PEDIATRICS Vol. 100 No. 2 August 1997,
p. e4
Copyright ©1997 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
ELECTRONIC ARTICLE:
Outcome of Small-for-Gestational Age and
Appropriate-for-Gestational Age Infants Born Before 27 Weeks of
Gestation
Claudette Bardin*,
Phyllis Zelkowitz
, and
Apostolos Papageorgiou*
From the * Department of Neonatology and the
Department of
Psychiatry, Sir Mortimer B. Davis Jewish General Hospital: McGill
University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
MATERIALS AND METHODS
RESULTS
DISCUSSION
ABBREVIATIONS
REFERENCES
ABSTRACT
Objective. To evaluate the consequences
of being small-for-gestational age at extremely low gestational age.
Methodology. Comparison of two historical cohorts of
small-for-gestational age (SGA) and appropriate-for-gestational age
(AGA) infants born between 24 and 26 6/7 weeks of gestation
(gestational age estimated by early ultrasound at 16 to 18 weeks). Data
were collected retrospectively on 191 successive admissions to the neonatal intensive care unit between January 1, 1983, and December 31, 1992. These included: demographic and maternal information, delivery
mode and condition at birth, mortality, neonatal intensive care unit
morbidities (respiratory distress syndrome, intraventricular hemorrhage, patent ductus arteriosis [PDA], chronic lung disease [CLD], retinopathy of prematurity [ROP], necrotizing enterocolitis, infection), nutrition, and length of hospitalization.
Results. Forty-one (21%) of the 191 infants were
classified as SGA. Those with congenital anomalies (10% in the SGA and
2% in the AGA group) were excluded from further analysis. Despite a
similar rate of respiratory distress syndrome (50%), the SGA infants
had a greater rate of failure of indomethacin treatment for PDA closure
(54% vs 32% for AGA), a higher risk for CLD defined as a need for
supplementary oxygen at 36 weeks (65% vs 32% for AGA), a more
prolonged need for oxygen supplementation and ventilatory support (94 days vs 68 days for AGA and 58 days vs 40 days for AGA, respectively).
SGA infants were also at greater risk for developing severe ROP (stage
III) (65% vs 12% for AGA).
Conclusions. For infants born before 27 weeks, being
small-for-gestational age confers additional risks for severe
morbidity, ie, PDA ligation, CLD, and ROP.
Key words:
extreme
prematurity,
small for gestational age,
mortality,
morbidity.
INTRODUCTION
Small-for-gestational age (SGA) infants represent a
significant percentage of infants admitted to neonatal intensive care units (NICU). There is abundant literature on the neonatal course and
long-term outcome of SGA infants born at or near
term.1 For those born prematurely, comparisons
between SGA and appropriate-for-gestational age (AGA) infants have
generally shown that SGA infants have fewer respiratory difficulties in
the neonatal period than AGA infants.6 However, these
conclusions were drawn when the birth weight rather than the
gestational age served as the basis for comparison.9,10 The
limited number of studies comparing premature AGA and SGA infants of
similar gestational age have shown inconclusive
outcomes.11 Furthermore, there is a paucity of
information regarding the outcome of infants born at extremely low
gestational age (ELGA).
The present study addresses the issue of outcome of SGA infants born
between 24 and 26 6/7 weeks of gestation, an age group which was very
difficult to study earlier. Nowadays, with the routine use of
ultrasound between 16 and 20 weeks of gestation in the province of
Quebec, it is possible to accurately date a pregnancy. Furthermore, the
survival rate of infants of extremely low birth weight (ELBW) and ELGA
has increased in the last decade. This permits the evaluation of the
impact of early intrauterine growth retardation on the outcome of
infants born before 27 weeks of gestation.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Patient Population
The 191 infants enrolled in the study were born at the Sir
Mortimer B. Davis Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, between January 1, 1983 and December 31, 1992. Their gestational age, calculated by
ultrasonography performed between 16 and 20 weeks of gestation and LMP,
ranged from 24 to 26 6/7 weeks. If there was a discrepancy greater than
1 week between last menstrual (LMP) and ultrasound dating, the
gestational age determined by ultrasound was taken as reference. An
infant was classified as SGA if the birth weight was at or below the
third percentile, using the Usher and McLean grids of intrauterine
growth, constructed from patients born in the province of
Quebec15 and extrapolated to 24 weeks.
Forty-one infants were classified as SGA and 150 as AGA. Four infants
in the SGA group and three in the AGA group had lethal congenital
anomalies (P = .05) and were thus excluded from
further analysis.
Outcome Variables
The following clinical conditions were evaluated:
- Early neonatal course describes the infant's condition upon
admission to the NICU.
- Respiratory distress syndrome (RDS): The diagnosis of RDS was
made on the basis of clinical and radiologic criteria. Surfactant replacement therapy became available in our NICU in 1990 and has been
used early in the treatment of infants with RDS in respiratory failure.
- Intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH): Ultrasonographic evaluation
of the ventricular system was routinely done in the first week of life
and repeated 1 week later. If pathology was present, ongoing evaluation
would proceed on a weekly basis. The ultrasounds were evaluated by the
same ultrasonographer who was unaware of the SGA/AGA status of the
infant. IVH was reported according to Papile's classification.16
- Periventricular leukomalacia: A head ultrasound was done
between 36 and 40 weeks of gestation for the diagnosis of
periventricular leukomalacia.
- Patent ductus arteriosis (PDA): PDA was diagnosed clinically
and by echocardiography. In the absence of contraindications (active
bleeding or renal failure), indomethacin was the treatment of choice
for ductuses with clinical signs of failure. Two to three courses of
indomethacin were attempted before surgery was considered.
- Sepsis: Infection was diagnosed either by a positive blood
culture or an abnormal white blood cell count and differential in the
presence of obvious clinical signs of infection. Infections were
classified as early (occurring during the first week of life) or late.
- Chronic lung disease (CLD): CLD was defined as an oxygen need
beyond 36 weeks of gestation.
- Retinopathy of prematurity (ROP): Each infant's retina was
assessed by an ophthalmologist 4 to 6 weeks after admission to the NICU
with repeat examinations until maturity of the retina. The diagnosis
and staging of ROP was done according to the International Classification.17
- Time of discharge: Infants were discharged home when they
reached a weight of 2200 g and were free of medical problems.
Statistical Analysis
The data were analyzed by the SPSS statistical program. Between
group differences on categorical variables were analyzed with
2 statistics or Fisher's exact test if cell sizes
were less than 5. Student's t test was used to compare the
groups on continuous variables. A P value of <.05 was
considered significant.
RESULTS
Perinatal Outcome
Pregnancy complications, mode of delivery, and the infant's
condition at birth are described in Table 1. Except for
an increased incidence of preeclampsia in the mothers of SGA infants,
all other parameters were similar in the two groups. The percentages of SGA and AGA infants born after prolonged rupture of membranes (greater
than 24 hours) were comparable (40% and 30%, respectively). At birth,
more SGA infants were depressed as indicated by the greater percentage
of SGA infants with an Apgar score of
5 at 5 minutes (32% vs 19%)
(P = .05). The distribution of SGA and AGA
infants by gestational age was as follows: at 24 weeks, 19 SGA and 42 AGA; at 25 weeks, 11 SGA and 50 AGA; and at 26 weeks, 7 SGA and 55 AGA.
The distribution of infants according to gender was similar.
Early Neonatal Course
Table 2 presents data on neonatal morbidity after
admission to the NICU. The incidence of RDS was similar in the two
groups (50%). Surfactant replacement therapy was given to 12% of SGA and 14% of AGA infants. The incidence of IVH of any grade was 22% for
SGA and 30% for AGA infants. There was a trend for severe IVH (grade
III or IV) to occur more frequently among the AGA infants (23% vs
12%).
The need for ventilatory assistance was similar in the two groups, but
the reasons for intubation differed. Among the SGA infants, 27% were
intubated for RDS, 30% for depression, and 42% for immaturity. Among
the AGA infants, 27% were intubated for RDS, 14% for depression, 41%
for immaturity, 11% for intractable apnea, and 7% for other causes.
All 33 SGA infants who required ventilatory support were intubated
within the first 3 hours of age (32/33 by 1 hour of age), compared with
85% of the AGA infants (P = .02). The incidence
of air leaks was 24% for the SGA and 21% for the AGA infants. All the
SGA infants required oxygen supplementation at some time during their
hospitalization, compared with 90% of the AGA infants
(P = .05).
Mortality
Mortality to discharge home was somewhat higher for the SGA group,
although not statistically significant (46% vs 35%). The mean birth
weight and gestational age of the 17 deceased SGA infants were 556 g and 25.4 weeks, and for the 52 AGA infants, 773 g and 25.3 weeks. The causes of death were not different for SGA and AGA infants
(Table 3). Causes other than respiratory or infectious included intractable hyperkalemia, massive IVH, and renal failure. The
median age at death was 7 days for the SGA and 2.5 days for the AGA
infants.
Neonatal Complications Among the Survivors
The outcome of the surviving infants (20 SGA, 95 AGA) is described
in Tables 4 and 5. Although the incidence
of RDS and need for oxygen were similar in AGA and SGA infants,
appropriate oxygenation and ventilation were achieved with
significantly higher peak inspiratory pressure at 48 and 72 hours for
the SGA infants (Table 5). A clinically significant PDA was diagnosed
more frequently in the SGA group. Indomethacin treatment was
unsuccessful in 7/13 (54%) SGA infants and 14/44 (32%); these infants
subsequently required surgical ligation of the ductus arteriosus.
Infection was suspected or confirmed more frequently in SGA infants,
especially during the first week of life. The number of positive blood
cultures was 2 (10%) for SGA and 2 (2%) for AGA infants during the
first week of life, and 7 (38%) for SGA and 11 (12%) for AGA infants after 7 days of life.
With reference to long term neonatal outcome, SGA infants required an
average of 58 days of mechanical ventilation and 94 days of oxygen
supplementation compared with 40 days and 68 days, respectively, for
the AGA infants (P < .01). At 28 days of life, 100% of the SGA and 83% of the AGA infants were oxygen-dependent (P < .05), and at 36 weeks of gestation 65% of
SGA and 32% of AGA still required oxygen supplementation
(P < .01). Retinal changes were present in 90%
of SGA infants and in 58% of AGA (P < .01) and
severe ROP (stage III or IV) occurred in 65% of the SGA infants versus
12% of the AGA infants (P < .01). Two of the
20 SGA infants and 5 of the 95 AGA infants are now considered legally
blind. Even though the incidence of necrotizing enterocolitis was not significantly different between the two groups, the SGA infants had
more difficulties with enteral feedings. Achieving full enteral feeding
took 64 days for the SGA infants versus 50 days for the AGA infants
(P < .01). That the neonatal course of the SGA
infants was more complicated is reflected by the fact that their median hospital stay was 20 days longer than that of the AGA infants (115 days
for SGA vs 95 day for AGA, P < .01).
DISCUSSION
The prognosis of SGA infants with chromosomal anomalies, genetic
syndromes, or congenital infections is relatively predictable. However,
for the others, the outcome is much less certain. Furthermore, very
little information is available concerning SGA infants who are born
extremely premature. In view of the increasing survival of ELBW
infants, a better knowledge of the consequences of the combination of
severe prematurity and intrauterine growth retardation becomes
imperative for proper parental counseling and decision making.
Published data comparing premature SGA and AGA infants of similar
gestational age indicate serious discrepancies in their findings. Sung
et al12 compared 27 SGA to 27 AGA infants with a mean
gestational age of 29 weeks. There were no differences in neonatal
morbidities between the two groups of infants. In Pena et al's
report,13 there were no differences in the incidence of
RDS, apnea, necrotizing enterocolitis, or need for ventilatory assistance but there was a decreased incidence of IVH and an
increased duration of ventilation and number of days of
hospitalization for SGA infants at a mean gestational age of 30.8 weeks. Morley et al18 and Thompson et al have found an
increased need for ventilation for SGA infants of 30 to 31 weeks
gestational age. In Thompson's study,10 this need was
secondary to an increased incidence of RDS among the SGA infants. On
the other hand, Robertson11 described a decreased need for
assisted ventilation among 36 SGA infants of mean gestational age 33.5 weeks compared with 36 AGA infants of similar gestational age, but no
increased length of hospitalization or increased incidence of CLD.
Tyson et al9 reported an increased risk of RDS and
respiratory failure in SGA infants born between 27 and 38 weeks
compared with AGA infants. In terms of mortality,
Thompson10 found greater mortality (19% vs 11%) in SGA
infants of mean gestational age of 30 weeks attributable to an
increased incidence of sepsis. In a study by Teberg et al,3 none of the seven SGA infants of less than 26 weeks gestation survived,
compared with 18% survival in AGA infants. Similarly, Chen et
al,19 comparing AGA and SGA twins from 23 to 34 weeks, found an increased risk of death and sepsis among the smaller twin. All
these studies clearly underline the important role that gestational age
plays in the prognosis for SGA infants.
Our study of ELGA infants confirms the previous reports of increased
incidence of congenital anomalies among SGA infants.20 After exclusion of infants with congenital anomalies, the mortality remained higher in SGA infants; 46% vs 35% in AGA. SGA infants were
more depressed at birth, as indicated by the lower 5-minute Apgar score
and the need for more aggressive resuscitation. This is in agreement
with the findings of Williams21 and Wilcox,22 who demonstrated increased mortality as birth weight decreases at any
specific gestational age.
During their hospitalization, all SGA infants required oxygen
supplementation and most of them needed early assisted ventilation attributable to neonatal depression in one-third of the cases. Despite
the high incidence of early neonatal problems (need for resuscitation,
PDA, more severe lung disease), we observed a trend for a lower
incidence of severe IVH in the SGA group (12% vs 23%), in accordance
with the findings of Pena et al.13 One may speculate that
chronic hypoxic state in utero alters the levels and balance of
prostanoids, leading to wider autoregulatory range and a better protection of cerebral blood flow.23 The higher failure
rate of indomethacin therapy for the closure of the PDA among SGA
infants may also be related to altered levels of prostaglandins or
altered number or sensitivity of their receptors.24
Although the incidence of RDS and the need for exogenous surfactant
were similar in SGA and AGA infants, the initial pulmonary disease was
more severe for the SGA infants as demonstrated by the need for more
aggressive ventilatory support in the first days of life. Many factors
may be responsible for this difference: remodeling of the pulmonary
vasculature attributable to chronic intrauterine hypoxia, which in turn
can predispose to pulmonary hypertension. Depression at birth can add
additional hypoxic injury to the lung. Finally, smaller muscle mass can
lead to fatigue and respiratory failure. The SGA infants also
demonstrated a much higher incidence of CLD, with 65% of them
requiring oxygen supplementation at 36 weeks postconception. Although
the etiology of CLD is multifactorial, some factors such as more severe
early lung disease and persistence of PDA requiring higher oxygen
concentration and more ventilatory support are to be emphasized.
Furthermore, chronic malnutrition can aggravate the deficiency in
antioxidants already present in low concentration in premature
infants.25
In our ELGA population, the incidence of infection was greater in the
SGA group. Tolerance of enteral feeding, already a problem in ELBW
infants, was significantly aggravated by intrauterine growth
retardation. Indeed, full enteral nutrition was achieved on the average
after 64 days in SGA infants versus 50 days in AGA infants.
The increased incidence of severe ROP in SGA infants in comparison to
AGA infants is a new observation which has significant implications in
terms of ophthalmologic intervention, parental counseling and potential
medico-legal issues. As to the reasons for this increased risk for ROP
among SGA infants of ELBW, one can speculate that it could be a
combination of many factors, such as chronic intrauterine hypoxia,
altered levels of prostanoids, growth factors, and endothelins, and
antioxidant deficiency.
Finally, the length of stay in hospital for SGA infants of ELGA was
substantially longer than for AGA infants. This is not a
surprising finding in view of the complexity and severity of their
medical problems.
In conclusion, our data indicate that intrauterine growth retardation
in extremely premature infants is associated with higher mortality.
Moreover, the risk of CLD and ROP is much higher in SGA than in AGA
infants. Parental counseling before delivery is based mostly on the
gestational age of the pregnancy. Thus, after the birth of an SGA, ELGA
infant, counseling and treatment must reflect the increased
difficulties potentially faced by these infants. Furthermore, because
of the seriousness of the early problems and the impact that these may
have on their future health, long term outcome in SGA, ELBW infants
needs to be carefully evaluated.
FOOTNOTES
Received for publication Dec 16, 1996; accepted Feb 24, 1997.
Presented in part at the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric
Research, Seattle, Washington, May, 1994.
Reprint requests to (C.B.) The SMBD-Jewish General Hospital,
3755 Cote St Catherine Road, Room A-209, Montreal, Quebec H3T 1E2,
Canada.
ABBREVIATIONS
SGA, small-for-gestational age.
NICU, neonatal
intensive care unit.
AGA, appropriate-for-gestational age.
ELGA, extremely low gestational age.
ELBW, extremely low birth weight.
LMP, last menstrual period.
RDS, respiratory distress syndrome.
IVH, intraventricular hemorrhage.
PDA, patent ductus arteriosus.
CLD, chronic lung disease.
ROP, retinopathy of prematurity.
REFERENCES
-
Allen MC
Developmental outcome and follow-up of the small for
gestational infant.
Semin Perinatol
1984;
8:123-156[Medline]
-
Villar J,
de Onis M,
Kestler E,
Bolanos F,
Cerezo R,
Bernedez H
The
differential neonatal morbidity of the intrauterine growth retardation
syndrome.
Am J Obstet Gynecol
1990;
163:151-157[Medline]
-
Teberg AJ,
Walther FJ,
Pena IC
Mortality, morbidity, and outcome of
the small for gestational infant.
Semin Perinatol
1988;
12:84-94[Medline]
-
Kramer MS,
Olivier M,
McLean FH,
Willis DM,
Usher RH
Impact of
intrauterine growth retardation and body proportionality on fetal and
neonatal outcome.
Pediatrics
1990;
85:707-713
-
Ott WJ
Small for gestational age fetus and neonatal outcome:
reevaluation of the relationship.
Am J Perinatol
1995;
12:396-400[Medline]
-
Gluck L,
Kulovich MV
Lecithin/sphingomyelin ratios in amniotic fluid
in normal and abnormal pregnancy.
Am J Obstet Gynecol
1973;
115:539-546[Medline]
-
Procianoy RS,
Garcia-Prats JA,
Adams JM,
Silvers A,
Rudolph AJ
Hyaline
membrane disease and intraventricular hemorrhage in
small-for-gestational-age infants.
Arch Dis Child
1980;
55:502-505[Abstract]
-
Yamaguchi K,
Hara H,
Nishida H,
Clinical study on intrauterine
growth retardation. Part 1-Outcome for small-for-gestational-age
infants with very low birth weight (<1500 g).
Acta Paediatr
Jpn
1987;
29:742-748[Medline]
-
Tyson JE,
Kennedy K,
Broyles S,
Rosenfeld CR
The small for gestational
age infant: accelerated or delayed pulmonary maturation? Increased or
decreased survival?
Pediatrics
1995;
95:534-538[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Thompson PJ,
Greenough A,
Gamsu HR,
Nicolaides KH
Ventilatory
requirements for respiratory distress syndrome in
small-for-gestational-age infants.
Eur J Pediatr
1992;
151:528-531[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Robertson CMT,
Etches PC,
Kyle JM
Eight-year school performance and
growth of preterm, small for gestational age infants: a comparative
study with subjects matched for birth weight or for gestational age.
J Pediatr
1990;
116:19-26[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Sung IK,
Vohr B,
Oh W
Growth and developmental outcome of very low
birth weight infants with intrauterine growth retardation: comparison
with control subjects matched by birthweight and gestational age.
J Pediatr
1993;
123:618-624[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Pena IC,
Teberg AJ,
Finello KM
The premature small-for-gestational age
infant during the first year of life: comparison by birth weight and
gestational age.
J Pediatr
1988;
113:1066-1073[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Ruys-Dudok van Hell I,
de Leevw R
Clinical outcome of
small-for-gestational age preterm infants.
J Perinat Med
1989;
17:77-83[Medline]
-
Usher R,
McLean F
Intrauterine growth of live born Caucasian infants
at sea level: standards obtained from measurements in 7 dimensions of
infants born between 25 and 44 weeks of gestation.
J
Pediatr
1969;
74:901-910[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Papile LA,
Burstein J,
Burstein AR,
Koffler H
Incidence and evolution
of subependymal and intraventricular hemorrhage: a study of infants
with birth weights less than 1500 gm.
J Pediatr
1978;
92:529-534[CrossRef][Medline]
-
The Committee for the Classification of Retinopathy of Prematurity
An
international classification of retinopathy of prematurity.
Pediatrics
1984;
74:127-133[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Morley R,
Brooke OG,
Cole TJ,
Powell R,
Lucas A
Birthweight ratio and
outcome in preterm infants.
Arch Dis Child
1990;
65:30-34[Abstract]
-
Chen SJ,
Vohr B,
Oh W
Effects of birth order, gender and intrauterine
growth retardation on the outcome of very low birth weight in twins.
J Pediatr
1993;
123:132-136[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Khoury MJ,
Erickson JD,
Cordero J,
McCarthy BJ
Congenital
malformations and intrauterine growth retardation: a population study.
Pediatrics
1988;
82:83-90[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Wilcox AJ,
Skjoerven R
Birthweight and perinatal mortality: the effect
of gestational age.
Am J Public Health
1992;
82:378-382[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Williams RL,
Creasy RK,
Cunningham GC,
Hawers WE,
Norris FD,
Tashiro M
Fetal growth and perinatal viability in California.
Obstet
Gynecol
1982;
59:624-632[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Aranda JV,
Beharry K,
Sasyniuk B,
Chemtob S
The role of prostanoids in
neonatal cerebral blood flow autoregulation.
J Lipid Mediat
1993;
6:493-501[Medline]
-
Heymann MA
Prostaglandins and leukotrienes in the perinatal period.
Clin Perinatol
1987;
14:957-980
-
Franks L,
Sosenko IRS
Development of the lung antioxidant enzyme
system in late gestation: possible implications for the prematurely
born infant.
J Pediatr
1987;
110:9-14[CrossRef][Medline]