PEDIATRICS Vol. 108 No. 5 November 2001, p. e87
, b,
,
, and
From the * Division of Infectious Diseases and Geographic
Medicine, Stanford University Medical Center, Stanford, California;
Background. Cohort and case-crossover
studies were conducted to evaluate whether new Helicobacter
pylori infections are followed by increased diarrhea.
Methods. Participants were 6-month-old to 12-year-old
shantytown residents living near Lima, Peru. Baseline data were
collected from community households. Health interviews were completed
daily, and sera, drawn every 4 months, were tested for H
pylori immunoglobulin G. Diarrhea rates among newly H
pylori-infected (seroconverting) children were compared with
rates among persistently uninfected and infected children using cohort
and case-crossover analyses.
Results. Sera were obtained from 345 children from January
1, 1995, through September 1, 1997. H pylori incidence
was 12% per year (36 H pylori infections in 109 866
seronegative days). In adjusted cohort analyses, seroconverters had
more diarrhea days (rate ratio: 2.0; 95% confidence interval:
1.6-2.4), episodes, and sick days in the year after infection than did
uninfected children; and more diarrhea days and sick days than did
persistently infected children. This effect was strongest in the first
2 months. Case-crossover analyses supported these findings.
Conclusion. Preventing H pylori infection
may help reduce pediatric diarrheal disease.
US Naval Military Research Detachment (NAMRID), Lima, Peru;
§ Asociasión Benéfica PRISMA, Lima, Peru; and
Department
of International Medicine, Johns Hopkins School of Public Health,
Baltimore, Maryland.
![]()
ABSTRACT
Top
Abstract
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
Helicobacter pylori infection is extremely
common, infecting 20% to 60% of adults in developed countries and
nearly all adults in developing countries.1-8 Chronic
infection with H pylori Acute H pylori infections often cause transient
hypochlorhydria beginning as soon as 2 weeks after
infection.18,2024-26 In a cluster of probable H
pylori infections transmitted by nasogastric instrumentation,
hypochlorhydria lasted for a median of 4 months after infection among
14 of the 17 adults who recovered normal gastric acidity; 3 adults
remained hypochlorhydric during throughout the year-long study
period.17,19 Hypochlorhydria has also been demonstrated in
newly H pylori-infected Gambian infants.23
Although there are several potential mechanisms by which H
pylori could lead to increased enteric infections, hypochlorhydria
is a documented risk factor for a number of enteric infections, notably
cholera and salmonellosis.27-30
We hypothesize that acute H pylori infection leads to an
increase in diarrheal illness for several months after infection. To
test this hypothesis, we conducted a retrospective cohort study of
children in a shantytown near Lima, Peru. In Peru, diarrhea is a major
cause of childhood morbidity, and H pylori infects up to
50% of children and 90% of older adults.31
Participants
This study was conducted in Pampas de San Juan de Miraflores
(Pampas), a community 10 km north of Lima. Of its 36 000+ inhabitants, 45% are Demographic and socioeconomic information was collected in 1995 from
each participating household and serum specimens were taken from each
index child. Sera were then collected from children every 4 months for
the duration of follow-up. Fieldworkers visited each household daily
(Monday-Friday) and administered a short questionnaire about the
child's health. Informed consent for blood sampling and interviews was
obtained from all participating households.
H pylori Antibody Testing
Sera were tested for H pylori-specific immunoglobulin
G (IgG) using an in-house enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay
(EIA)14 modified for use in Peru. High-binding microwell
plates were coated with antigen (1:428 dilution) derived from 5 Peruvian H pylori strains. Serum (1:150) and goat anti-human
IgG (1:2000) were added. The assay was standardized using sera from 19 seronegative and 16 biopsy-confirmed seropositive Peruvian adult and
child controls. An optical density (OD) twice the mean of the negative
controls indicated H pylori infection; using this cutoff,
positive and negative controls showed complete separation. Serial
samples from each child were run on the same plate; ODs were adjusted
using at least three calibrated controls per plate. Analyses were
performed using the mean adjusted OD of triplicate runs. Infants <6
months old were excluded to avoid interference from maternal IgG
antibody.33
Children were categorized as uninfected (all samples negative),
persistently infected (all samples positive), transiently infected
[earlier sample(s) positive and later sample(s) negative] or newly
infected (a change between 2 consecutive samples from negative to
positive with a 50% or greater increase in OD).34 Newly
infected children could also be considered transiently infected if they
later lost H pylori antibody. Children in whom consecutive sera changed from negative to positive with a <50% increase in OD
were excluded from analysis.
An assessment of the time required to develop H
pylori-specific IgG antibody has been published in 3 adults and 1 child who developed acute infection. Seroconversion in the 3 adults
occurred, respectively, between 3 and 14 weeks,26 between
2 and 11 weeks,35 and >7 weeks36 after the
probable date of infection. Seroconversion in the child probably
occurred between 5 and 10 weeks after infection.37 We
therefore estimated that H pylori infection occurred at the
midpoint between each child's last negative and first positive serum
minus 7 weeks.
Measures of illness included:
which is typically acquired in childhood and persists throughout life
causes a variety of chronic diseases: duodenal9,10 and gastric11 ulcers,
gastric cancer,12,13 and gastric
lymphoma.14,15The health effects of acute H
pylori infection, however, are unknown. Reports in adults suggest
that newly established infection is accompanied by mild
gastrointestinal symptoms, although no controlled studies have been
performed.16-20 Childhood infection has been linked to
chronic diarrhea and growth retardation. Whether H pylori
causes these problems or is simply a marker for other factors is
unclear.21-23
![]()
METHODS
Top
Abstract
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
18 years old. Most residences are huts with sheet metal roofing; indoor plumbing is rare.32 The cohort was
comprised of 3 population-based samplings of Pampas children: 1) a
random sample of children aged 0-24 months that comprised 36% of
final cohort; 2) a random sample of children aged 0 to 30 months that comprised 28% of the final cohort; and 3) a random sample of children 0 to 12 years old that comprised 36% of the final cohort. Enrolling 1 child per consenting household yielded a cohort of 412 children 6 months to 12 years old with a median age of 18 months.
Bivariate Analysis
Bivariate analyses were performed using the Mantel-Haenszel
2 test for categorical variables and the
Student t test or the Kruskal-Wallis 2-sample test for
integer and continuous variables. All comparisons were 2-tailed.
Confidence intervals for proportions were calculated using a normal
approximation of the binomial distribution.39 Seasonality
was assessed using a modification of the Hewitt test.40
Multivariate Analysis
Cohort Analysis Adjusted incidence rate (incidence density) ratios for diarrhea days among the entire cohort were determined using 2 Poisson regression models.41 Covariates initially included in model 1 included: age (using its square root, as it significantly improved the fit of the model), season, household crowding, sleeping density, birth order (firstborn versus other) and the presence of stunting. Household socioeconomic variables included: type of household flooring, presence of electricity or running water,42 ownership of a television or farm animals, and educational attainment of the head of household (whether or not completed eighth grade). Model 2, developed for children <4 years old, also included whether the child had been breastfed or bottle-fed at least once in the previous day. Stepwise backward elimination was used to remove covariates not associated with diarrhea days (P < .2) in at least 1 model.
We first developed adjusted baseline rates of illness (diarrhea days, diarrhea episodes, diarrhea sick days, and cough days) for persistently H pylori-infected and uninfected children throughout the study period. We then compared adjusted baseline rates of illness in persistently uninfected or persistently infected children with rates among newly infected children at several time periods before and after the estimated dates of infection. The periods analyzed were: from 12 through 3 months before; 2 months before; month 1 after (ie, the first month after); month 2 after; months 3 and 4 after; months 5 through 8 after; and months 9 through 12 after the estimated onset of infection. The population-attributable risk (PAR) of diarrhea sick days from acute H pylori infection was calculated using the formula:
|
Case-Crossover Analysis To assess unrecognized sources of confounding, a case-crossover analysis compared newly infected children to themselves at earlier and later periods. Crude rates of diarrheal illness for these children in the first 3 months after acquisition of infection were compared with the pooled rates during the same 3 months 1 year earlier and 1 year later, using the rank-sum test.44 This analysis was performed using only the subset of children who had seroconverted and who had complete follow-up for the case period and 1 or more months in the crossover periods.
Definitions
Breastfed means that the child was breastfed at least once in the preceding 24-hour period, irrespective of other feeding methods. Bottle-fed means that the child was bottle-fed at least once in the preceding 24-hour period, irrespective of other feeding methods. Sleeping density is the number of people who stayed overnight at the house at least twice weekly divided by the number of bedrooms. Crowding is the number of people who stayed overnight at least twice weekly divided by the roofed area of the house. Running water means that the household drew water for daily use from a pipe and tap mechanism on the homestead. False floor means that the bottom surface of the house is built off ground; this usually implies a higher quality of housing construction than a floor set directly on ground. A farm animal is a pig, chicken, or rabbit. Stunting means height-for-age >2 standard deviations below World Health Organization norms.45
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
H pylori Status of Participants
Of 412 enrolled children, 345 (84%) provided baseline and
1
follow-up serum sample (mean: 3.8 samples per child). The 67 children
who did not provide follow-up sera were of similar age and
socioeconomic status as children who provided follow-up serum. Children
who provided follow-up sera were a median of 17.5 months (interquartile
range: 13-50 months) of age during the study period and were followed
for a median of 424 days, contributing 109 866 days of follow-up. Of
these 345 children, 259 (75%) were persistently uninfected, 39 (11%)
were persistently infected, 2 (1%) were initially seropositive but
were subsequently seronegative (transiently infected) and 32 (9%)
developed a new H pylori infection. Thirteen children (4%)
became seropositive during the study period but had small (<50%)
increases in OD between consecutive sera and were not included in
subsequent analyses. Of the 32 newly infected children, 7 (22%) later
lost H pylori antibodies; 4 of these 7 again became
seropositive during the study period. Children who lost antibodies (and
the subset who regained them) had similar rates of antibiotic use as
other seroconverting children. Assuming all seroconversions were
detected, the incidence of H pylori infection was 12% per person-year (36 H pylori infections in 109 866 seronegative
days-at-risk; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 8%-17%); if the 13 borderline seroconversions were considered to represent real
infections, then the incidence of H pylori infection was
14% (45 new H pylori infections in 115 398 seronegative
days-at-risk; 95% CI: 10%-19%). Eighteen girls and 14 boys
seroconverted (Fig 1). Although more
seroconversions
7
occurred in January than in any other month, no
seasonal clustering was evident.
|
Risk Factors for Diarrhea
Of 345 children, 262 (76%) had diarrhea at some point during the study period. Diarrhea was reported on 2.2% of follow-up days, ranging from 3.9% in children 6 to 12 months old to 0.7% in children 10 to 12 years old. Children <4 years old had 4.0 reported diarrheal episodes per year. Diarrheal illness was seasonal; diarrhea days were more frequent in all months from February through June than in other months (Hewitt's P = .02).
In multivariate analysis (model 1), the following factors were associated with an increased risk of diarrhea days: younger age, calendar years 1996 and 1997, calendar quarter April through June, female sex, having older siblings in the household, and having farm animals in the household. Higher educational attainment by the head of household and the presence of a television, electricity, or running water were associated with a decreased risk of diarrhea days. In model 2 (the adjusted model restricted to children 4 years old or younger), running water in the house and breastfeeding or bottle-feeding (as opposed to eating only solid food) were also associated with a decreased risk of diarrhea days (Table 1).
|
Cohort Analyses
The rate of diarrheal illness among children who developed a new H pylori infection was compared with rates in persistently uninfected and infected children. The rate of diarrheal illness among children who developed a new H pylori infection was compared separately against rates in persistently uninfected and in persistently infected children. Crude rates of diarrheal illness and coughing (unadjusted for age or other covariates) were lowest for persistently infected children, highest for persistently uninfected children, and intermediate for newly infected children in the year after onset of infection (Table 2). However, in the adjusted analysis (model 1), newly infected children had more diarrheal illness than persistently uninfected children during the first 2, 8 and 12 months after the estimated onset of H pylori infection (Table 3). In the year after infection, these children had more diarrhea days (rate ratio [RR]: 2.0; 95% CI: 1.6-2.4), more diarrhea episodes (RR: 1.9; 95% CI: 1.4-2.5), and more diarrhea sick days (RR: 2.0; 95% CI: 1.4-2.9) than did uninfected children. The rate of cough (the comparison symptom) decreased during this time (RR: 0.8; 95% CI: 0.7-0.9). These effects were unchanged when analyzing only children 4 years old or younger (model 2; Table 3). Assuming a H pylori incidence of 12% in this community, 10.6% of 24-month-old children would be expected to have an H pylori infection that had occurred in the previous year. Therefore, 11.5% of diarrhea sick days among Pampas children <4 years old could be attributed to new H pylori infection.
|
|
The influence of new H pylori infection on rates of diarrheal illness was strongest in the first 2 months after infection. Rate ratios for all measures of diarrhea among newly infected children showed a clear rise and fall during the year after infection; no similar trend was demonstrated for cough (Fig 2). To assess whether our findings were robust, we repeated the analyses 3 additional times: a) omitting the 4 recurrent infections; b) omitting the 7 transient infections; and c) including the 13 children with borderline seroconversion as true seroconverters. None of these 3 modifications significantly altered the observed effect sizes or trends.
|
To evaluate the effects of acute versus chronic H pylori infection, we compared the rates of illness in newly infected children with rates in persistently infected children. When compared with persistently infected children, newly infected children had an increase in diarrhea days (RR: 1.7; 95% CI: 1.3-2.4), episodes (RR: 1.6; 95% CI: 1.0-2.5; P = .065), and sick days (RR: 3.2; 95% CI: 1.6-6.7) in the year after infection. Analyses adjusting for breastfeeding or bottle-feeding (model 2) could not be performed because of small numbers.
Case-Crossover Analyses
Data for crossover periods were available for only 11 of the 36 seroconversions that were followed in the in the cohort study. Among
these children, crude rates of diarrhea were higher in the 3 months
after H pylori infection than in either the 3 months of the
year before or after this period (Table
4). In the pooled case-crossover
analysis, diarrhea days (RR: 2.84; 95% CI: 0.15
), episodes
(RR: 2.77; 95% CI: 0.34
), and sick days (RR:
; 95% CI:
0
), but not cough days (RR: 0.95; 95% CI: 0.0-14.9),
tended to be more frequent in the 3 months immediately after H
pylori infection than in the 3 corresponding months of the years
before and after.
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this study, we found that new H pylori
infection in children is followed by a period
several months to a
year
of increased diarrhea. This increase occurred among children who,
at baseline, did not have more diarrhea than other children (Fig 2). Moreover, because diarrhea rates in the setting of acute H
pylori infection were greater than those seen in chronically
infected children, we cannot attribute the increased diarrhea simply to the presence of H pylori, or to spurious effects associated
with H pylori serostatus. Instead, it appears to result from
some, as yet unclear, factor related to acute infection.
Loss of the gastric acid barrier permits ingested pathogens to more readily cause diarrheal disease.46-48 Postmarketing surveillance of the histamine-blocker cimetidine revealed a 4.3-fold increase in diarrhea among persons taking the drug compared with controls.49 Salmonella and Vibrio cholerae disproportionately infect hypochlorhydric patients28-30; 1 hospital-based study showed a 3.1-fold increased odds of salmonellosis among persons with iatrogenic achlorhydria.31 Similarly, the infectious dose of ingested Campylobacter jejuni was reduced among volunteers who first drank sodium bicarbonate.50 Although resistance to gastric acid among Escherichia coli is probably strain-specific,51,52 the infectious dose of enterotoxigenic E coli infection is decreased among hypochlorhydric persons.53-55 Other acid-sensitive organisms that might preferentially cause diarrhea in people with hypochlorhydria include rotavirus and other enteric viruses,56-58 Brucella spp.,59 and Giardia lamblia.42
Although not proven, it is therefore plausible that temporary loss of
the gastric acid barrier could mediate the observed association between
H pylori and diarrheal disease, because H pylori-induced hypochlorhydria has been observed after acute
infection in adults.17,18,2024-26 This hypochlorhydria
may result from neutrophilic inflammation at the neck of parietal
cells
which could physically block acid secretion into the
stomach20,60
or from the generation of an acute-phase
protein that transiently blocks the acid-producing capability of the
cells.61 However, no direct evidence yet links H
pylori, hypochlorhydria, and diarrhea. Moreover, these mechanisms
are controversial, and there are other potential mechanisms by which
H pylori could lead to gastroenteritis-like illness. H
pylori infection has been linked to protein-losing enteropathy62 and to food allergies,63 which can cause diarrhea. Application of the H pylori cytotoxin
VacA to the surface of human intestine-derived cell monolayers promotes apical Cl
and water secretion.64
Finally, H pylori attachment to gastric epithelial cells
could cause a cytokine-mediated diarrhea by promoting, for example,
systemic elaboration of IL-8.65-68 One or several of
these mechanisms could be responsible for an acute infection syndrome
which has
so far
been difficult to elucidate. Research to detect
other effects of Helicobacter species in the human intestine
and to determine if natural H pylori infections are followed
by a period of hypochlorhydria is ongoing.
This study suggests that H pylori has developed an elegant survival strategy. Our laboratory has shown that H pylori is not normally cultured from the stools of infected adults, but that viable H pylori are routinely excreted when diarrhea is induced.69 We postulate that H pylori either causes or indirectly promotes gastroenteritis in the months after acute infection as a means of transmission between young children. Because most acute H pylori infections occur in children, and because young children are the most susceptible to diarrheal illness, this is the group most likely to suffer from H pylori-associated diarrhea. After this initial period, H pylori (usually) becomes a quiescent, lifelong infection, thereby maintaining its striking prevalence. In fact, there is evidence from a cross-sectional study in German schoolchildren that chronic infection protects against diarrheal diseases.70 However, both our study and studies using the 13C-urea breath test to detect H pylori infection among younger Peruvian children have shown that 20% or more of early infections are transient, and may be followed by recurrent acute infection.71,72 The deleterious health effects of acute H pylori infection may by most important in areas of the world where infection (and repeat infection) is most common.
One limitation of our study is that seroreversion may not occur for more than a year after H pylori eradication.72 Because young children spontaneously eradicate H pylori, it is possible that some children classified as persistently seropositive were actually uninfected. This could have diluted the effect of chronic infection on diarrheal disease. However, because we found only 2 seroreverters in this cohort, we suspect that the number of seroreverters misclassified as seropositives was also small. The most critical limitation of this study was our inability to accurately determine infection onset; dates of H pylori seroconversion were crude estimates interpolated from consecutive serum samples. Serology is neither as sensitive nor as specific as the 13C-urea breath test for detecting H pylori colonization73 in children. However, we used stringent criteria for seroconversion, to maximize the chance that seroconverters truly had been recently infected. Nevertheless, we suspect that trends over time (Fig 2) would have been even more clearly defined had we been able to reduce these sources of misclassification.74 Our inability to accurately assess infection onset also leaves open the possibility that a period of increased diarrheal disease precedes or facilitates H pylori infection. However, because diarrheal disease rates were consistently below baseline before seroconversion, this possibility seems unlikely (unless our estimate of the time from infection to IgG formation is grossly incorrect).
This study in a Peruvian community demonstrated that about 12% of
susceptible children were infected by H pylori each year and
that these children had twice the risk of diarrheal disease in the year
after infection as children who remained uninfected. Complications of
diarrheal disease kill 3 million children yearly; most of these
complications occur in regions of the world where H pylori
infection is common.75,76 Prevention of H
pylori infection
for example, by
immunization77,78
may eventually become part of a broader
strategy to reduce the impact of pediatric diarrheal disease as well as
to prevent cancer and ulcer disease. Examining the mechanisms
underlying H pylori-associated diarrheal disease is an
important avenue for future research.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
This study was supported in part by National Institutes of Health Grant 1K23-AI01602-01.
We thank Drs Martin Blaser, Catherine Ley, and Atsuko Shibata for providing valuable suggestions regarding data analysis.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
a
Present affiliation: Division of
Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health, University of
Illinois
Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
b Present affiliation: Department of Enteric Infections, Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, Silver Spring, Maryland.
Received for publication Nov 10 2000; accepted Jun 26, 2001.
This paper was presented, in part, at the 36th Annual Meeting of the Infectious Disease Society of America Annual Meeting; November 12-15, 1998; Denver, CO.
Reprint requests to (D.J.P.) Division of Epidemiology and
Biostatistics, School of Public Health, University of
Illinois
Chicago, 221 W Taylor St, Chicago, IL 60612. E-mail:
doug{at}uic.edu
| |
ABBREVIATIONS |
|---|
IgG, Immunoglobulin G; EIA, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; OD, optical density; PAR, population-attributable risk; 95% CI, confidence interval; RR, rate ratio.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||