

* Departments of Medicine
Pediatrics, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Department of Medicine, Howard University, Washington, District of Columbia
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective. Our goal was to determine how maternal depressive symptoms influence child medication adherence, impact of the childs asthma on the mother, and maternal attitudes and beliefs.
Methods. Baseline and 6-month surveys were administered to 177 mothers of young minority children with asthma in inner-city Baltimore, MD and Washington, DC. Medication adherence, disruptiveness of asthma, and select attitudes toward illness and asthma therapy were measured. Six-month data (N = 158) were used to prospectively evaluate long-term symptom control and emergency department use. Independent variables included asthma morbidity, age, depressive symptoms, and other psychosocial data.
Results. No difference in child asthma morbidity was observed between mothers high and low in depressive symptoms. However, mothers with high depressive symptoms reported significantly more problems with their child using inhalers properly (odds ratio [OR]: 5.0; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.318.9) and forgetting doses (OR: 4.2; 95% CI: 1.412.4). Depressive symptoms were also associated with greater emotional distress and interference with daily activities caused by the childs asthma, along with less confidence in asthma medications, ability to control asthma symptoms, and self-efficacy to cope with acute asthma episodes. In addition, depressed mothers reported less understanding about their childs medications and use (OR: 7.7; 95% CI: 1.735.9). Baseline asthma morbidity, maternal depression scores, and family income were independently associated with asthma symptoms 6 months later, whereas medication adherence was not predictive of subsequent asthma morbidity or emergency department use.
Conclusions. Maternal depressive symptoms were not associated with child asthma morbidity but were associated with a constellation of beliefs and attitudes that may significantly influence adherence to asthma medications and illness management. Identifying and addressing poor psychological adjustment in mothers is important when developing a childs asthma treatment and may facilitate parent-provider communication, medication adherence, and asthma management among inner-city children.
Key Words: asthma maternal depression medication adherence attitudes beliefs
Abbreviations: ED, emergency department ICS, inhaled corticosteroid CES-D, Center for Epidemiologic Studies-Depression scale OR, odds ratio df, degrees of freedom
Depression is a common disorder that often complicates the treatment of illnesses. In persons with chronic illnesses ranging from heart disease to rheumatic illnesses, growing evidence indicates that depression is linked with higher rates of health care utilization,1,2 significant impairment in daily functioning,3 diminished quality of life,4 and poorer treatment outcomes.5,6 Living with a chronic illnesses is an independent risk factor for depressive symptoms.7,8 Depressive symptoms in turn may influence illness outcomes through physiologic pathways such as changes in neurotransmitter regulation and illness-related behaviors.5,911
One example of this link is the recent finding that depressive symptoms are associated with nonadherence to treatment recommendations. In persons with a wide range of medical conditions including human immunodeficiency virus/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome,1214 osteoporosis,13 diabetes,15 and cardiac transplantation,16 high levels of depressive symptoms are associated with decreased adherence to therapy. In recent meta-analyses of studies from 1968 to 1998, DiMatteo et al17 concluded that depressed persons were 3 times as likely to be nonadherent with medical treatment recommendations than persons who were not depressed.
Adolescent and adult women are particularly vulnerable to depressive symptoms, with 10%25% of women experiencing a major depressive episode at some time in their lives.18 Poverty, low socioeconomic status, unemployment, and having young children place inner-city women at greater risk. Having a child with a chronic illness further exacerbates risk for depression among inner-city mothers, with reported point prevalence rates nearing 50%.1922
To our knowledge, no studies have addressed the impact of maternal depressive symptoms on the illness management of chronically ill inner-city children. Recently, we reported that maternal depression was a potent risk factor for emergency department (ED) use among young inner-city children with asthma.19 The goal of the present study was to expand these findings by evaluating how maternal depression influences asthma management in inner-city children. Specifically, we wanted to explore how depression influenced the impact of the disease on the mother, maternal attitudes toward the childs illness and therapy, as well as the childs adherence to prescribed asthma medications. Six-month follow-up data were used to prospectively evaluate long-term symptom control and health care utilization. We hypothesized that mothers with high levels of depressive symptoms would report greater disruption in their lives, more negative attitudes toward asthma therapy and care, and poorer adherence with controller asthma therapy (ie, inhaled corticosteroid [ICS] therapy) in their children than mothers with low levels of depressive symptoms. We also hypothesized that poorer adherence would be related to increased asthma symptoms and ED use in the following 6 months.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Participants
Mothers who had elementary school-aged children (ie, kindergarten through 5th grade) with an asthma diagnosis on their school health records were screened for eligibility. Mothers were eligible if they reported that their child had 1) asthma diagnosed by a physician, 2) day or night asthma symptoms including wheeze, shortness of breath, and/or cough at least once a week during the past 2 weeks, and/or 3) at least 1 visit for asthma to the ED in the previous 6 months or 1 overnight hospitalization for asthma in the previous year. Ninety-eight percent of the families were African American.
Procedures
Parents or guardians of eligible children were mailed a consent form. After obtaining informed written consent, trained interviewers (who were blinded to the study hypotheses) interviewed by phone the person identified as the primary caregiver. The childs biological mother was the interview respondent 89% of the time. Telephone surveys of pediatric populations have generally found good agreement for medically related information when querying information such as hospitalizations and number of visits for asthma.23,24
Within the total sample of 338 respondents, mood was assessed in the last 177 mothers enrolled in the studies; 6-month self-report data on ED use were available for 158 of the children in the baseline sample (89%). Mothers who did not participate in the mood assessment (ie, the first 161 caregivers surveyed) were more likely to report lower levels of asthma morbidity in their children (6.3 ± 7.2 vs 15.7 ± 11.7; P < .001 days/nights with symptoms per month, respectively) but did not differ in age, level of asthma symptoms, child age, or annual income as compared with the last 177 mothers surveyed (ie, those on whom depressive symptoms data were collected). All subsequent analyses reported were performed on this subset of 158 caregivers.
Measures
Maternal Characteristics
Maternal measures included demographic information and an assessment of depressive symptoms. Depressive symptoms were evaluated by using a modified version of the Center for Epidemiologic Studies-Depression scale (CES-D).25 The CES-D has been widely used in clinical trials in both general and psychiatric populations and has sound psychometric properties (ie, reliability and discriminant and convergent validity).26 The recommended clinical cutpoint score of 16 is commonly used to indicate "caseness" for depression27 and has been shown to have high sensitivity (.95) and specificity (.70) in predicting major depressive disorder in low-income minority women (as compared with diagnostic interviews).18 To reduce the burden on participants and because briefer versions of the test have also been shown to have good predictive accuracy,2831 an 11-item version of the CES-D was used.19 Scores on each item ranged from 0 to 3 with higher scores reflecting increased dysphoria; scores
9 were judged to reflect clinically significant levels of depressive symptoms (ie, depression), whereas scores <9 were judged to reflect nonsignificant levels of distress.
We assessed the impact of the childs asthma on the mother using an abbreviated form of the Pediatric Asthma Caregivers Quality of Life Questionnaire.32 This scale assesses the disruptions in normal daily activities as well as anxiety and fear caused by the childs asthma experienced by the caregivers of children with asthma. It has been shown to be reliable and valid both as an evaluative and discriminative measurement tool.32 We also asked about the mothers beliefs about selected asthma-management practices, health care providers, and her childs asthma treatment by using 4-point Likert scales.
Child Characteristics
Demographic information as well as information on the childs asthma symptoms and asthma medication use were obtained from the mother. We assessed the childs adherence to medication prescribed by his or her health care provider. Caregivers were told, "Most children have problems taking their medication just as prescribed" and then asked: 1) "How often does your child have problems using his/her inhaler the right way?" 2) "How often does your child forget to take his/her asthma medication?" and 3) "In the past 2 weeks (14 days), how many days would you guess that your child has forgotten to take his or her medicine?"
An index of the childs asthma morbidity was developed at baseline by summing the total number of days and nights during the previous 6 months that the child experienced asthma-related symptoms. Respondents were asked: 1) "For the last 6 months, on average, how many days per week did cough, wheeze, or shortness of breath limit your childs exercise, ability to play sports, or ability to play with friends?" and 2) "For the last 6 months, on the average, how many nights per week did your child wake up at night with cough, wheeze, shortness of breath, or tightness in chest?"
Statistical Analysis
Depressive symptoms were used both as a continuous variable and to classify caregivers dichotomously (ie, high versus low). t test and
2 analyses were used to assess differences in demographic characteristics, health care utilization patterns, and asthma-management practices between mothers classified as high or low in depressive symptoms. Spearman
coefficients were calculated to assess the association between maternal depression and variables of interest. Responses were coded as positive (for all or most of the time) or negative (for some or none of the time), and odds ratios (ORs) were calculated to facilitate interpretation of results. Nonparametric measures of association and partial correlation coefficients were used to evaluate the relationship between baseline medication adherence with symptom control and ED use 6 months later. Linear regression was used to evaluate the independent relationship between variables of interest and 6-month asthma outcomes. Variables were selected for inclusion in the model on the basis of significant bivariate associations and theoretical importance.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The children with asthma had a mean age of 7.9 ± 2.2 years, and 59% of the sample were female. Asthma morbidity was high in this sample, with most children (64%) experiencing asthma symptoms
4 days a week. The majority of mothers (92.0%) reported that their child had used asthma medications in the past 6 months, and more than half (56.5%) had been prescribed a daily antiinflammatory medication.
Mothers with high levels of depressive symptoms (ie, depressed mothers) were more likely to be unemployed and in the lower income categories (as shown in Table 1). Depressed mothers were also more likely to report smoking cigarettes, although this trend did not reach statistical significance. No differences were observed in age, education, or number of children at home between mothers high and low in depressive symptoms. There were no differences in age, gender, or selected markers of asthma morbidity between the children of mothers high and low in depressive symptoms (as shown in Table 2).
|
|
|
2 days in the past 2 weeks. The overall association between CES-D scores and adherence measures was relatively weak (r = .153 to .172; P < .05).
|
|
|
= .50; P < .001). Similarly, frequency of asthma symptoms at baseline was modestly associated with symptoms 6 months later (Spearmans
= .44; P < .001). Days of missed medication in the previous 2 weeks at baseline were positively correlated with asthma symptoms reported 6 months later (Spearmans
= .19; P = .02). Linear regression was used to evaluate the independent contribution of select baseline variables including child age, family income, asthma morbidity, and maternal depressive symptoms and medication adherence at follow-up (see Table 7). Only medication adherence at baseline was associated with adherence at follow-up (r = .183; P < .05). Asthma morbidity, maternal depressive symptoms, and frequently forgetting medication (at follow-up) were associated with asthma morbidity at follow-up (adjusted r2 = .220 with 3, 132, degrees of freedom [df]; P < .001). Baseline asthma morbidity and maternal depressive symptoms were independently associated with ED use 6 months later (adjusted r2 = .096 with 2, 155 df; P < .001), but follow-up adherence did not contribute significantly to the model.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
High levels of depressive symptoms in mothers were also associated with a greater impact of the childs illness on the mother, more negative maternal attitudes toward selected management practices, and communication difficulties with the childs doctor. Depressed mothers reported less confidence in the safety and effectiveness of their childs asthma medicine. A particularly worrisome finding was that depressed mothers were nearly 8 times more likely to report that their childs doctor had not adequately explained the rationale for, or proper use of, asthma medicines. Overall, depressed mothers reported less satisfaction with their childs asthma therapy, asthma care, and health care providers in general. Beyond their doubts about the efficacy of asthma therapy, mothers with high levels of depressive symptoms also reported less confidence in their own ability to manage their childs acute asthma episodes at home. Thus, maternal depression seems to be associated with a constellation of beliefs and attitudes regarding their childs asthma management including less confidence in asthma therapy, physician visits, and the doctors ability to help the family better control asthma symptoms and reduced parental self-efficacy to cope with acute asthma episodes.
The relationship between depression and poor treatment outcomes in adults has been well established. In older patients hospitalized with medical illnesses, depressive symptoms are independently associated with poorer outcomes6 and higher mortality rates, even after controlling for comorbid illness, as well as functional and cognitive impairments.9 Even subclinical levels of depression independently predict morbidity and mortality in cardiac patients.34,35 Depression also has been shown to have a substantial and significant negative impact on adherence with medical recommendations.17
Our results suggest potential mechanisms by which depression in mothers may lead to poor pediatric asthma outcomes. First, high depressive symptoms (suggestive of depression) in mothers were associated with decreased child adherence with asthma therapy. This seems understandable given that depressed mothers reported significantly less confidence in and understanding of the methods and goals of asthma therapy and less satisfaction overall with their childs asthma care. Adherence to recommended therapy for asthma is based, at least in part, on the patients (or parents) belief that the recommended therapeutic actions have a good probability of leading to positive outcomes (ie, better asthma control). Conversely, reduced optimism in the efficacy and benefits of asthma therapy would likely lead to declining adherence. Suboptimal symptom management, in turn, may reinforce lowered expectations for asthma control and reinforce beliefs about the futility of asthma therapy. Thus, the finding that medication adherence is poorer in children of depressed mothers is not surprising.
Beyond medication adherence, other behaviors, thoughts, and feelings associated with high levels of depressive symptoms in mothers may also create and perpetuate asthma-management difficulties. For example, characteristics of depression include the tendency to become socially isolated and to withdraw from interactions with others, memory impairments, and feelings of hopelessness, helplessness, and futility.36 Our results suggest that critical factors associated with a mothers ability to care for her ill child, including medication adherence, communication with the childs physician, overall satisfaction with childs asthma management, and parent self-efficacy to manage exacerbations, may be compromised significantly when the mother is experiencing high levels of depressive symptoms.
As anticipated, increased nonadherence to ICS was associated with a greater frequency of asthma symptoms over the following 6 months. We have shown previously that mothers with high levels of depressive symptoms were more likely to take their child to the ED (and be frequent users of the ED).19 Contrary to our expectations, we did not find a direct relationship between ICS adherence and subsequent ED use. However, pediatric ED use is multifactorial. Predictors of urgent care use include factors related to the child (ie, age),19,37,38 asthma symptoms (ie, frequency),19,37,38 medications (number prescribed),37,38 and asthma management (ie, previous hospitalizations for asthma or unclear criteria for deciding when to seek emergency care).37,38 The mothers emotional well being,19 perception of her childs needs,39 and level of social support37 have also been shown to be independently associated with the decision to seek medical care. In addition, because maternal self-reports of medication nonadherence in this study were relatively rare, statistical power may have been inadequate to detect differences between groups. Additional studies are needed to assess whether health care utilization is influenced by medication nonadherence in depressed mothers.
As has been reported, depression is pervasive among inner-city mothers.19,20 In our sample, depressive symptoms were not correlated with markers of asthma morbidity, suggesting that there is no direct relationship between the actual burden of the childs illness and the mothers emotional well being. Perhaps mothers who are more psychologically vulnerable may develop depression in response to the continued stress of having a chronically ill child. Once depressed, a downward spiral may develop in which mothers are less able to manage their childs illness effectively, asthma symptoms persist and increase, satisfaction with medical care decreases, and expectations of the effectiveness of asthma therapy fall, ultimately resulting in treatment nonadherence and increased health care use. Conversely, mothers with depression may be less able to cope with a range of life stressors including a childs illness.40
Effective treatments for depression exist41 that offer promise to enhance maternal functioning and quality of life for parent and child.4244 In addition, successful interventions to improve medication adherence,45,46 enhance patient-physician communication,47,48 and increase parental self-confidence4951 are available. Social support seems to buffer the impact of stressful life events in mothers with ill children.40 The question of whether treatment of maternal depression would enhance child adherence to asthma therapy has not been empirically addressed. However, preliminary evidence in persons with multiple sclerosis suggests that treatment of depression, by either cognitive-behavioral therapy or antidepressants, enhances adherence to pharmacotherapy.52,53 Hence, if depression in mothers of children with asthma is recognized and addressed, at a minimum, this will enhance quality of life and parental functioning. Treatment of maternal depression may also offer an important opportunity to optimize medication adherence, asthma management, and appropriate health care use in the inner city.
There are several limitations to this study. As with all self-report data, reporting bias may exist, and there is a tendency for correlation among self-report variables. In studies, most individuals underreport medication nonadherence,54 and rates of reported medication nonadherence in this study were notably lower than those obtained in other asthma studies when electronic medication monitoring has been used.51,55,56 We were also unable to determine whether medication adherence truly was lower in children of depressed mothers or whether depressed mothers were simply more candid about their child medication use, because self-reports of treatment nonadherence have been shown to be highly reliable and valid.54 Concern about reporting bias by depressive-symptom status is reduced somewhat by the fact that no differences by depressive-symptom status were evident in several asthma-related variables including the frequency of asthma symptoms, use of asthma medications or home remedies, or concerns about medication side effects. The use of medication-monitoring devices would provide objective information about the relationship between maternal depression and child treatment adherence. A depression screening test, the CES-D, was used with a predetermined cutoff point to classify individuals as being at risk for depression (ie, high CES-D scores). Although this is a common strategy in population and clinical research,13,57 it is important to note that CES-D scores cannot be used to "diagnose" individuals. Clinical interviews would have allowed us to classify individuals more accurately. Finally, underlying asthma severity was inferred by evaluating the mothers reports of symptom frequency during the previous 6 months.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| UBIQUITOUS TV |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Elliott C. Better Than Well. Norton; 2003
Submitted by Student
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Reprint requests to (S.J.B.) Johns Hopkins AAC, 5501 Hopkins Bayview Cir, No. 4b.30, Baltimore, MD 21224. E-mail: bartlett{at}jhmi.edu
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. D. Goodwin, P. Wickramaratne, Y. Nomura, and M. M. Weissman Familial Depression and Respiratory Illness in Children Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, May 1, 2007; 161(5): 487 - 494. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Seguin, B. Nikiema, L. Gauvin, M.-V. Zunzunegui, and Q. Xu Duration of Poverty and Child Health in the Quebec Longitudinal Study of Child Development: Longitudinal Analysis of a Birth Cohort Pediatrics, May 1, 2007; 119(5): e1063 - e1070. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. L. McQuaid, D. Koinis Mitchell, N. Walders, J. H. Nassau, S. J. Kopel, R. B. Klein, M. Z. Wamboldt, and G. K. Fritz Pediatric Asthma Morbidity: The Importance of Symptom Perception and Family Response to Symptoms J. Pediatr. Psychol., March 1, 2007; 32(2): 167 - 177. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. K. Lehman, K. A. Lillis, S. H. Shaha, M. Augustine, and M. Ballow Initiation of Maintenance Antiinflammatory Medication in Asthmatic Children in a Pediatric Emergency Department Pediatrics, December 1, 2006; 118(6): 2394 - 2401. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Smith, J. A. Krishnan, A. Bilderback, K. A. Riekert, C. S. Rand, and S. J. Bartlett Depressive symptoms and adherence to asthma therapy after hospital discharge. Chest, October 1, 2006; 130(4): 1034 - 1038. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. G. Bender Risk Taking, Depression, Adherence, and Symptom Control in Adolescents and Young Adults with Asthma Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., May 1, 2006; 173(9): 953 - 957. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. McDaniel, C. Paxson, and J. Waldfogel Racial Disparities in Childhood Asthma in the United States: Evidence From the National Health Interview Survey, 1997 to 2003 Pediatrics, May 1, 2006; 117(5): e868 - e877. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. S. Minkovitz, D. Strobino, D. Scharfstein, W. Hou, T. Miller, K. B. Mistry, and K. Swartz Maternal Depressive Symptoms and Children's Receipt of Health Care in the First 3 Years of Life Pediatrics, February 1, 2005; 115(2): 306 - 314. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||