaction), consistent categories began to emerge. Three themes were identified within the maternal domain, and 2 were identified within the interaction domain. The coding of responses was performed by the investigators in an iterative process with review and discussion to achieve agreement between coders. This rigor is part of the process of crystallization of data.43
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
20). The mean number of children was 2 with mean age of 6 years, 1 month. Demographics for individual groups are shown in Table 2.
|
|
Emotional Health
Mothers in all groups agreed that a mothers emotional health greatly affects her childs well being. All mothers had an appreciation of the potential impact their own emotional state has on their children. They used visual symbols of mirrors, circles, and sponges to describe the bond that exist between parent and child. For example, 1 mother described her feelings as "circular," ie, her emotional health and her childs are a continuum. Mothers used phrases such as "if mama aint happy, nobodys happy" to convey that their emotional state is reflected by their children. Mothers believed that children pick up cues and absorb the emotional energy of their parents: "they know." One mother stated: "How you cope is how they cope." Others described precisely what occurs when their affect is transferred to their child. One mother stated: "My anger triggers anger, frustration, and anxiety." Another stated: "My tears trigger concern and sympathy." In sum, mothers in all groups believed that they set the mood for their households.
Participants saw motherhood as giving them opportunities to be fulfilled and creative, to receive love and support from offspring, and to experience delight, warmth, and comfort. On the other hand, mothers were forthright in sharing their feelings of sadness, anger, and especially anxiety. Parenting was perceived as fulfilling but stressful. Words often used by mothers were "consuming," "overwhelming," "stressed out," and "big responsibility." The emotional toll of parenting was articulated by mothers in all groups. First-time mothers perceived that their lives had "totally changed." "I need a break" was the comment made most often, repeated by mothers in all groups, but especially by mothers who had sole responsibility for caring for their children.
Self-Efficacy
Mothers across all groups exhibited personal resourcefulness and self-efficacy. Motherhood appeared to draw out these qualities in many respondents. Mothers believed that much of their strength and sense of self arise from motherhood. One mother said "If my child is okay, I can take care of everything else." Mothers placed a great premium on their sense of control and "choice" as well as "building self-esteem." As stated by a mother in group 1: "You have to influence your environment and not let your environment influence you." There was general agreement across all groups that methods such as journal writing, prayer, and talking to someone close were effective stress reducers and effective ways to enhance self-efficacy.
Support Systems
Within the maternal domain, the theme of support, or lack thereof, was well developed, consistent across all groups, and a frequent response to each question. Mothers were keenly aware of their need to feel supported in their roles as mothers. More importantly, perceived lack of support was a frequent stressor to mothers and quite undesirable, especially when it was the childs father that was unsupportive. Mothers in all groups wanted and needed to share parenting experiences and the stresses of parenting. They believed sharing was helpful to process their feelings (especially ambivalent ones) and to gain information and advice from others to help them become better parents.
Pediatricians were not mentioned as a key support for mothers. Instead, mothers turned to their family, especially their mothers, their friends, and even their children for their encouragement, advice, and emotional support. Overwhelmingly, mothers reported that other mothers are a strong source of support. "Feeling blue is not as bad if you have another mother you can call on." Mothers felt that being able to talk about their child and their feelings about being a parent was most helpful when they could do it with other mothers.
An unexpected development within the groups was that the atmosphere of the focus groups quickly became therapeutic for participants in that they felt a rapport with fellow participants and gained a sense that others felt the same way. Despite the fact that the aims of the focus group were clearly presented to mothers in recruitment and again at the time the focus group convened, every group had 1 member ask when the group could meet again, as if it were a support group. In fact, group 3 left the focus group en masse to reconvene informally and continue their discussion. Mothers in every group exchanged information and phone numbers, pleased that they had connected with other mothers. It was summed up best by 1 mother in group 4: "I was dying to meet other mothers."
Lack of support, particularly from the childs father, was very difficult for mothers. This was raised in all groups but predominated as a topic in groups 2, 6, and 7, which were comprised of single mothers. Fathers were described as "unsupportive, neglectful, and unreliable." Fathers were perceived as not wanting to spend time with their children and "wanting power but assuming no responsibility." Lack of paternal involvement was pointed out in all groups. Although more distressing among single mothers, it was a perception even among married mothers. Married mothers stated: "My husband expects me to know exactly what I am doing" and "everything falls on me."
Domain II: Pediatrician-Mother Interaction
Within this domain, 2 themes resonated within our focus groups: trust and communication. Both of these themes were significantly modified by a mothers perception of the continuity of her relationship with her childs doctor. Themes of trust and communication were raised in all groups by virtually all participants. Explication of these dominant themes follows.
Trust
Mothers in our sample trust pediatricians with their childs health. They feel comfortable and confident that the pediatrician will identify and treat conditions that affect their children. Certain issues mothers discuss with their childs pediatrician during a health care visit were consistent across all groups, including how their child is eating, developing, and growing. Despite the fact that the pediatrician often asks a mother how she is doing at her childs visits, many mothers reported that the pediatricians role is to focus on the health and well being of the child, not the mother. Some mothers stated that the pediatricians being a parent is important to building trust, because pediatricians who have children of their own are better able to view the stresses of child rearing from a similar perspective. Also, mothers had trust in pediatricians who valued their opinions, assumed they knew right from wrong, and were willing to spend time during a health care visit listening to their concerns.
The most salient and consistent finding was mothers fear of judgment. Mothers drew a line at discussing issues beyond what is child centered and expressed feelings of discomfort and distrust because of such fear. When asked "do you ever discuss the stress of parenting with your pediatrician?" many mothers had reservations about doing so. For example, 1 participant stated: "Pediatricians are trained to take care of kids, not us." They reported hesitancy to volunteer information because they would not want the pediatrician to "think Im unable to take care of my kids." Because a lot of their identity is defined through motherhood, admitting any difficulties to pediatricians would be akin to admitting failure. Reluctance to volunteer such information was pervasive in all groups. One mother stated that she needed to "read her doctors motive" to decide whether she would engage in discussion regarding her feelings. The need to "choose words carefully" and to gauge the pediatricians response was a recurrent comment. Mothers were very concerned about how they presented themselves to their pediatrician, making statements such as "I hold things back" and "I wont be forthcoming." Most mothers said that, although they would not raise the issues of parenting stress, they would answer questions if asked.
Probing further, strains of a more concrete fear began to emerge. Mothers repeatedly described a fear that their pediatrician would interpret their request for help as a threat to their childs safety and, as a consequence, would refer them to child protective services. Mothers in lower socioeconomic status groups were particularly fearful of social work intervention, because they believed that a primary function of medical social workers is to remove the child from the home rather than to act as a resource for help. Although this concern was raised more strongly in the lower socioeconomic status groups, mothers in every group raised this fear of referral to child protective services. This is a significant finding and has important implications regarding reluctance of stressed mothers to speak out to professionals whom they fear may deem them as unfit mothers.
Communication
Open communication with a pediatrician who listens well was perceived as very important by all mothers. Mothers listed qualities that represented good communication styles that facilitated discussion of parenting stress and depressive symptoms. Likewise, they listed several communication "donts" that made them less willing to share their feelings with the pediatrician (Table 4). Mothers were all in agreement that pediatricians needed to be open to mothers concerns and ask questions in the right way. Inquiries that were felt to be intrusive or judgmental were poorly received. Mothers talked at length about "pediatricians who care." There were many who felt strongly that it was the pediatrician who set the tone when discussing maternal issues. Overall, mothers agreed that they were more likely to discuss the stresses of parenting if they felt their pediatrician considered the whole family environment. One mother stated: "The pediatrician has a wonderful opportunity to treat the entire family for the benefit of the child." Mothers opened up more with pediatricians who "ask without prying" and who can give "targeted advice without being pushy or intrusive." Most of all, mothers wanted a pediatrician that will "just listen." It is a paradox, however, that although some mothers want pediatricians to ask and will not offer any information unless asked, the overwhelming majority of mothers wanted pediatricians to be a sounding board rather than to intervene with them directly. One mother stated: "If a pediatrician initiates it [discussion], then Ill know she cares."
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our study revealed several important and somewhat surprising findings. Mothers in our focus groups expressed some willingness to discuss their own concerns with their childs pediatricians, particularly if the pediatrician raised the issue and if they felt there existed a relationship between themselves and the pediatrician. However, many mothers had mixed feelings about involving their childs pediatrician in family issues. Previous quantitative research by Heneghan et al44 showed that 95% of mothers would welcome or not mind discussing mental health issues with their childs pediatrician. Other investigators have found that mothers consider it appropriate to discuss family stresses and problems during a well-child visit.45,46 What mothers may report in a questionnaire differs from what we found in our focus groups, namely that mothers would like to openly converse with their childs pediatrician and would offer information when asked if the pediatrician seems "to care." The interpersonal dynamics and strength of the relationship between the mother and the pediatrician, as it is understood by the mother, is an essential element in mothers willingness to turn to her pediatrician for assistance or information.
Although mothers would like to consider their pediatrician a source of support for themselves, they are fearful of judgment. Mothers perceived risk of being reported to child protection services in fact may interfere with the discussion of maternal depressive symptoms and parenting stress, which poses a significant challenge to the existing structure of pediatric primary care. Mothers in our sample were very aware of a pediatricians role as a mandated reporter of child abuse; therefore, they were reluctant to discuss issues that may reflect any difficulties or stresses in parenting their children. Mothers in lower socioeconomic groups were particularly uncomfortable speaking with social workers, because they perceived their role as adversarial rather than supportive. To help mothers with depressive symptoms, pediatricians and social service professionals must rethink their "roles" and encourage mothers to disclose feelings of depressive symptoms without risk of child removal. Most often, mothers with depressive symptoms can and do provide appropriate care for their children. Therefore, a pediatrician who knows a mother well and is able to provide nonjudgmental assistance can intercede with therapeutic rather than punitive motives. Interventions that address maternal depression should promote improved communication between pediatricians and mothers and enhance efforts to build continuous, ongoing relationships between pediatricians and the families for whom they care. In these ways, the fear of judgment that mothers expressed can be minimized.
Mothers repeatedly stated that they gain strength from other mothers. Mothers in our focus groups developed an almost immediate therapeutic alliance while talking about the stresses of parenting. The spontaneous exchange of information that occurred at the end of every group (from telephone numbers and playgroup and parenting group meeting times to other services of interest to mothers) speaks to the need for future interventions that bring mothers together. Recently, support groups such as lactation and postpartum groups and playgroups have emerged to address the isolation that many mothers experience. The Internet has also become a medium to bring mothers together. For example, Dunham et al47 created an online support group for mothers in a Canadian community with great success.
The qualitative data collected from mothers in our study was extremely illuminating to describe not only mothers self-perceptions and feelings about their emotional well being but also about the role their pediatrician can and should play in assisting them with depressive symptoms and parenting stress. Other qualitative studies have been performed in this area. In in-depth interviews with new mothers, Beck48 found that women with postpartum depression described a loss of control and a "dying of ones former self." Both studies add significantly to the understanding of depression by asking participants to recount and elaborate their experiences, feelings, and perceptions, thus providing a detailed portrait of the process.
This study helps to describe the attitudes and perceptions that mothers have about discussing depressive symptoms within the context of health care for their children. Pediatricians attitudes are equally important to understand. In a national sample of practicing pediatricians, Olson et al49 recently described pediatricians perceived roles, management practices, and encountered barriers in regard to addressing maternal depression. Although 57% believed it was their responsibility to recognize maternal depression, only 7% felt responsible for treatment. Most (66%) did provide some type of brief intervention such as referral to a mental health professional or primary care provider or referral to a support group.49 Time constraints and incomplete training, but not mothers fear of judgment, as we found, were barriers raised by the pediatricians surveyed.
Depression and depressive disorders are prevalent, treatable mental health problems16,50,51 and are especially frequent among women with young children.16 Because of their frequent contact with mothers and the important impact of maternal depressive symptoms on child development, pediatricians are an especially valuable resource in reaching women 15 to 44 years old, a group in which depression is the leading cause of disease burden worldwide.52 In fact, the US Preventive Services Task Force recommends screening all primary care patients for depression.53 Pediatricians are poised to discuss parenting stress or mild depressive symptoms with mothers and to refer those who are more symptomatic to adult health care providers for treatments that are known to be effective.54,55 Interventions that consider both mothers and pediatricians perceptions will ultimately be most successful in assisting mothers with depressive symptoms.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We thank Vanessa Farrell and Sunny Morton for assistance in organizing the focus groups; Kurt Stange, MD, PhD, for thoughtful review of this manuscript; and the participants who shared so generously of their time and energy for this research.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address correspondence to Amy M. Heneghan, MD, Department of Pediatrics, Case Western Reserve University/Rainbow Babies and Childrens Hospital, 11000 Euclid Ave, Cleveland, OH 44106. E-mail: axh65{at}po.cwru.edu
This work was presented in part at the Pediatric Academic Societies 2002 Annual Meeting, Baltimore, MD, May 7, 2002.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
W. Sword, D. Busser, R. Ganann, T. McMillan, and M. Swinton Women's Care-Seeking Experiences After Referral for Postpartum Depression Qual Health Res, September 1, 2008; 18(9): 1161 - 1173. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. Kabir, J. Sheeder, and L. S. Kelly Identifying Postpartum Depression: Are 3 Questions as Good as 10? Pediatrics, September 1, 2008; 122(3): e696 - e702. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. K. Gjerdingen and B. P. Yawn Postpartum Depression Screening: Importance, Methods, Barriers, and Recommendations for Practice J Am Board Fam Med, May 1, 2007; 20(3): 280 - 288. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Dubowitz, S. Feigelman, W. Lane, L. Prescott, K. Blackman, L. Grube, W. Meyer, and J. K. Tracy Screening for Depression in an Urban Pediatric Primary Care Clinic Pediatrics, March 1, 2007; 119(3): 435 - 443. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. H. Chaudron, P. G. Szilagyi, A. T. Campbell, K. O. Mounts, and T. K. McInerny Legal and Ethical Considerations: Risks and Benefits of Postpartum Depression Screening at Well-Child Visits Pediatrics, January 1, 2007; 119(1): 123 - 128. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. M. Horwitz, K. J. Kelleher, R. E.K. Stein, A. Storfer-Isser, E. A. Youngstrom, E. R. Park, A. M. Heneghan, P. S. Jensen, K. G. O'Connor, and K. E. Hoagwood Barriers to the Identification and Management of Psychosocial Issues in Children and Maternal Depression Pediatrics, January 1, 2007; 119(1): e208 - e218. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. M. Dumont-Mathieu, B. A. Bernstein, P. H. Dworkin, and L. M. Pachter Role of Pediatric Health Care Professionals in the Provision of Parenting Advice: A Qualitative Study With Mothers From 4 Minority Ethnocultural Groups Pediatrics, September 1, 2006; 118(3): e839 - e848. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. Zink, L. Levin, P. Wollan, and F. Putnam Mothers' Comfort with Screening Questions about Sensitive Issues, Including Domestic Violence. J Am Board Fam Med, July 1, 2006; 19(4): 358 - 367. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. L. Olson, A. J. Dietrich, G. Prazar, and J. Hurley Brief Maternal Depression Screening at Well-Child Visits Pediatrics, July 1, 2006; 118(1): 207 - 216. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. C. Whitaker, S. M. Orzol, and R. S. Kahn Maternal Mental Health, Substance Use, and Domestic Violence in the Year After Delivery and Subsequent Behavior Problems in Children at Age 3 Years. Arch Gen Psychiatry, May 1, 2006; 63(5): 551 - 560. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. S. Wissow, S. Larson, J. Anderson, and E. Hadjiisky Pediatric Residents' Responses That Discourage Discussion of Psychosocial Problems in Primary Care Pediatrics, June 1, 2005; 115(6): 1569 - 1578. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. C. Whitaker Mental Health and Obesity in Pediatric Primary Care: A Gap Between Importance and Action Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, August 1, 2004; 158(8): 826 - 828. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Other articles noted: 06 Feb 2004 to 16 Apr 2004 Evid. Based Nurs., July 1, 2004; 7(3): e3 - e3. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Moran Pediatricians Logical Choice To Identify Depressed Moms Psychiatr News, April 16, 2004; 39(8): 66 - 69. [Full Text] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||