PEDIATRICS Vol. 106 No. 4 October 2000, pp. 719-724
-Casein Fractions in Icelandic Versus Scandinavian
Cow's Milk May Influence Diabetogenicity of Cow's Milk in Infancy and
Explain Low Incidence of Insulin-Dependent Diabetes Mellitus in Iceland
,
, and
From the * Unit for Nutrition Research, National University
Hospital, Department of Food Science, and the
Department of
Pediatrics, Reykjavik Hospital, University of Iceland, Reykjavik,
Iceland; § New Zealand Dairy Research Institute, Palmerston North, New
Zealand; and
Icelandic Nutrition Council, Reykjavik, Iceland.
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objectives. To compare children with
insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) with controls in Iceland
regarding their consumption of cow's milk in infancy, and to
investigate the
-casein fractions in Scandinavian and Icelandic
cow's milk. The A1 variant of
-casein has been shown to be
diabetogenic in animal studies, and suggestions have been made that the
B variant of
-casein acts similarly. Differences in the relative
proportions of
-casein fractions might explain the lower incidence
of IDDM in Iceland than in Scandinavia.
Methods. A retrospective case-control study on IDDM
patients and matching controls was performed in Iceland to compare
their diets in infancy. Fifty-five children with IDDM born in Iceland
over a 16-year period and randomly collected controls
(n = 165) were recruited to the study. Mothers of
the children answered questions on breastfeeding habits and on when
cow's milk products were introduced. Samples of cow's milk from
randomly selected milk batches from the largest consumption areas in
Iceland and Scandinavia were collected. The milk samples were
freeze-dried and their
-casein fractions were analyzed using
capillary electrophoresis.
Results. No significant difference was found between IDDM
patients and controls in the frequency and duration of breastfeeding or
the first introduction of cow's milk products. The analyses of milk samples showed that the percentage of the A1 and B variants of
-casein in Icelandic milk was significantly lower than in the milk
from the Scandinavian countries.
Conclusions. Cow's milk consumption in infancy is not
related to IDDM in Iceland. The lower fraction of A1 and B
-caseins
in Icelandic cow's milk may explain why there is a lower incidence of
IDDM in Iceland than in Scandinavia.
Key words:
insulin-dependent
diabetes mellitus,
cow,
caseins,
milk proteins,
breastfeeding,
primary
prevention,
diabetes,
infants.
The incidence of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM)
in Iceland is less than one half the IDDM incidence in the other Nordic
countries, ie, Scandinavia (Norway, Denmark, Sweden, and Finland),
despite a similar genetic background.1-6 This difference
cannot be explained by different breastfeeding habits because the
duration of breastfeeding is similar and high in all these
countries.7 However, studies from Europe and the United
States have shown a relationship between short duration of
breastfeeding and a higher incidence of IDDM.8,9 The
consumption of dairy products in infancy has also repeatedly been
related to IDDM,10,11 although not all studies have found
this relationship.12 This discrepancy indicates variations
in diabetogenicity of cow's milk. However, a meta-analysis has
pinpointed exposure to cow's milk as an important determinant of
IDDM,13 and in 1994 the American Academy of Pediatrics
found reason to strongly recommend breastfeeding. They also recommended
that families with a strong history of IDDM should avoid products
containing intact cow's milk protein during the first year of
life.14
Recently a cow's milk Genetic research on the Icelandic and Scandinavian cattle breeds
indicates that genes coding for A1 and B The aims of this current study was to compare Icelandic infants who
later became diabetic and healthy controls with regard to breastfeeding
habits and consumption of cow's milk, and to determine the fractions
of the A1, A2, and B Subjects
Fifty-five children with IDDM in Iceland, born during a 16-year
period, were included in the study. For each patient the Statistical Bureau of Iceland chose 3 children randomly of the same gender and with
the same date of birth as a control group. At the time of this study
the children were between 3 and 19 years old, the average age being
12.5 years. The Icelandic Data Protection Commission approved the
study. The subjects and their parents gave informed consent for
participation.
Design of Infant Diet Study
A retrospective case-control method was used in which a letter
introducing the study was sent to mothers of all the children, followed
by a telephone interview. The questions asked the mothers whether and
how long they breastfed their children and when the children received a
cow's milk product for the first time. It is known that mothers are
very precise in remembering the feeding of their children during the
first months of life, especially regarding
breastfeeding.25 Telephone surveys on food habits have
proven to be a good method to obtain dietary
information.26
Milk Sample Collection
A total of 15 different batches or consumer packages of whole
consumer cow's milk were randomly collected from the largest consumption areas in Iceland (6 batches) and Scandinavia (9 batches), ie, Denmark (2 batches), Norway (2 batches), Sweden (3 batches), and
Finland (2 batches). Milk batches were collected in 9 different areas
within the countries surveyed; 3 in Iceland and 6 in Scandinavia. For 3 areas in Iceland and 3 areas in Scandinavia, samples were collected
both in autumn and spring, with a 7-month interval between collections.
To ensure that the proteins were not degraded before analysis, all
samples were kept chilled before freezing. The samples were then
freeze-dried, coded, and sent to New Zealand where they were analyzed
blind.
Milk Sample Analysis
The content of A1, A2, and B Statistical Analysis
The results from the case-control study were compared using the
No significant difference was found between infants later
developing IDDM and controls in exclusive breastfeeding or cow's milk
consumption (P > .1). The frequency and duration of
breastfeeding were similar in both groups (P > .1).
Figure 1 shows the percentage of both
groups of infants getting cow's milk at 1 to 6 months of age. There
was no connection between the age of the child at the time of the study
and the mother's memory regarding how long she breastfed her child,
and when the child got cow's milk product for the first time. The
mothers seemed to remember this very well.
-casein fraction, A1, has been found to be
diabetogenic in animal research, whereas the
-casein fraction A2 has
not.15 These are the dominant variants of
-casein in
milk from most cattle breeds.15 Thus, it is possible that
variations in
-casein fractions could contribute to the apparent
lack of agreement among studies on the diabetogenicity of cow's milk.
Earlier,
-casein, which is one of the primary proteins in cow's
milk, was found to be diabetogenic in experimental animals (nonobese
diabetic [NOD] mice),16 but hydrolyzed cow's milk
proteins showed a highly protective effect against
diabetes.17,18 Increased lymphocyte response to
-casein
was also found in patients with recent onset of IDDM, compared with
nondiabetic healthy subjects and patients with other autoimmune
diseases.19 Another study showed higher antibody levels
against A1
-casein in diabetic patients than in healthy
controls.20 A less frequent
-casein variant, B
-casein, has been suggested to act in a similar way as A1. A1 and B
-caseins both have histidine at position 67 in the primary sequence
of this protein, but A2
-casein has proline at this
position.15,21 The amino acid sequence of A1 and B
-caseins causes a cleavage pattern by intestinal digestive enzymes
that produces
-casomorphin-7 (BCM), suggested to be
diabetogenic.15,21
-caseins are less frequent
in Icelandic cattle than in the predominant cattle breeds in
Scandinavia.22 Icelandic cattle have been isolated for
1100 years,22 while cattle breeding has been performed
within and between the Scandinavian countries.23 In
addition, in Scandinavia dairy cattle have also been imported from
other countries.23 Very recently a significant correlation
was found between the calculated per capita consumption of A1 and B
-casein and the incidence of IDDM in 10 countries, including Iceland
and the 4 Scandinavian countries.24 The consumption of
dairy products in infancy and its relation to IDDM in Iceland have not
been investigated. Also, the actual content of
-casein variants in
the milk supply in Scandinavia has not been analyzed.
-casein variants in Icelandic and Scandinavian
cow's milk.
![]()
METHODS
Top
Abstract
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
-casein variants were determined
in samples from randomly collected batches of consumers cow's milk.
Method of analysis was capillary electrophoresis, described by Recio et
al27 with modifications. Freeze-dried samples were
reconstituted to 130 mg/mL with water and mixed for 3 hours. Exactly .5 mL of reconstituted sample was added to 2.5 mL of sample buffer (pH
8.6) containing 6 mol/L urea, 42 mmol/L 4-morpholinepropanesulfonic
acid, .05% methyl cellulose, and 167 mM
Tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane.
-Mercaptoethanol (30 µL) was
added to the sample and left for 1 hour at room temperature before
filtering (.45 µm). Capillary electrophoresis runs were performed on
an Applied Biosystems 270A-HT system (Applied Biosystems Inc, San Jose,
CA) with a hydrophilic coated capillary of 57 cm × 50 µm
(Supelco, Bellefonte, PA). Approximately 10 nL of sample was injected
onto the capillary. The running buffer contained 6 M urea, 20 mM sodium
citrate, .32 mM citric acid, and .05% methyl cellulose at pH 3.0. The
content of A1, A2, and B
-casein variants were given as relative
proportions, ie, fractions.
2 test. The results from the analyses of
Icelandic milk batches versus Scandinavian milk batches are described
using mean, range, and standard error (SE). The Mann-Whitney
U test was used to test the difference between the results
of analyses of milk samples from Iceland and Scandinavia. All
statistical analysis was performed with the SPSS statistical program
(SPSS, Chicago, IL). P < .05 was regarded as
statistically significant.
![]()
RESULTS
Top
Abstract
Methods
Results
Discussion
References

View larger version (37K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 1.
Percentage of infants consuming cow's milk and cow's milk products,
children who later became diabetic (light shading), compared with
controls (dark shading).
The results from analyses of
-casein variants in cow's milk from
the largest consumption areas in Iceland and Scandinavia are shown in
Table 1. A1
-casein and the sum of A1
and B are shown as the mean and range of analyzed batches from Iceland (6 batches) and Scandinavia (9 batches) as well as from each country of
Scandinavia, ie, Denmark (2 batches), Norway (2 batches), Sweden (3 batches), and Finland (2 batches). All the Icelandic milk samples that
were analyzed had a lower fraction of A1
-casein and a lower fraction of the sum of A1 and B
-caseins than did milk samples from
Scandinavia. Table 1 also shows earlier published values, based on
either chemical analyses or estimations from genetic
research.24 As seen in the table, the earlier published
values showed a greater discrepancy between Iceland and Scandinavia,
both for A1
-casein and for the sum of A1 and B
-caseins. The
fraction of the B
-casein variant in the milk from all countries in
this current study was higher compared with the earlier published
values. Figure 2 shows that the
-casein fractions A1, the sum of A1 and B, and A2 in milk, collected
in 6 different areas with a 7-month interval, were fairly constant for
both seasons.
|
|
Figure 3 shows the fractions of A1 and B
-casein variants in Icelandic and Scandinavian milk samples analyzed
in this study. The fraction of A1
-casein in Icelandic milk was 35.6 ± .7 (mean ± SE), which is significantly lower than
the fraction of this milk protein variant in Scandinavian milk, ie,
42.2 ± .6 (P < .02). This was also the case for
the sum of A1 and B
-caseins, both with histidine in
position 67 in the primary protein sequence, which was
38.4 ± .8 (mean ± SE) for the Icelandic milk and 48.7 ± 1.3 for the Scandinavian milk (P < .02).
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Breastfeeding and cow's milk consumption in infancy were similar among the IDDM patients and controls, which is in accordance with some previous studies.12 However, other studies have found a shorter duration of breastfeeding or an earlier consumption of cow's milk in infancy among IDDM patients than among controls,8-11,13 suggesting a causative relationship between cow's milk consumption and IDDM. This relationship seems, therefore, to exist in some countries and not in others, indicating that the cow's milk itself might contain different amounts of diabetogenic factors in different countries.
Animal studies show that A1
-casein is diabetogenic,15
and suggestions have been made on a similar effect from B
-casein.15,24 The analysis of cow's milk in the
present study showed a significantly lower fraction of A1 and the sum
of A1 and B
-caseins in Icelandic milk than in milk from
Scandinavia. This may explain the lower incidence of IDDM in Iceland
than in Scandinavia. The mechanism behind the putative diabetogenicity
of A1 and B
-caseins is not fully known. The peptide BCM, produced
in digestion of A1 and B
-caseins, behaves like an opioid receptor
ligand and is absorbed through the gastrointestinal
mucosa.28 BCM has been shown to be inhibitory to immune
cell function in NOD mice and prediabetic humans but not in Swiss mice
or normal humans.15 A sequence homology between
-casein
and several
-cell molecules has also been suggested as an immune
response trigger.19
In the present study the lower fraction of A1
-casein and the sum of
A1 and B
-caseins found in consumers cow's milk from Iceland versus
that from Scandinavia are in accordance with results from genetic
studies on cattle breeds.22 The current results also
support recently published values by Elliott et al24 who
found an even larger difference between the values for Icelandic and
Scandinavian milk by chemical analysis or estimation from genetic
research. The milk samples taken from the same areas within a 7-month
interval in the present study had a relatively constant
-casein
variant composition. However, it is likely that over relatively long
periods, or decades, cattle breeding programs will have resulted in
some variation in
-casein fractions.23
For the development of IDDM, the timing, dosage, and duration of the exposure to cow's milk could be important,29 and some studies suggest that exposure during infancy may be important.14 A possible explanation of the significance of early introduction could be that an infant's intestines can absorb larger protein fragments from food than can the intestines of children and adults. Infants given hydrolyzed formula had depressed cellular and humoral responsiveness to cow's milk proteins, compared with a control group.30 An international, double-blind study is currently in progress in which infants at high risk for IDDM are given hydrolyzed infant formula for the first 6 months of life to avoid intact dietary protein.31 Scientists have suggested that continuous exposure is needed for those genetically susceptible to progress to IDDM, and results from animal studies show that food can have a diabetogenic effect through puberty.29 However, it should be kept in mind that most IDDM patients are diagnosed before adulthood, and the consumption in childhood, therefore, seems of greatest importance.
Dahl-Jörgensen and coworkers32 found a strong
correlation between total cow milk consumption per capita and the
incidence of IDDM in 12 countries, including the 4 Scandinavian
countries, Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and Finland. A similar relationship
was found for 9 regions in Italy.33 This obviously
contradicts the Icelandic situation because the cow's milk consumption
per capita in Iceland is one of the highest in the world, whereas the
incidence of IDDM is low.34 However, the recent paper by
Elliott et al24 found a strong correlation between the per
capita consumption of A1 and B
-caseins and the incidence of IDDM in
10 countries, including Iceland and the 4 Scandinavian countries.
In this context it is important to evaluate the total exposure to milk,
or especially to
-casein A1 and B, among infants and children. The
high per capita consumption of cow's milk in Iceland is similarly
found in the youngest population, while the consumption of formula is
lower than in the other Scandinavian countries.35-39 In
childhood the consumption of cow's milk is similar in Iceland and in
the 4 Scandinavian countries.40-44 The total exposure to
cow's milk in young age is, therefore, not less in Iceland than in
Scandinavia, but the total exposure to
-caseins A1 and B seems
lower. This has to be verified with calculations adding exact
information from chemical analysis on
-caseins A1 and B in formulas.
Genetically predisposed people can develop IDDM, but the majority of those with the so-called high-risk genes do not.14 Nations that are genetically similar but have very different incidences of IDDM support the hypothesis that environmental factors are contributing to the risk of IDDM. The Icelandic population has the same genetic origin as the nations of Scandinavia.6 However, studies have shown that the Finnish nation has a special genetic susceptibility to IDDM.45,46 No major differences in human leukocyte antigen allelic distribution between Icelandic and Norwegian diabetic patients can be found,47 but the incidence of IDDM in Norway is approximately twice as high as in Iceland.1,2
Today IDDM is the second most common chronic childhood
disease.48 Very recently it has been reported that the
incidence of IDDM in Finland in 1996 was 44.8 per 100 000 for 0- to
14-year-old children.5 The incidence is especially
increasing among young children 1 to 4 years old. The incidence is also
increasing in the other countries used for comparison with Iceland in
the present study, ie, Denmark, Norway, and Sweden. All of these
nations are related to the Icelandic nation, which has a much lower and
more stable incidence of IDDM. The importance of explaining this
difference is large. The fact that IDDM is one of the fastest growing
diseases in the world has drawn attention to the importance of
identifying possible environmental triggers.48 Whether
there is a single trigger or whether multiple environmental insults
accumulate to cause the destruction of the
-cells is not
known.14 To focus solely on breastfeeding and early
exposure to cow's milk is most likely an
oversimplification,29 but other factors thought to be
connected to IDDM48 are similar in Iceland and the
Scandinavian countries, such as the prevalence of infections among
small children, consumption of nitrates, and insecticides, as well as
the per capita consumption of coffee and tea.49-52 Even
more factors could be mentioned. Substantial evidence indicates that
cow's milk is important for the development of IDDM and that variability in the casein composition of cow's milk could, in part,
explain varying results from the studies on the relationship between
IDDM and cow's milk consumption.
Cow's milk consumption in infancy has no relation to IDDM in Iceland.
The fraction of A1 and B
-caseins in Icelandic cow's milk is
significantly lower than in Scandinavian cow's milk, which may explain
the lower incidence of IDDM in Iceland than in Scandinavia.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We thank Olafur Reykdal for his assistance in preparing the milk samples for analysis; Carmen Norris for assistance with capillary electrophoresis; and Dr Mike Boland for his advice during the preparation of the manuscript.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication Sep 20, 1999; accepted Feb 11, 2000.
Reprint requests to (I.T.) Unit for Nutrition Research, National University Hospital, IS-101, Reykjavik, Iceland. E-mail: ingathor{at}rsp.is
| |
ABBREVIATIONS |
|---|
IDDM, insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus;
NOD, nonobese diabetic;
BCM,
-casomorphin-7;
SE, standard error.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-casein in the induction of insulin-dependent diabetes in the non-obese diabetic mouse and humans. In: Seminar on Milk Protein Polymorphism: IDF Special Issue 9702. Brussels, Belgium: International Dairy Federation; 1997:445-453
-casein in recent-onset insulin-dependent diabetes: implications for disease pathogenesis.
Lancet
1996;
348:926-928 [CrossRef][Medline]This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. M Virtanen and M. Knip Nutritional risk predictors of {beta} cell autoimmunity and type 1 diabetes at a young age Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, December 1, 2003; 78(6): 1053 - 1067. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
I. Thorsdottir, J. E. Torfadottir, B. E. Birgisdottir, and R. T. Geirsson Weight Gain in Women of Normal Weight Before Pregnancy: Complications in Pregnancy or Delivery and Birth Outcome Obstet. Gynecol., May 1, 2002; 99(5): 799 - 806. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||