From the * Departments of Pediatrics and Neurobiology, State University of New York at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, New York.
Objectives. To determine whether adjunctive therapy with recombinant human granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (rhG-CSF) could reverse sepsis-associated neonatal neutropenia and improve neonatal survival compared with conventional therapy in a phase I/II-type trial.
Study Design. An intravenous infusion of rhG-CSF (10 µg/kg/d × 3 d) was administered to 14 septic neutropenic
neonates. Neutrophilic responses and outcome of these neonates were
compared with 11 concurrently treated, retrospectively selected,
case-matched control septic patients identified by using a search of
medical records coded for sepsis with neutropenia (
24 hours).
Results. Seven neonates with early-onset sepsis with neutropenia at birth and seven neonates with late-onset sepsis plus neutropenia (all with necrotizing enterocolitis) were entered in the rhG-CSF treatment group. Results were compared with a conventional therapy control group (five early onset, six late onset). No significant differences existed in the birth weight, gestational age, use of antibiotic therapy, magnitude of respiratory support, severity of metabolic acidosis, use of vasopressors, or other supportive therapy between the two groups. In the rhG-CSF-treated group and in the conventionally treated control group, the absolute neutrophil count (ANC) (mean ± SEM) was 585 ± 138 and 438 ± 152, respectively. The ANC increased to more than baseline in the rhG-CSF-treated group by 10-fold versus 2-fold at 24 hours, 18-fold versus 4-fold at 48 hours, 24-fold versus 5-fold at 72 hours (significant by one-way analysis of variance in the rhG-CSF group only), and 29-fold versus 16-fold at 7 to 10 days when compared with the conventional therapy group. There were no nonresponders in the rhG-CSF group by 24 hours after the first dose of study drug. Monocyte cell counts also increased significantly in both groups by 7 days after entry into this protocol but remained within normal range for age. No clinically significant effect on lymphocytes, erythrocytes, or platelet counts was noted. Thirteen patients in the rhG-CSF-treated group (92%; 13 out of 14) and five in the conventionally treated group (55%; 5 out of 11) survived to 28 days after the onset of the signs of sepsis. No adverse effects were noted in the rhG-CSF-treated group.
Conclusions. rhG-CSF can increase the neutrophil count in critically ill septic neutropenic neonates. This finding suggests that rhG-CSF may be effective in a therapeutically useful time frame to treat septic neonates with neonatal neutropenia attributable to bone marrow suppression or neutrophil consumption. Future randomized trials are needed to validate the beneficial effects of rhG-CSF and to determine whether any significant side effects of therapy exist.
Key words: neonatal sepsis, recombinant human granulocyte colony stimulating factor, bacteremia, cytokines, very low birth weight, neutropenia.Sepsis continues to remain a major reason for an increased morbidity and mortality in neonates. Bacterial sepsis occurs in .1 to 1% of term newborns,1 and is up to 50 times more common in extremely low birth weight infants (neonates below 800 g at birth).2 Four percent of deaths in the first 3 days of postnatal life and 45% of deaths after 2 weeks are related to infections, with no change in this pattern for the past 15 years.3,4 Mortality from neonatal sepsis depends upon the virulence of the organism, the gestational age of the neonate, and the particular combination and severity of the patient's concomitant illnesses.1,5
Neonatal sepsis is also commonly associated with neutropenia8,9 as a result of a shortened neutrophil half-life from 6.3 hours to less than 4 hours,10 a limited ability to augment production of the neutrophil proliferative pool, defective production of cytokines, and a rapid depletion of the infant's neutrophil storage pool during bacteremia.11 The resulting neutropenia serves as an ominous marker for an exaggerated additional risk of mortality attributable to sepsis which rises to as high as 90%.4,5,14,15
Although the immature immune system is limited in a variety of
ways,16 quantitative deficiencies of the myeloid and
phagocytic system in general, and immaturity of neutrophil function in
particular, are thought to contribute significantly to the high
morbidity and mortality from bacterial sepsis in this
population.11,16 Furthermore, as nosocomial infections
are the most common cause of late-onset mortality2,4 and
because this patient group contributes up to 70% of all in-hospital
patient days (University Medical Center at Stony Brook, 1995), better
methods of reducing morbidity and mortality attributable to late-onset
nosocomial infections (
4 days) as well as early-onset infections (<1
day) are desirable.
rhG-CSF has been considered to enhance stochastic entry into the granulocytic pathway, increase rapid egress of immature neutrophils into the peripheral circulation,20,21 and also, improve the killing capacity of mature neutrophils.22 In addition, septic neonates show reduced expression of granulocyte colony-stimulating factor yet the myeloid lineage from premature infants expresses receptors for this cytokine at adult levels.23,24 Taken together, these observations suggest that rhG-CSF replacement therapy may be beneficial in this population.
Recently, several case reports argue that administration of rhG-CSF contributed significantly to improved outcome attributable to neonatal septicemia even without neutropenia.25 In addition, we and others have found that persistent preeclampsia-associated neutropenia (>3 consecutive days) could be reversed with rhG-CSF in severely affected neonates suggesting that the immature neonate's bone marrow had a substantial and unanticipated reserve capacity in these two clinical conditions.29,30 The objective of this study is to determine whether rhG-CSF might prove helpful in the treatment of neonatal sepsis-associated neutropenia in a therapeutically useful time frame. We examined the effects of rhG-CSF on the peripheral white cell responses and survival of fourteen neutropenic and septic neonates and compared this with eleven neutropenic and septic neonates concurrently treated using only conventional therapy.
Patient Selection
The study was conducted in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit of the University Hospital of the State University of New York at Stony Brook from August 1994 to August 1996. Neonates treated with rhG-CSF were selected as potential candidates for therapy if they were considered to be septic (ie, systemic signs of infection) and were neutropenic for
24 hours (see below). Patients were enrolled into
this Phase I/II-type toxicity trial after obtaining written informed
consent from a parent. The protocol was approved by our Institutional
Research Board and is registered with the Food and Drug Administration
(IND #5616). Concurrently treated and conventionally-treated control
patients were identified retrospectively from a review of hospital
records identified for neonatal sepsis with associated neutropenia for
24 hours using the same study entry criteria.
Definitions
Neutropenia was defined as a total neutrophil count less than 1500 cells/mm3 using a minor modification of the criteria of Manroe, et al.31 Neutropenia was identified in two separate peripheral blood samples taken >12 hours apart and obtained within 24 hours of the onset of clinical symptoms. The absolute neutrophil count was determined by multiplying the total leukocyte count (corrected for nucleated red blood cells and obtained by a Coulter Counter, model #STKS, Coulter Technologies, Miami, FL) by the percentage of polymorphonuclear leukocytes and band forms identified manually in peripheral venous or arterial blood. Metamyelocytes and myelocytes were not included because they may not be functionally active as a phagocytic defense system and contribute minimally to the total count.32
24 hours) neonate, had both
an unexplained metabolic acidosis (>5 meq/L) and hypotension (below
age-appropriate normative data34). Culture-positive sepsis was diagnosed when a positive blood culture was obtained in association with any of these signs. Culture-negative sepsis was defined as neutropenia for 24 hours in association with metabolic acidosis and
hypotension.
Treatment Protocol
Both the study population and the control population were treated with appropriate conventional therapeutic interventions including antibiotics, oxygen and mechanical ventilatory support, intravenous fluids, vasopressor drugs (dopamine or dobutamine), and other standard interventions deemed necessary by the attending neonatologist responsible for the clinical treatment of the neonate independent of study drug usage. In addition, neonates in the study group received intravenous rhG-CSF (Filgrastin; Amgen, Thousand Oaks, CA) at a dose of 10 µg/kg/d in 5% dextrose (final concentration, 15 µg/mL) for 1 hour29,30 daily for a maximum of 3 days administered via microbore tubing (0.8 mL dead space to limit drug loss on tubing). During and up to 72 hours after the administration of rhG-CSF, continuous cardiorespiratory monitoring, as well as frequent fluid and electrolyte measurements, were performed. Daily monitoring of complete peripheral white blood cell counts and manual differential counts were performed until they remained within the normal range in all neonates for a period of up to 2 weeks as is the current hospital routine in patients with this severity of infectious illness.Statistics
Statistical analysis was performed using a one way analysis of variance with repeated measures followed by the Dunnet's multirange test for multiple comparisons between the baseline value cell count and counts from subsequent time points for both patient groups. A
2 test was used to determine significance of
difference in proportional data. All nominal data are reported as
mean ± SEM (a P value <.05 was considered significant
with a power >.8).
Infectious Course
Fourteen neonates were entered in the rhG-CSF plus conventional treatment group and 11 concurrently-treated neonates received only conventional medical treatment. The demographic clinical characteristics of both groups (Table 1) showed no significant differences. Seven patients from the rhG-CSF group and five from the conventionally-treated group had early-onset sepsis (<1 day postnatal age) and were clinically symptomatic and neutropenic from birth. Seven neonates from the rhG-CSF group and six from the conventionally-treated group had late-onset sepsis (onset >4 days postnatal age) with a median age of onset of 14 days in both the conventional and rhG-CSF-treated groups. All patients with late-onset sepsis had a normal ANC from birth but subsequently became neutropenic (<1500 cells/mm3 × 24 h) after the diagnosis of necrotizing enterocolitis.|
Table 1. Demographic Characteristics of Study Patients |
-hemolytic Streptococcus. In addition, one neonate from
rhG-CSF group and two neonates from the conventional treatment group
grew gram-negative bacteria from their blood. Culture-negative sepsis
was diagnosed in three neutropenic infants in the rhG-CSF treatment
group who also had an unexplained metabolic acidosis (>5 meq/L),
hypotension34 (treated with pressors), oxygen and ventilator dependence, plus other clinical and laboratory signs of
sepsis.33 These three patients also had an obstetrical
history and histopathological evidence (placenta) of maternal
chorioamnionitis in which antepartum antibiotics were given to the
mother less than 4 hours before delivery.
Clinical Hospital Course
All neonates tolerated rhG-CSF well and in each case no adverse reactions were identified with regard to cardiovascular performance, electrolyte balance, skin reaction, irritability or worsening of respiratory function. One 930-g patient in the early sepsis group received surfactant for hyaline membrane disease and developed a pulmonary hemorrhage on day 3 postnatal age. This patient's hospital course had been complicated by neutropenia, metabolic acidosis, hypotension (treated with pressors), and apnea (<24 hours postnatal age) all before rhG-CSF therapy. He went on to develop pulmonary hemorrhage again on day 10 postnatal age after a routine tracheal toileting (suctioning) procedure. This adverse event was considered to be unrelated to use of study drug. Patients in both groups also received conventional neonatal intensive care unit treatment for severe sepsis which included antibiotics for 10 days or more, ventilatory support of respiration (13 out of 14 vs 11 out of 11, P = ns), and vasopressors (dopamine and/or dobutamine: 7 out of 14 vs 7 out of 11, P = ns; Table 1) in the conventional and rhG-CSF treatment groups, respectively. Hematocrits were routinely maintained at or around 40% by transfusions with packed red blood cells.Mortality
Thirteen neonates in the rhG-CSF group and five in the conventionally-treated group were alive at 28 days after the onset of their presenting illness (P < .03, power .8) and 12 neonates in rhG-CSF group and 4 in conventionally-treated group survived to discharge. In the 11 conventionally-treated patients, 3 of 5 neonates with early-onset sepsis died within 24 hours of treatment with only antibiotics plus supportive therapy and one additional neonate died 48 hours after initiating conventional treatment. None of the rhG-CSF-treated neonates died in the early-onset sepsis group.rhG-CSF Effects on Peripheral White Blood Cell Counts and Differential Counts
The absolute neutrophil count at the time of entry into this protocol in the rhG-CSF treatment group was 585 ± 138/mm3 (mean ± SEM) and 438 ± 152/mm3 (P = ns) in the conventionally-treated group (Table 2). The neutropenia in all patients was present from 24 hours or more to 120 hours before the institution of rhG-CSF therapy.|
Table 2. Peripheral Blood Cell Responses of Septic and Neutropenic Neonates After Treatment With rhG-CSF Compared With Recovery of Cell Counts With Conventional Therapy |
Fig. 1.
The timing of the changes in the ANC in the rhG-CSF-treated neonates
occurs sooner and remains longer than in the conventionally-treated control neonates. rhG-CSF group (n = 14,
); no rhG-CSF group (n = 11,
). Numbers adjacent to individual points indicate the remaining live patients at each time point.
[View Larger Version of this Image (23K GIF file)]
± SEM) for the rhG-CSF and conventional groups, respectively. At day 7 to 10, the values were 38 ± 2 and 39 ± 2, respectively (P = ns). The absolute cell
counts were noted to increase with regard to lymphocytes in both groups
with a peak effect on day 7 to 10 after entry into this study protocol
(P < .05 for both groups versus baseline in
rhG-CSF- and conventional-treatment groups, respectively). However,
absolute lymphocyte counts remained within normal range and there was
no significant difference between the two groups at any time point.
Also there were no clinically or statistically significant differences
in platelet counts throughout the time for either group (eg, 199 ± 73 and 101 ± 19/mm3 at entry and 219 ± 55 and 172 ± 57/mm3 at day 7 to 10 for rhG-CSF and
conventional groups, respectively), and no patients were transfused
with platelets.
We identified two groups of septic and neutropenic neonates
who presented either at birth (<1 day postnatal age) or after the
fourth day of postnatal life with systemic symptoms of sepsis including
hypotension and metabolic acidosis. In either the early- or late-onset
groups, the absolute neutrophil count increased in 24 hours or less
after intravenous administration of rhG-CSF well before changes
observed in a similar population of retrospectively selected
case-matched, conventionally-treated control patients. The increase in
the white blood cells in the rhG-CSF-treatment group was statistically
significantly higher at 24 hours than that of the
conventionally-treated control group in which the increase only
achieved significance at 7 to 10 days after entry. The neonatal
response followed a predictable pattern of timing similar to
observations made in adult patients with sepsis or pneumonia.37,38
.8) or to mortality in septic
and neutropenic patients described in previous reports in which it was
nearly 90%.14 Based on animal literature and adult
studies, this effect would be anticipated. In rodents, administration
of rhG-CSF at the onset of the inoculum lowers mortality in
experimental group B
-hemolytic streptococcus sepsis compared with
antibiotics alone.42 Similarly, administration of rhG-CSF
with antibiotics in a rabbit model of gram-negative sepsis and
neutropenia improves survival compared with antibiotics
alone.43 Because a survival benefit is also detected in
adult humans with severe sepsis and multiorgan failure,38
it is plausible that the improved survival we observed in neonates may
eventually prove valid in a larger blinded randomized sample of
patients. This putative improvement in survival may arise from the
ability of rhG-CSF to augment neutrophil chemotaxis, enhance
phagocytosis, increase superoxide production, accelerate antibody
dependent cellular cytotoxicity, increase neutrophil Fc
RI and C3bi
expression, and increase respiratory burst activity.22 Treating extremely low birth weight neonates with a cytokine that can
rapidly (<24 hours) augment the cellular immune responses has
extraordinary potential for benefit in a population of patients with a
more than 30% underlying incidence of bacterial sepsis at baseline
risk that carries up to a 50% mortality2,5 or even more
with neutropenia.2,4,5,14,15 Although a good reason for
cautious optimism, current thinking suggests that reperfusion injury
(after hypoxia or reduced blood flow or both) may involve a significant
activation of macrophages and local invasion of peripheral blood
neutrophils, that could be detrimental to recovery.40,44 Thus, it is conceivable that bronchopulmonary dysplasia, NEC, retinopathy of prematurity, or even intraventricular hemorrhage may be
considerably worsened by adjunctive treatment with this drug.
Received for publication Nov 22, 1996; accepted Feb 6, 1997.
Reprint requests to (E.F.L.) HSC 11-060, Division of Newborn Medicine, Departments of Pediatrics and Neurobiology, SUNY at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, NY 11794-8111.
We would like to thank Dr J. DeCristofaro for his helpful comments in preparing this manuscript.
rhG-CSF, recombinant human granulocyte colony-stimulating factor. NEC, necrotizing enterocolitis. ANC, absolute neutrophil count.
role and relationships in infectious diseases.
(Review).
J Infect Dis
1995;
172:1061-1075[Medline]This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
N. Modi and R. Carr Promising stratagems for reducing the burden of neonatal sepsis Arch. Dis. Child. Fetal Neonatal Ed., September 1, 2000; 83(2): 150F - 153. [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
E. C. Eichenwald and A. R. Stark High-frequency Ventilation: Current Status Pediatr. Rev., December 1, 1999; 20(12): e127 - e133. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Kocherlakota and E. F. La Gamma Preliminary Report: rhG-CSF May Reduce the Incidence of Neonatal Sepsis in Prolonged Preeclampsia-associated Neutropenia Pediatrics, November 1, 1998; 102(5): 1107 - 1111. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||