PEDIATRICS Vol. 107 No. 5 May 2001, p. e79
,
From the Divisions of * Pediatric Endocrinology and
Adult
Endocrinology, Maimonides Medical Center, Brooklyn, New York; and
§ Byrd Regional Hospital, Leesville, Louisiana.
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objectives. Bone mass increases throughout childhood, with maximal bone mass accrual rate occurring in early to mid-puberty and slowing in late puberty. Prevention of osteoporosis and its morbidities depends primarily on the establishment of adequate peak bone mass. Physical activity, calcium intake, and vitamin D stores (from sunlight conversion of precursors of vitamin D and to a lesser degree from dietary intake) are vital determinants of bone mineral density (BMD). BMD is further controlled by genetic and environmental factors that are poorly understood. Observance of ultra-Orthodox Jewish customs may have a negative effect on the factors that promote bone health, and there have been anecdotal reports of higher fracture rates in this population. The ultra-Orthodox Jewish lifestyle encourages scholarly activity in preference to physical activity. Additionally, modest dress codes and inner-city dwelling reduce sunlight exposure. Orthodox Jews do not consume milk products for 6 hours after meat ingestion, leading to potentially fewer opportunities to consume calcium. Foods from the milk group are some of the best sources of dietary calcium.Our aims are to examine BMD in a group of healthy ultra-Orthodox Jewish adolescents in an urban community and to attempt to correlate it to physical activity and dietary factors.
Design and Methods. We recruited 50 healthy, ultra-Orthodox Jews, ages 15 to 19 years (30 males and 20 females). None were taking corticosteroids or had evidence of malabsorption. All girls were postmenarchal and nulliparous. Pubic hair Tanner stage for boys and breast Tanner stage for girls were determined. Weight and height standard deviation scores were calculated. Calcium, phosphorus, protein, vitamin D, and calorie intake were assessed using a comprehensive food questionnaire referring to what has been eaten over the last year. Hours per week of weight-bearing exercise and walking were determined. Serum levels of calcium, intact parathyroid hormone (PTH), 25 hydroxyvitamin D (25[OH]D) and 1,25 dihydroxyvitamin D (1,25[OH]2D) were measured.Lumbar spine (L) BMD was assessed by dual energy radiograph absorptiometry. The pediatric software supplied by Lunar Radiation Corporation, which contains gender- and age-specific norms, provided a z score for the lumbar BMD for each participant. L2 to L4 bone mineral apparent density (BMAD) was calculated from L2 to L4 BMD.
Results. BMD of L2 to L4 was significantly decreased
compared with age/sex-matched normative data: mean z
score was
1.25 ± 1.25 (n = 50). The mean L2
to L4 BMD z score ± standard deviation was
1.71 ± 1.18 for boys and
0.58 ± 1.04 for girls. Eight
boys (27%) had L2 to L4 BMD z scores <
2.5, which
defines osteoporosis in adulthood. Twenty-seven adolescents (54%), 16 boys and 11 girls, had Tanner stage V. Two participants (4%) had
delayed development of Tanner stage V. Mean consumption of calcium by
participants under 19 years old was 908 ± 506 mg/day
(n = 46), which is lower than the adequate intake
of 1300 mg/day for this age. The consumption of phosphorus was
1329 ± 606 mg/day, and the consumption of vitamin D was 286 ± 173 IU/day (n = 50). The mean serum 25(OH)D level was 18.4 ± 7.6 ng/mL, and the mean
serum 1,25(OH)2D level was 71.1 ± 15.7 pg/mL
(n = 50). Boys had significantly higher serum
levels of 1,25(OH)2D than did girls (74.9 ± 16.46 pg/mL vs 65.25 ± 12.8 pg/mL, respectively). The serum levels of
PTH, calcium, and protein were (mean ± standard deviation):
33 ± 16 pg/mL, 9.5 ± 0.69 mg/dL, and 7.8 ± 0.6 g/dL, respectively (n = 50).L2 to L4 BMD z score had positive correlation with
walking hours (r = 0.4). L2 to L4 BMD
z score had negative correlation with serum level of
1,25(OH)2D )r =
0.33;
n = 50). We could not find significant correlation
between L2 to L4 BMD z scores for the entire cohort and
any of calcium, vitamin D, phosphorus, or protein intake. However, the
L2 to L4 BMD z scores of boys had positive correlation
with calcium, phosphorus, and protein intake (r = 42, r = 44, and r = 43, respectively). After adjustment for Tanner stage, boys who had Tanner
stage V (n = 16) had stronger positive correlation
between L2 to L4 BMD z scores and calcium and protein
intake (r = 0.55 and r = 0.57, respectively), as was the correlation between L2 to L4 BMD
z score and weight-bearing activity and walking hours
(r = 0.77 and r = 0.72, respectively; n = 16).By multiple regression analysis with stepwise selection, sex, walking
hours, weight-standard deviation scores, and serum PTH predicted 54%
of the variability in L2 to L4 BMD z score. Sex, walking
hours, and age predicted 65% of the variability in L2 to L4 BMAD.
Conclusions. Lumbar BMD is significantly decreased in ultra-Orthodox Jewish adolescents living in an urban community. Boys had profoundly lower spinal BMD than did girls. Previous studies have introduced estrogen as a critical factor in bone mineralization. However, the role of estrogen is still controversial. Our investigation of the significant determinants of BMD proved that sex is an important predictor of z score in this group, which may indicate the importance of sex hormones.Walking activity was positively associated with L2 to L4 BMD z score and was a significant predictor of L2 to L4 BMD z score and L2 to L4 BMAD. Additional studies are needed to investigate whether walking activity is lacking or is a causal factor of low BMD.The high normal levels of 1,25(OH)2D may represent a compensatory mechanism to absorb more calcium from the intestine, and the low normal 25(OH)D levels may represent relatively poor total body stores of vitamin D in this group of adolescents. This group is at great risk for the morbidities of poor bone health if no bone mineral recovery happens later in their life. We encourage additional longitudinal studies to evaluate the bone mineral status of the elder generation of this community and possible interventions that will lead to improved BMD. We recommend an increase in calcium intake to reach the adequate intake and an increase in walking activity. However, our study provides no evidence that following these recommendations will improve the BMD of this particular population. Key words: bone mineral density, ultra-Orthodox Jews, adolescents, walking.
Adolescence is the time of peak bone mass accrual. Bone
mass increases throughout childhood, with maximal bone mass accrual rate occurring in early to mid-puberty and slowing in late
puberty.1-5 Prevention of osteoporosis and its
morbidities depends largely on the establishment of adequate peak bone
mass.6 Prime determinants of bone mineral density (BMD),
in addition to sex steroids, are physical activity, calcium intake, and
vitamin D stores (from sunlight conversion of precursors to vitamin D and to a lesser degree from dietary intake).7-12 BMD is
further controlled by genetic and environmental factors that are poorly
understood.13-15
Approximately 5% to 10% of America's Jewish population is
Orthodox.16 A significant number define themselves as
ultra-Orthodox. Observance of ultra-Orthodox Jewish customs may have a
negative effect on the factors that promote bone health, and there have
been anecdotal reports of higher fracture rates in this population. The
ultra-Orthodox Jewish lifestyle encourages scholarly activity in
preference to physical activity. Additionally, modest dress codes and
inner-city dwelling reduces sunlight exposure. Orthodox Jews do not
consume milk products for 6 hours after meat ingestion, leading to
potentially fewer opportunities to consume calcium. Foods from the milk
group are some of the best sources of dietary
calcium.17-21
In general, adolescents have been reported to have less than the
recommended intake of calcium.22-24 Our aims are to
determine the BMD in a group of healthy ultra-Orthodox Jewish
adolescents and to evaluate the factors that contribute to bone mass
when in compliance with ultra-Orthodox Jewish practices.
Participants
The participants were 32 boys and 20 girls, ages 15 to 19 years,
recruited through an advertisement placed in a newspaper popular with
the ultra-Orthodox Jewish community. The recruitment of girls took
place in November and December, whereas the recruitment of boys took
place in April and May. Two boys were excluded because of having
Crohn's disease25,26 and allergy to
milk.27,28 All participants were healthy, white, and free
of any medications that may affect calcium metabolism. None reported
smoking or consuming alcohol. The girls were postmenarchal and
nulliparous. Participants and parents provided informed consent to
participate in this cross-sectional study. Institutional review board
approval was granted. Incentive amount of $100 was offered to each
participant on completion of the study.
Study Design
The study protocol for each participant was performed in 1 day.
Calcium, phosphorus, protein, vitamin D, and calorie intake were
assessed using a comprehensive food questionnaire referring to what has
been eaten over the last year. The questionnaire (K-95-1 eating survey)
was developed and analyzed by the Harvard Medical School, Channing
Laboratory (Boston, MA). The validity of the food frequency
questionnaire was previously described.29-31
Physical activity was assessed by a questionnaire developed by our
division. The participants were asked to estimate the time spent in
minutes per week in a list of weight-bearing activities, which is
defined as any exercise that loads the body with at least body weight.
The list included: jogging, roller-blading, dancing, basketball,
football, and gymnastics. A question regarding any other activity was
also included. Because walking is a daily activity, we instructed the
participants to estimate all their daily walking as minutes per day for
each day of the previous week and then to calculate the sum as minutes
per week. Walking time was considered in separate (hours/week) and was
added to the time spent in the rest of the listed activities to
calculate weight-bearing activity time (hours/week). Seasonal
differences were ruled out because all participants were evaluated
during the school year.
All participants gave their medical history and had a physical
examination. The physical examination and pubic hair Tanner stage
assessment were performed by 1 author for all of the boys. For the
girls, the physical examination and breast Tanner stage assessment were
performed by another author. The delay of Tanner stage development was
defined as >2 standard deviation (SD) delay from the mean age at which
the stage should be reached.32,33 Measurements of height
(cm) and weight (kg) were made by standardized equipment. The
participant's height in stockings was recorded to the nearest 1 cm, on
a wall-mounted stadiometer. The participant's weight was measured to
the nearest 0.5 kg, with minimal clothing. Body mass index (BMI) was
calculated as weight (kg)/height (m2). Standard
deviation scores (SDS) for height, weight, and BMI were calculated
using normative data.34 SDS is adjusted for age and sex.
Dual-energy radiograph absorptiometry was used to measure bone mineral
content. Its safety, reliability, and accuracy in the pediatric
population are well studied.35-38 Dual-energy radiograph
absorptiometry measurements were made by a scanner (DPX model, IQ 2025;
Lunar Radiation Corporation, Madison, WI) equipped with Pediatric
Software, Version 4.7 (Lunar Radiation Corporation) for lumbar
spines (Ls). BMD (g/cm2) of L2 to L4 was
assessed.
During measurement of the L, the participant was supine, and the
physiologic lumbar lordosis was flattened by elevation of the knees.
All measurements were performed and analyzed by the same person. The
pediatric software supplied by Lunar Radiation Corporation, which
contains gender- and age-specific norms, provided a z score
for the L2 to L4 BMD for each participant.
Because BMD may be influenced by bone size, we calculated bone mineral
apparent density (BMAD; g/cm3). Spine L2 to L4
BMAD was derived using the formula: L2 to L4 BMAD = bone mineral
content in grams Venous blood samples were collected and centrifuged immediately for
measurement of serum levels of calcium, intact parathyroid hormone
(PTH), total protein, 25 hydroxyvitamin D (25[OH]D), and 1,25 dihydroxyvitamin D (1,25[OH]2D). Intact PTH
levels were measured by a highly sensitive 2-site chemiluminescent
assay. Endocrine Sciences Laboratory (Calabasas Hills, CA) performed
all serum measurements.
Statistical Methods
All statistical tests were performed with SPSS, Version
9.0 (SPSS, Chicago, IL). One-sample t tests were used
to compare our participants' BMD z scores with standard
controls from the Lunar pediatric software package. Independent samples
t test was used to compare sex differences. Stepwise
multiple regression analysis was used to determine predictors of BMD.
General Characteristics
Table 1 provides a general
description of our data. Mean age for boys and girls was comparable, as
was their dietary intake of calcium, phosphorus, protein, and vitamin
D. Five boys (10%) had a BMI-SDS >2.
TABLE 1
![]()
METHODS
Top
Abstract
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
(area)1.5, as previously
described.5,39,40
![]()
RESULTS
Top
Abstract
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
Description of the Cohort, Dietary Intake, and Serum Measurements
Mean consumption of calcium by the participants under 19 years old was 908 ± 506 mg/day (n = 46), which is lower than the adequate intake of 1300 mg/day for this age.18,41 Serum calcium levels were normal, serum 25(OH)D levels were in the low normal range, and serum 1,25(OH)2D levels were in the high normal range. Boys had significantly higher serum levels of 1,25(OH)2D than did girls (P = .03).
Significantly, L2 to L4 BMD z scores for all adolescents
were reduced compared with the age- and sex-matched normative data supplied by Lunar Radiation Corporation. We ran 1-sample t
tests to perform this comparison. Mean L2 to L4 BMD z score
(± SD) was
1.25 ± 1.25 (n = 50;
P < .001). Figure 1
shows z score distribution for the entire cohort.
|
Mean L2 to L4 BMD z score for boys was
1.71 ± 1.18 (P < .001) and for girls
0.58 ± 1.04 (P < .001). Significantly, boys had lower L2 to L4 BMD
z scores than did girls (P = .001). Eight boys (27%) had L2 to L4 z scores <
2.5, which defines
osteoporosis in adulthood. Twenty-seven adolescents (54%), 16 boys and
11 girls, had Tanner stage V. One boy had Tanner stage II. Two boys had delayed development of Tanner stage V. Table
2 stratifies z scores by
Tanner stage.
|
Sixteen adolescents (32%), 11 boys and 5 girls, had a history of trauma-induced fracture. We compared mean z scores for adolescents who had trauma-induced fracture with adolescents who did not. This comparison resulted in no significant difference.
Correlations of L2 to L4 BMD z Score
Table 3 shows Pearson correlation of L2 to L4 BMD z scores. L2 to L4 BMD z score had positive correlation with walking hours. The correlation between L2 to L4 BMD z score and weight-bearing activity was close to significance.
|
We could not find correlation among L2 to L4 BMD z scores for the entire cohort and any of calcium, vitamin D, or protein intake. However, boys L2 to L4 BMD z scores had positive correlation with calcium and protein intake. Also, L2 to L4 BMD z scores for boys correlated significantly to Tanner stage (r = 0.41; P = .025).
After adjustment for Tanner stage, boys who had Tanner stage V (n = 16) had stronger positive correlation between L2 to L4 BMD z scores and calcium and protein intake, as was the correlation between L2 to L4 BMD z score and weight-bearing activity and walking hours.
Interestingly, boys at Tanner V had a positive correlation between L2 to L4 BMD z scores and vitamin D intake, which we could not find before adjustment for Tanner stage.
The entire cohort had negative correlation between serum level of
1,25(OH)2D and L2 to L4 BMD z score
(r =
0.33; P = .018).
Predictors of L2 to L4 BMD z Scores
We ran multiple regression analysis using stepwise selection
method for L2 to L4 BMD z score as the dependent variable.
The significant predictors were sex (B =
1.7; t =
5.7; P < .001), walking hours (B = 0.24;
t = 3.8; P < .001), weight-SDS (B = 0.44; t = 3.4; P = .002), serum level
of PTH (B =
0.02; t =
2.5; P = .018). These factors combined explained 54% of the variance (standard
error = 0.9; F = 12.7; P < .001).
In this model, the excluded variables were: age, height-SDS, Tanner
stage, calcium intake, protein intake, vitamin D intake, calorie
intake, phosphorus intake, serum levels of calcium, total protein,
25(OH)D, 1,25(OH)2D, and weight-bearing activity.
By the same selection and method, with L2 to L4 BMAD as the dependent
variable, sex (B =
0.04; t =
8.04;
P < .001), walking hours (B = 0.003;
t = 2.96; P = .005), and age (B = 0.005; t = 2.66; P = .01) predicted
65% of the variance (standard error = 0.016; F = 27.1; P < .001). The rest of the variables were
excluded from this model.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A primary goal of this study was to determine the BMD status of adolescents of the ultra-Orthodox Jewish community. Our results indicate that the lumbar BMD was significantly reduced in male and female adolescents of this community with 27% of boys actually having very low values. This reduction could be attributable to lifestyle factors, ie, observance of religious customs, eating habits, and studying for many hours hunched over books, although we were unsuccessful in finding significant dietary predictors by our study design. The poor BMD can also be attributable to genetic factors, which have been shown to account for 46% to 62% of the variance in a study of parents and their children.42
We took into account the regulators of bone mass.43,44 Medical histories and laboratory measurements did not point to abnormal regulation of bone in any of these adolescents. It is unclear whether the high normal levels of 1,25(OH)2D represent a compensatory mechanism to absorb more calcium from the intestine and whether the low normal 25(OH)D levels represent relatively poor total body stores of vitamin D in this group of adolescents. Although 1,25(OH)2D levels were normal by our reference laboratory values, other studies would consider these levels to represent vitamin D deficiency.45
When compared with similar bone health studies of a comparable sample and method, the mean calcium intake for our participants was similar.46 Calcium intake was excluded as a predictor of L2 to L4 BMD z score for the entire cohort; however, it was correlated to L2 to L4 BMD z score only in boys. Boot et al47 also reported that the intake of calcium is not associated with bone mineral status in girls. Welten et al48 as well excluded calcium intake as a predictor of lumbar BMD in adolescents.
Girls had higher L2 to L4 BMD z scores than did boys, who had near osteoporotic values. Previous studies have introduced estrogen as a critical factor in bone mineralization49; however, the role of estrogen is still controversial. Our investigation of the significant determinants of BMD4,7,10,50 proved that sex is an important predictor of z score in this group, which may indicate the importance of sex hormones.
Walking activity comprised a major part of their weight-bearing activity. Walking activity was positively associated with z score in boys and was a significant predictor of z score in our linear regression model. Our study singles out walking as a principal activity, which is not a surprise, because walking is primarily an outdoor activity, which, in turn, increases the chance of concomitant sunlight exposure. In contrast, our study does not prove that walking activity is lacking and it is not a causal factor of low BMD.
Our study identifies a group at great risk for the morbidities of poor bone health if no bone mineral recovery happens later in their life. We recommend an increase in calcium intake to reach the adequate intake. We also recommend an increase in weight-bearing activity, particularly walking. However, our study provides no evidence that following these recommendations will improve the BMD of this particular population. We encourage additional longitudinal studies to evaluate the bone mineral status of the elder generation of this community and possible interventions that will lead to improved BMD.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
This work was supported by grants from the Maimonides Research and Development Foundation, Genentech Inc, Eli Lilly and Company, and Pharmacia & Upjohn Co.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication Oct 12, 2000; accepted Dec 20, 2000.
This work was presented in part at the 11th International Congress of Endocrinology (ICE2000); October 31, 2000; Sydney, Australia; and at the Endocrine Society Meeting; June 12, 1999; San Diego, CA.
Reprint requests to (H.A.) Division of Endocrinology, Department of Pediatrics, Maimonides Medical Center, 977 48th St, Brooklyn, NY 11219. E-mail: hanhalt{at}maimonidesmed.org
| |
ABBREVIATIONS |
|---|
BMD, bone mineral density; SD, standard deviation; BMI, body mass index; SDS, standard deviation score; L, lumbar spine; BMAD, bone mineral apparent density; PTH, parathyroid hormone; 25(OH)D, 25 hydroxyvitamin D; 1, 25(OH)2D, 1,25 dihydroxyvitamin D.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Read all P3Rs
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||