PEDIATRICS Vol. 107 No. 6 June 2001, pp. 1351-1356
Child Health Status, Neurodevelopmental Outcome, and Parental Satisfaction in a Randomized, Controlled Trial of Nitric Oxide for Persistent Pulmonary Hypertension of the Newborn
,
, ¶,
From the * Department of Pediatrics, New York Hospital Medical
Center of Queens, New York, New York; Objective. To describe health and
neurodevelopmental outcomes and parental satisfaction with hospital
care among surviving intervention and control enrollees in a
randomized, controlled trial of nitric oxide for persistent pulmonary
hypertension of the newborn (PPHN).
Methods. All surviving enrollees 1 to 4 years of age were
eligible for follow-up. Outcomes were assessed by telephone using a
trained interviewer and standardized instruments. Domains assessed
included parental report of specific conditions and hospital use,
rating of general health, cognitive and motor development, behavior
problems, temperament, and satisfaction with the hospital stay.
Fisher's exact test and the Wilcoxon rank sum test assessed
differences between intervention and control infants.
Results. Interviews were completed on 60 of 83 survivors
(72%). Eighteen families (22%) could not be located, 2 (2%) were
non-English-speaking, and 3 (4%) declined participation. No
postdischarge deaths were ascertained. Among those interviewed, race,
income, and education of parents of intervention and controls were
comparable, as were entry oxygenation index, extracorporeal oxygenation
utilization, and days of hospitalization. No differences were found in
pulmonary, neurologic, cognitive, behavioral, or neurosensory outcomes;
hospital readmission rates; or parental ratings of child's health. The overall neurologic handicap rate was 15%. The rate of hearing deficit
was 7%. The rate of significant behavioral problems was 26%. Levels
of satisfaction expressed were high for each group. No differences in
parental ratings were found between the 2 groups.
Conclusions. No adverse health or neurodevelopmental
outcomes have been observed among infants treated with nitric oxide for
PPHN. The parents of the critically ill infants enrolled in our
clinical trial welcomed their child's inclusion and all expressed
satisfaction with the care that their child received while at a
tertiary care hospital. Enrollment in either arm of this randomized,
controlled trial did not seem to affect parental satisfaction with the
hospital care that their child received.
Department of Pediatrics,
Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, New York;
§ Department of Pediatrics, University of California-San Francisco, San
Francisco, California;
Neuroepidemiology Unit, Children's Hospital
of Boston, Boston, Massachusetts; ¶ Department of Pediatrics, Division
of Newborn Medicine, Children's Hospital of Boston, Harvard Medical
School, Boston, Massachusetts; # Department of Maternal and Child
Health, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts; and the
** Department of Cardiology, Children's Hospital of Boston, Boston,
Massachusetts.
![]()
ABSTRACT
Top
Abstract
Methods
Results
Discussion
Conclusion
References
Infants with persistent pulmonary hypertension of the
newborn (PPHN) are critically ill in the neonatal period and are known to be at risk for adverse health and neurodevelopmental outcomes. Published health and neurodevelopmental follow-up studies report that
survivors of PPHN are at risk for pulmonary morbidities, hearing and speech loss, cerebral palsy, seizures, stroke, and developmental delay.1-6 Many of these studies reflect the
experience with extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO), as
well as older management approaches. More recent approaches include
inhaled nitric oxide, which has proven successful in multicenter trials
for the treatment of PPHN and respiratory failure. Inhaled nitric oxide
improves oxygenation and reduces the need for ECMO.7,8 To
examine the health and neurodevelopmental outcomes of infants treated with nitric oxide for PPHN, we followed surviving children ages 1 to 4 years who were participants of a randomized, controlled trial of nitric
oxide in PPHN.
We also explored parental reactions to participation in randomized,
controlled trials. The process of clinical trials requires the informed
consent of parents whose critically ill infants may or may not receive
the new therapy. Parents have expressed both suspicion of novel
therapies as well as a desire for assessment of the safety and efficacy
of clinical interventions.9 Assessment of parental
attitudes toward enrollment in a nonblinded, randomized, controlled
study is, therefore, a valuable avenue of investigation. To assess
parental reactions to the hospital experience, including participation
in the trial, we chose to measure patient satisfaction, because it
gauges the parents' reaction to the process of care, importantly, both
the technical quality and the interpersonal aspects.10-12
Our follow-up study of infants enrolled in a clinical trial evaluating
the effectiveness of nitric oxide for PPHN sought to determine whether
there were differences among intervention and control infants in health
and neurodevelopmental outcomes or parental satisfaction with care. We
did not anticipate differences in health or neurodevelopmental
outcomes; however, we suspected that the parents of infants who did not
receive the experimental therapy might be less satisfied with the care
that their child received than would be the parents of the infants who
did.
From September 1992 through January 1997, 90 infants admitted to
Children's Hospital with PPHN were randomized with parental consent to
receive conventional therapy or conventional therapy plus nitric oxide.
Entry criteria included respiratory failure, as defined by ventilatory
support requiring 100% oxygen with persistent hypoxia, and documented
pulmonary hypertension by echo or ductal shunting. During this period,
nitric oxide was used only within protocol. All analysis was performed
following intent-to-treat criteria. No parents refused participation in
the trial and there were no withdrawals for any reason. Protocols and
results of this study have been published elsewhere.13,14
We attempted to contact the 83 survivors at 1 to 4 years of age using
mail and telephone search strategies described
previously.15 Forty-three children had received nitric
oxide, and 40 received conventional therapy. The Children's Hospital
Committee on Clinical Investigation approved the study.
Data Collection
Study data were collected through a telephone interview using a
questionnaire. The interviewer was blinded to treatment group. Interviews required ~20 minutes to complete. Specific items included:
![]()
METHODS
Top
Abstract
Methods
Results
Discussion
Conclusion
References
Analyses
Patient's whom we successfully interviewed were compared with those with whom we were unsuccessful by severity of illness measures and available sociodemographic factors. The nitric oxide and control groups were compared for differences in sociodemographic factors and characteristics of the neonatal hospitalization. Statistical significance was determined using the Wilcoxon rank sum test and Fisher's exact test. Multivariate regression was performed to determine whether socioeconomic factors contributed to variation in health, developmental, and satisfaction outcomes.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Characteristics of Sample
Interviews were completed on 60 of 83 of the survivors (72%); 35 intervention infants and 25 controls. Eighteen families (22%) were not located, 2 (2%) were non-English-speaking, and 3 (4%) declined participation. No postdischarge deaths were ascertained. No differences were seen between respondents and nonrespondents in mean entry oxygenation index, ECMO use, sex, insurance status, or distance from Children's Hospital. Respondents, however, were more likely to have received nitric oxide (Table 1).
|
The vast majority of caretakers interviewed were biologic parents. There were 2 exceptions: a foster mother and a female relative, each of whom had been the caretaker since discharge from the hospital. No differences emerged in sex, mean entry oxygenation index, ECMO use, length of stay, or age at interview between intervention and control infants. There were likewise no differences in race, income, or education of the parents of intervention and control infants (Table 2).
|
Health Outcomes
The intervention and control groups were similar in pulmonary, neurologic, or neurosensory outcomes and in hospital readmission rates (Table 3). Likewise, parents of each group reported that their children's health, behavior, temperament, and cognitive development were similar. The vast majority of respondents (65%) reported that their child did not have any morbidities. Twenty-seven percent reported at least 1 hospital readmission. The overall neurologic handicap rate reported by respondents was 15%. The rate of hearing deficit reported was 7%. The rate of hearing or speech disability reported was 18%. Visual disability was reported by 8% of respondents. Ten percent of respondents recalled that their child was discharged from the hospital from the initial hospitalization on oxygen, and 18% reported that their child had suffered from asthma at some point since discharge. The rate of significant behavioral problems reported was 26%.
|
Satisfaction
A high level of satisfaction with the tertiary care received was expressed. No difference between the 2 groups in parental ratings of overall satisfaction with hospital care was seen (Table 3). Furthermore, there was no difference in parental satisfaction between the parents of infants who had undergone ECMO or the parents of infants who reported current morbidities. No respondent agreed that "doctor's experimented on infants," and all respondents agreed that they "appreciated being at an institution that offered experimental therapies."
Multivariate linear regression was performed to determine whether level of parental education or family income contributed any variation to the comparisons of parental health ratings, cognitive development, behavior and temperament, and parental satisfaction with care. Level of parental income was significantly associated with cognitive development but not other outcomes. In no case did the association with study status change with entry of parental education into the models.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
As we hypothesized, no differences in the neurodevelopmental or health outcomes were seen for surviving infants with PPHN with or without nitric oxide treatment. In addition, contrary to our expectation, we have found that enrollment in either arm of this nonblinded, randomized, controlled trial did not affect parental satisfaction with the hospital care that their child received.
Our follow-up study suggests that nitric oxide therapy does not pose any additional risk of adverse health or neurodevelopmental outcomes compared with conventional therapy for PPHN. In fact, the decrease observed in hypoxemia and ECMO use among infants with PPHN suggests the potential for an overall improvement in the outcome of infants with PPHN as a result of nitric oxide therapy.7,8,13,14
Comparison of our findings with previously reported health and neurodevelopmental outcomes is difficult because of inconsistency in outcome measures across studies and small sample size, particularly in the pre-ECMO era. However, when neurodevelopmental disability is defined as presence of cerebral palsy, DQ < 70, or seizures, disability rates are in the range of 0% to 36%.1-627-37 Early studies (pre-1990) reported a higher rate of poor outcomes. Our neurodevelopmental disability rate of 15% is consistent with the more recent reports of outcomes of ECMO, as well as the recent report by Rosenberg et al,38 in which 12% of nitric-treated PPHN survivors had severe neurodevelopmental disabilities. Rosenberg et al,38 however, does not include seizure disorders in the definition of neurodevelopmental disabilities.
Poor neurosensory outcomes, defined as hearing, speech, or visual impairment, received significant attention in published reports of the 1980s. Reported rates of impairment were variable, ranging from 5% to 53%, with a predominance of hearing loss and abnormal speech patterns.3,6,27,30,31,3335-37 Rates of visual impairment ranged from 0% to 13%.27,32,35 Our finding of 18% prevalence of hearing or speech problems reflects this previous literature. Our findings are also consistent with Rosenberg et al,38 of 6% hearing loss because parents reported hearing problems in 7% of our study sample.
Pulmonary sequelae, defined as reactive airway disease, chronic lung disease, and rehospitalization for respiratory illnesses, ranged from 25% to 30%.2,6,32 Our findings of pulmonary sequelae are also consistent with the previous literature.
Behavioral outcomes have not previously been described among survivors of PPHN. Parental reports of difficult temperament among 1- to 2-year-olds are similar to published norms.26 Rates of clinically significant behavior problems among 2- to 4-year-olds, however, were higher than the prevalence of 14% in reference populations.24 We found that 16% of intervention patients and 40% of controls exhibited problem behaviors, although median scores did not differ. The prevalence of behavior problems deserves additional examination in future outcome studies of PPHN survivors.
Parental reports of current health are similar to reference populations.19 There are, however, striking differences between parental reports of susceptibility to illness and previous health between our group of infants and the reference populations. Consistent with their life-threatening neonatal experiences, parents rated their child's past health more poorly than published norms.
In summary, the health and neurodevelopmental outcomes of our cohort are consistent with the experience reported among PPHN survivors. There was no difference in outcome among those treated with nitric oxide and those receiving conventional medical therapy.
Our study also provides encouragement for tertiary care centers engaging in the clinical investigation of new therapies and technologies. To our knowledge, no studies of patient satisfaction with participation in clinical trials have been published. We found that most parents expressed high levels of satisfaction with the care received at a tertiary care center using investigational therapies with no difference between the groups in level of satisfaction. No one expressed distrust of physicians with regard to research, and all parents appreciated that their critically ill infant was cared for at an institution that offered experimental therapies.
Our study also provides additional experience with using survey methodologies in the follow-up of critically ill neonatal intensive care unit graduates at risk for health, neurodevelopmental, and behavioral morbidities. Although telephone interviews and other survey techniques do not replace direct patient examination and observation, these methodologies might prove valuable adjuncts for infant follow-up programs confronting funding limitations.
We must also acknowledge the limitations of our study. First, although our cohort of 60 infants is larger than most previously published cohorts, our power to detect differences in health and neurodevelopmental outcomes between intervention and control infants is limited. For example, a full standard deviation difference in the mean scores of DQ would have been needed to achieve statistical significance. Thus, although we have shared the striking differences in the numbers of intervention and control infants with DQs < 70, we must emphasize that our study does not detect differences in the median DQs of the 2 groups. Second, the timing of assessment has implications for interpreting the results. For example, we could not assess for any learning difficulties, which may become evident as our cohort reaches school age. Third, our study relies on parental report during telephone interview. Although this approach is validated and would not affect the detection of severe disabilities, mild neurologic deficits may be underestimated. Additionally, we were unable to elicit information concerning the infants' growth and head circumference. This information is often part of infant follow-up studies. Fourth, parental satisfaction with care might be influenced by the child's current health status, although in our small sample we detected no such influence. Alternatively, the survival of a child with life-threatening illness may lead to high satisfaction irrespective of treatment or outcome. Finally, we ethically could not assess the satisfaction with care of the parents of children who died. Differences in reaction to study status may be more pronounced among those whose children did not survive.
| |
CONCLUSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We detected no excess adverse health or neurodevelopmental outcome among PPHN survivors treated with nitric oxide compared with those treated with conventional therapies. Parents of the critically ill infants enrolled in our clinical trial welcomed their child's inclusion. Most parents subsequently expressed satisfaction with the tertiary care that their child received. Given that in our trial inhaled nitric oxide reduced the need for ECMO and did not adversely affect platelet function, our results suggest no adverse sequelae from exposure to nitric oxide.14,39 Furthermore, our results argue for more attention to outcomes, such as behavior and satisfaction with care, in randomized, controlled trials.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
This program was supported by the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Grant T32HD07392 and a grant from Ohmeda. Dr Wessel was supported by Grant FD-R00133136 from the Food and Drug Administration. Dr Kourembanas was supported by Grants R01 HL55454 and P50HL46491 from the American Heart Association and the National Institutes of Health. Data collection was performed at Children's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts.
We thank David Gemmel and Melissa Himes of the Research Department of Western Reserve Health Care for their assistance in the editing and preparation of this manuscript.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication Feb 4, 2000; accepted Oct 10, 2000.
Reprint requests to (M.E.) Department of Pediatrics, New York Hospital Medical Center of Queens, 56-45 Main St, Flushing, New York 11355. E-mail: mae9011{at}nyp.org
| |
ABBREVIATIONS |
|---|
PPHN, persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn; ECMO, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; DQ, developmental quotient; PSQ, Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-
Bifano EM,
Pfannenstiel A
Duration of hyperventilation and outcome
in infants with persistent pulmonary hypertension.
Pediatrics
1988;
81:657-661
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Bernbaum JC, Russell P, Sheridan PH, Long-term follow-up of newborns with persistent pulmonary hypertension. Crit Care Med 1984; 12:579-583 [Medline]
-
Hendricks-Muñoz KD,
Walton JP
Hearing loss in infants with
persistent fetal circulation.
Pediatrics
1988;
81:650-656
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Scher MS, Klesh KW, Murphy F, Guthrie RD Seizures and infarction in neonates with persistent pulmonary hypertension. Pediatr Neurol 1986; 2:332-339 [CrossRef][Medline]
-
Glass P,
Miller M,
Short B
Morbidity for survivors of extracorporeal
membrane oxygenation: neurodevelopmental outcome at 1 year of age.
Pediatrics
1989;
83:72-78
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
Schumacher RE,
Palmer TW,
Roloff DW,
LaClaire PA,
Bartlett RH
Follow-up of infants treated with extracorporeal membrane oxygenation
for newborn respiratory failure.
Pediatrics
1991;
87:451-457
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
The Neonatal Inhaled Nitric Oxide Study
Inhaled nitric oxide in
full-term and nearly full-term infants with hypoxic respiratory
failure.
N Engl J Med
1997;
336:597-604
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
Roberts JD,
Fineman JR,
Morin FC III,
Inhaled nitric oxide and
persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn: the inhaled nitric
oxide study group.
N Engl J Med
1997;
336:605-610
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
Harrison H
The principles of family-centered neonatal care.
Pediatrics
1993;
92:643-650
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Ware JE, Snyder MK, Wright R, Davies AR Defining and measuring patient satisfaction with medical care. Evaluation Program Planning 1983; 6:247-263
- Davies AR, Ware JE Involving consumers in quality of care assessment. Health Aff (Millwood) 1988; 7:33-48 [CrossRef][Medline]
- Cleary PD, McNeil BJ Patient satisfaction as an indicator of quality care. Inquiry 1988; 25:25-36 [Medline]
- Wessel DL, Adatia I, Van Marter LJ, et al. Improved oxygenation in a randomized trial of inhaled nitric oxide for persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn. Pediatrics. 1997;100(5). URL: http://www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/100/5/e7
- Christou H, Van Marter LJ, Wessel DL, Combination of inhaled nitric oxide with HFOV reduces the need for ECMO. Pediatr Res 1998; 43:169A
-
Klonoff-Cohen H
Tracking strategies involving fourteen sources for
locating a transient study sample: parents of sudden infant death
syndrome infants and control infants.
Am J Epidemiol
1996;
144:98-101
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
McCormick MC,
Brooks-Gunn J,
Workman-Daniels K,
Peckman GJ
Maternal
rating of child health at school age: does the vulnerable child
syndrome persist?
Pediatrics
1993;
92:380-388
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
McCormick MC,
Shapiro S,
Starfield BH
Rehospitalization in the first
year of life for high-risk survivors.
Pediatrics
1980;
66:991-999
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
Gray J,
McCormick MC,
Richardson DK,
Ringer S
Normal birth weight
intensive care unit survivors: outcome assessment.
Pediatrics
1996;
97:832-838
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Eisen M, Ware JE Jr, Donald CA, Brook RH Measuring components of children's health status. Med Care 1979; 17:902-921 [Medline]
- McCormick MC, Workman-Daniels K, Brooks-Gunn J, Peckman GH When you're only a phone call away: a comparison of the information in telephone and face-to-face interviews. J Dev Behav Pediatr 1993; 14:250-255 [Medline]
-
National Center for Health Statistics, Department of Health and Human
Services. National Health Interview Survey
1981 Child Health
Supplement. Washington, DC: National Center for Health Statistics,
Department of Health and Human Services; 1981 -
Glascoe FP,
Dworkin PH
Role of parents in the detection of
developmental and behavioral problems.
Pediatrics
1995;
95:829-836
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Richman N, Graham P A behavioral screening questionnaire for use with three-year-old children. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 1971; 12:5-33
- Richman N, Stevenson J, Graham P Prevalence of behavior problems in 3-year-old children. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 1975; 16:277-287 [Medline]
- Stevenson J, Richman N, Graham P Behavior problems and language abilities of three years and behavioral deviance at eight years. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 1985; 26:215-230 [Medline]
- Baker PC, Keck CK, Mott Fl, Quinlan SV. NLSY Child Handbook: A Guide to the 1986-1990 National Longitudinal Survey of Youth. Columbus, OH: Center for Human Resource Research, Ohio State University; 1993:99-105
-
Brett C,
Dekle M,
Leonard CH
Developmental follow-up of
hyperventilated neonates: preliminary observations.
Pediatrics
1981;
68:588-591
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Ballard RA, Leonard CH Developmental follow-up of infants with persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn. Clin Perinatol 1984; 11:737-744 [Medline]
- Ferrara B, Johnson PE, Chang PN, Thompson TR Efficacy and neurologic outcome of profound hypocapneic alkalosis for the treatment of persistent pulmonary hypertension in infancy. J Pediatr 1984; 105:457-461 [CrossRef][Medline]
-
Sell EJ,
Jaines JA,
Gluckman C,
Williams E
Persistent fetal
circulation: neurodevelopmental outcome
. Am J Dis
Child
1985;
139:25-28
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Naulty CM, Weiss IP, Herer GR Progressive sensorineural hearing loss in survivors of persistent fetal circulation. Ear Hear 1986; 7:74-77 [Medline]
-
Andrews AF,
Nixon CA,
Cilley RE,
Rollof DW,
Bartlett RA
One- to
three-year outcome for 14 neonatal survivors of extracorporeal membrane
oxygenation.
Pediatrics
1986;
78:692-698
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
Hofkosh D,
Thompson AE,
Nozza RJ,
Kemp SS,
Bowen A,
Feldman HM
Ten
years of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation.
Pediatrics
1991;
87:549-555
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
Marron MJ,
Crisafi MA,
Driscoll JM Jr,
Hearing and
neurodevelopmental outcome in survivors of persistent pulmonary
hypertension of the newborn.
Pediatrics
1992;
90:392-396
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Glass P, Wagner AE, Papero PH, Neurodevelopmental status at age five years of neonates treated with extracorporeal membrane oxygenation. J Pediatr 1995; 127:447-457 [CrossRef][Medline]
- Vaucher YE, Dudell GG, Bejar R, Gist K Predictors in early childhood outcome in candidates for extracorporeal membrane oxygenation. J Pediatr 1996; 128:109-117 [CrossRef][Medline]
- Walton JP, Hendricks-Munoz K Profile and stability of sensorineural hearing loss in persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn. Am Speech Lang Hear Assoc 1991; 34:1362-1370
- Rosenberg AA, Kennaugh JM, Moreland SG, Longitudinal follow-up of a cohort of newborn infants treated with inhaled nitric oxide for persistent pulmonary hypertension. J Pediatr 1997; 131:70-75 [CrossRef][Medline]
-
Christou H,
Magnani B,
Morse DS,
Inhaled nitric oxide does not
affect adenosine 5'-diphosphate-dependent platelet activation in
infants with persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn.
Pediatrics
1998;
102:1390-1393
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Pediatrics (ISSN 0031 4005). Copyright ©2001 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||





