PEDIATRICS Vol. 100 No. 1 July 1997,
p. e5
Copyright ©1997 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
ELECTRONIC ARTICLE:
Neurodevelopmental Outcomes of Ugandan Infants With Human
Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Infection
,
,
From the * Departments of Pediatrics, Epidemiology, and
Psychology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio;
Johns
Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland; and the § Departments of
Pediatrics, Child Health, and Psychology, Makerere University, Kampala,
Uganda.
Background. The neurodevelopmental outcomes of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)-infected Ugandan infants of nondrug-using mothers were studied using controlled, prospective methodology.
Method. The sample of 436 full-term infants included 79 HIV-infected infants of HIV-1-infected mothers, 241 uninfected infants of HIV-1-infected mothers (seroreverters), and 116 uninfected infants born to HIV-negative mothers. Neurologic status, information processing ability, and motor and mental development were assessed from 6 to 24 months of age. Observations of caretaker-child interaction and home environments were made at 6 and 12 months. All evaluators were blinded to the HIV status of the child and family.
Results. Compared with seroreverters and uninfected infants, HIV-infected infants demonstrated greater deficits in motor development and neurologic status, and more frequent and earlier onset of motor and neurologic abnormalities. Compared with controls, HIV-infected infants had more abnormalities in mental development at 6 and 18 months and an earlier onset of abnormalities. By 12 months, 30% of HIV-infected infants demonstrated motor abnormalities and 26% cognitive abnormalities as compared with 11% and 6% among seroreverters and 5% and 6% among seronegative infants. HIV-infected infants (62%) demonstrated a higher probability of developing an abnormal neurologic examination by 12 months, compared with seroreverters (17%) or seronegative infants (15%). Information-processing abilities did not differ as a function of HIV infection. Home environments and infants' interactions with caretakers were similar across groups.
Conclusion. We conclude that HIV infection results in more frequent and earlier abnormalities in infants' neurologic status and motor development that are not attributable to other biological and environmental risk factors. More frequent mental developmental abnormalities were evident at several ages. However, information-processing abilities, such as recognition memory, may be spared from HIV-related deficits.
Key words: HIV infection, neurodevelopment, mental development, motor development, neurological status, information processing ability.The prevalence of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) in infants and young children in the United States and in the world has dramatically increased.1 Prevalence rates of HIV infection, which are now more than one million children worldwide, indicate that HIV-1-related central nervous system disease will become a significant cause of mental deficiency and developmental disabilities in the United States and worldwide.5 Generalized cognitive deficiencies,6 language15 and motor9 deficits, and variation in the type and severity of developmental and neurologic deficits have been consistently reported.8 For this reason, there is a continuing need for controlled studies of neurodevelopmental outcomes among young children with HIV-1, not only in the United States, but also in developing countries where HIV has high prevalence. Although such studies are important in their own right, they also provide an opportunity to assess the impact of HIV infection on children's development unconfounded by the effects of risk factors such as maternal drug addiction.
However, most studies of the developmental outcomes of HIV-infected children have been conducted in the United States. The outcomes obtained in such studies are not directly comparable to those that have been conducted in developing countries because children in the United States are now receiving antiretroviral treatments that may lessen the severity of cognitive and motor deficits.17 To our knowledge, only three such studies have been reported. The study of Boivan et al11 on Zairian infants from birth to 18 months identified deficits (with the exception of language) on the Denver Developmental Screening Test among HIV-infected (n = 14) versus uninfected (n = 20) children. A second group (n = 11) of HIV-infected children (mean age of 54 months) demonstrated sequential motor and visual spatial memory deficits on the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children compared with uninfected children.
Msellati et al's follow-up13 of Rwandan infants (birth to 24 months) identified higher rates of neurologic impairments (15% to 40%) in HIV-infected children (n = 20 to 43) compared with those (5% or less) of controls (uninfected children born to seropositive mothers, n = 113 to 133, and uninfected children born to seronegative mothers, n = 156 to 193). HIV-infected children also had more deficits on a developmental screening test.
A recent prospective study18 assessed the outcomes of infants born to nondrug-using HIV-seropositive Haitian women from 3 to 24 months of age. By 3 months, the mean mental and motor scores of HIV-infected infants (n = 28) were lower than those of uninfected infants (n = 98).
Taken together, these findings have documented significant HIV-related developmental and neurologic deficits that are not attributable to associated risk factors such as maternal drug addiction, and family instability. However, the conclusions that can be drawn from the above studies are limited by several methodological issues that are addressed in the present study. In two of the above studies,10,12 developmental outcome data were based entirely on unvalidated screening instruments. In the third, sensorimotor development was assessed using a standardized instrument.
However, no previous study has measured infants' information processing abilities, which have been shown to be more robust predictors of children's cognitive development at school age than measures of sensorimotor development.19 In addition, previous studies have not determined whether the obtained developmental outcomes were attributable to differences in the quality of home environments and caretaking in families of HIV-infected children. Finally, prior studies have not provided detailed information concerning the time to onset of neurodevelopmental impairments.
To address these needs, our research employed a prospective assessment of Ugandan infants' cognitive development, information-processing abilities, and neurologic status using well-validated measures to describe the nature of neurodevelopmental impairments, including time to onset, in this population. Detailed observations of mother-child interactions and home environments were also conducted. Three groups were studied: HIV-1-infected infants of HIV-1- infected mothers, uninfected infants of HIV-1-infected mothers (seroreverters), and uninfected infants born to HIV-negative mothers.
Selection Criteria and Patient Recruitment
The study was approved by the institutional review boards at University Hospitals, Cleveland and Makerere University, Kampala, Uganda. Pregnant women presenting during the second trimester of pregnancy to the Makerere University prenatal clinic at New Mulago Hospital in Kampala, Uganda, gave informed consent for blood drawing for themselves before delivery and for their infants after birth. Infection with HIV-1 was determined by initial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (Cambridge Bioscience, Worcester, MA, Recombigen) with confirmation of seropositivity by IG Western blotting (Dupont, Geneva, Switzerland). Biorad Novapath (Hercules, CA) Immunoblot assay, a Western blot immunoblot assay, was interpreted as positive if it contained any two of the following bands: gp 120/160, gp41, or p24.Clinical Follow-up
Infants were seen in scheduled visits at 6, 10, and 14 weeks and at 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, and 24 months. Cord and birth blood were obtained on each infant, and blood was subsequently drawn at birth, 6 weeks, 6 months, 12 months, and beyond 15 months. HIV-1 status was determined by HIV-1 enzyme immunoassay beyond 15 months in surviving infants with confirmatory Western blot of all seropositives. HIV-1 DNA polymerase chain reaction and immune complex dissociation p24 antigen testing was performed on specimens from children who were lost to follow-up or died before 15 months of age. Anthropometric measures, (height, weight, and head circumference), interim history (intercurrent illnesses, HIV-related symptoms, feeding, development, and maternal health), and physical and neurologic examinations were performed at each visit. Immunizations, medications, and management of acute interim illnesses were provided for all infants. Infants with growth failure were referred to a weekly nutrition clinic.Definition and Classification of HIV-1 Infection
Laboratory criteria for diagnosis of HIV infection were enzyme immunoassay and Western blot positive 15 months of age or older or positive HIV DNA polymerase chain reaction (excluding cord blood) or positive neutralizable immune complex dissociation p24 antigen (excluding cord blood).20 Children born to mothers with HIV infection were defined as seroreverters if they became HIV-antibody-negative after 9 months of age and had no other laboratory evidence of HIV infection and did not meet the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome surveillance case definition criteria.21 Laboratory measures of immune status such as CD4 were not available in this field setting.Neurodevelopmental Assessment Procedures
Sensorimotor Development The Bayley Scales of Infant Development22 including mental development (eg, comprehension, imitation, language) and motor development (motor coordination and skills) was determined at 6, 9, 12, 18, and 24 months. Based on a pilot study (n = 65) of healthy Ugandan infants (ages 3 to 30 months), culturally appropriate modifications of these measures were employed (eg, objects and pictures commonly found in the culture and translation of all instructions into the local language, eg, Luganda).Information Processing Ability
The Fagan Test of Infant Intelligence was administered at 6, 9, and 12 months of age because it measures information-processing ability, does not require any motoric responses,23 has established predictive validity for detection of mental retardation,19,24 and is feasible in field settings with infants from different cultures.25 The Fagan test assesses recognition memory by measuring an infant's differential visual attention to a novel stimulus (a picture of a novel human face) relative to a familiar stimulus (human face) that was previously presented. The average percentage of total time that infants looked at novel versus familiar faces across 10 such pairings was calculated.Neurologic Status
During each well-child visit, physical examinations included neurodevelopmental assessments that identified focal deficits and abnormalities in strength, tone, and coordination based on the Amiel-Tison scoring system.26 An on-site developmental pediatrician (L.M.) supervised clinical assessments. All clinicians were blinded to HIV status of mothers and infants. Abnormal neurologic examinations were checked by a second clinician. An experienced pediatric neurologist (M.W.) trained all physicians and reviewed cumulative neurologic examination results to derive a rating of normal versus abnormal. To be classified as abnormal, a child had to demonstrate a persistent (rather than transient) neurologic examination as documented by abnormalities on two or more consecutive examination.Family Characteristics, Mother-Child Interaction, and Quality of Home Environment
Based on measures developed in African field research,27 family caretaker-child interactions were assessed in home visits at 6 and 12 months of age. Each 30-minute visit yielded objective data concerning the frequency of mother-child and caretaker-child (eg, extended family, siblings) interactions, including touch, vocalization, and physical care. Observers also rated the quality of home environments, such as caretaker responsiveness and organization, based on reliable and valid procedures28,29 that were modified for Uganda based on pilot work. Interrater reliabilities ranged from .75 to .88.Procedures to Enhance Reliability and Validity of Data
All staff, including physicians and research assistants who conducted psychologic and home assessments, were blind to maternal and child HIV status. Data were reviewed regularly by the investigators to enhance quality control and interobserver reliability. Infants were not assessed when acutely ill.Data Analyses
Analyses of variance compared group means. Post-hoc pair-wise comparisons were adjusted using a Bonferroni corrected P value (P < .015).
2 tests for
contingency tables and Fisher's exact tests compared categorical and
event frequency data. Kaplan-Meier right-censored product-limit
life-table analysis estimated the probability of an abnormal neurologic
(Amiel-Tison) or psychologic examination (Bayley or Fagan) and infant
infection status while also adjusting for time to abnormal examination
and/or censoring attributable to early death or loss to follow-up.
Unweighted Wilcoxon log-rank and Breslow (weighted for early events)
statistics were used to identify differences (two-sided nominal
P values) in pair-wise survival curve comparisons. All
analyses and data management were conducted using SPSS/PC + V6.0
and EPI-INFO V5.01B.
Description of Completed Follow-up Assessments
The number and percentages of living children who completed developmental assessments (Bayley Scales) from 6 to 24 months are shown in Table 1. Forty-four (56%) of the HIV-infected children, 14 (6%) of the seroreverters, and only 1 (.09%) of the uninfected children died. Maternal mortality was comparable in the HIV-infected (13.6%) and sero-reverter (11.5%) groups, but was 0% for seronegative mothers.|
Table 1. Summary of Completed Developmental Assessments Over Two Years of Follow-up* |
Mental and Motor Development
Bayley Motor and Mental Development scores (number of items passed) are shown in Table 2. Analyses of variance indicated that HIV-infected children's motor development scores were lower than that of noninfected infants at all ages (P < .002 or greater). HIV-infected infants had lower mental development scores than the other groups at 6, 18, and 24 months (P < .001 or greater). Seroreverters and uninfected children had comparable scores on these measures at all time points.|
Table 2. Means and Standard Deviations of Raw Scores on Bayley Scale for Children Ages 6 to 24 Months According to HIV Infection Status |
Table 3.
Frequency and Percentage of Children With Normal Versus Abnormal Scores
on Bayley Scales*
2. As shown
in Table 3, a greater percentage of HIV-infected
children demonstrated motor abnormalities at every age compared with
the other groups, which did not differ (P < .02 or greater). A greater percentage of HIV-infected infants also had more
abnormal Bayley Mental Development scores than uninfected infants at 6 and 18 months (P < .01).
Neurologic Examination
Table 4.
Numbers and Percentages of Children With Normal Versus Abnormal
Neurological Exams*
Information Processing
Fig. 1.
Cumulative probability of normal Bayley motor score.
[View Larger Version of this Image (24K GIF file)]
Fig. 2.
Cumulative probability of normal Bayley mental score.
[View Larger Version of this Image (21K GIF file)]
Fig. 3.
Cumulative probability of normal neurologic examination.
[View Larger Version of this Image (22K GIF file)]
Assessment of Quality of Home Environment and Mother-Child Interaction
To determine whether the neurodevelopmental deficits associated with HIV infection could be attributed to group differences in the quality of caretaking, the frequency of positive interactions (summary of vocalizations, touches, and holds) with all caregivers and total home environment scores were compared at 6 and 12 months. Higher scores indicated more positive interactions and home environments.Our primary finding was that HIV infection was associated with higher rates of abnormalities in motor development and neurologic status from 6 to 24 months of age, as well as with earlier onset of these deficits. In general, mental development was less powerfully affected, although HIV-infected infants demonstrated an earlier onset of significant impairment in mental development than uninfected infants, more abnormalities at 6 and 18 months, and lower mental development scores at 18 and 24 months.
Received for publication Sep 3, 1996; accepted Jan 14, 1997.
Reprint requests to (D.D.) Rainbow Babies and Children's Hospital, 11100 Euclid Ave, Cleveland, OH 44106.
This study was supported by National Institutes of Health grant NS28631, World Health Organization, Rotary International, and the Catholic Agency for Overseas Development.
HIV, human immunodeficiency virus.
- Quinn TC, Ruff A, Halsey N Pediatric acquired immunodeficiency syndrome: special considerations for developing nations. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 1991; 11:558-568
- Pizzo P, Wilfert C. Pediatric Aids: the Challenge of HIV Infection in Infants, Children, and Adolescents. Baltimore, MD: William & Wilkins; 1991
- Goodgame RW AIDS in Uganda. Clinical and social features. N Engl J Med. 1990; 323:383-389[Medline]
- Crocker AC, Cohen HJ, Kastner TA. HIV Infection and Developmental Disabilities. Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co; 1992
- World Health Organization AIDS-global data. The current global situation of the HIV-1 AIDS pandemic. Weekly Epidemiol Rec. 1994; 6:189-192
- Ultmann MH, Belman Al, Ruff HA Developmental abnormalities in infants and children with acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) and AIDS related complex. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1985; 27:563-571[Medline]
-
Epstein LG,
Charer LR,
Oleske JM
Neurologic manifestations of human
immunodeficiency virus in children.
Pediatrics
1986;
78:678-687
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Belman AL AIDS and pediatric neurology. Pediatr Neurol. 1990; 8:571-603
-
Aylward EH,
Butz AM,
Hutton N,
Joyner ML,
Vogelhut JW
Cognitive and
motor development in infants at risk for human immunodeficiency virus.
Am J Dis Child.
1992;
146:218-222
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
Levinson RL,
Mellins CA,
Zawadzki L,
Kairan R,
Stein Z
Cognitive
assessment in HIV exposed children.
Am J Dis Child.
1992;
146:1479-1483
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Boivan MJ, Green DRS, Davies AG, Giordani B, Mokili JKL, Cutting WAM A preliminary evaluation of the cognitive and motor effects of pediatric HIV-infection on African children. Health Psychol. 1995; 14:13-21[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Mellins CA,
Levenson RL,
Zawardzki R,
Kairam R,
Weston M
Effects of
pediatric HIV infection and prenatal drug exposure on mental and motor
development.
J Pediatr Psychol.
1994;
19:617-628
[Abstract/Free Full Text] -
Msellati P,
Lepage P,
Hitmana D,
VanGoethem C,
Vande Perre P, Dabis F
Neurodevelopmental testing of children born to human immunodeficiency
virus type 1 seropositive and seronegative mothers: a prospective
cohort study in Kigali, Rwanda.
Pediatrics
1993;
92:843-848
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Nozyce M, Hittelman J, Muenz L, Durako SJ, Fisher ML, Willoughby A Effect of perinatally acquired human immuodefiency virus infection and neurodevelopment in children during the first two years of life. Pediatrics 1994; 94:883-891[Medline]
- Condini A, Axia G, Cattelan C, Development of language in 18-30 month-old HIV-1 infected but ill children. AIDS 1991; 5:735-739[Medline]
- Diamond GW Developmental problems in children with HIV infection. Ment Retard. 1989; 27:213-217[Medline]
- Falloon J, Eddy J, Wiener L Human immunodeficiency virus infection in children. J Pediatr. 1989; 114:1-30[CrossRef][Medline]
- Gay CL, Armstrong D, Cohen D, The effects of HIV on cognitive and motor development in children born to HIV seropositive women with no reported drug use: birth to 24 months. Pediatrics 1995; 95:1078-1082
-
Fagan JF,
Singer LT,
Montie J,
Shepherd PA
Selective screening device
for the early detection of normal or delayed cognitive development in
infants at risk for later mental retardation.
Pediatrics
1986;
78:1021-1026
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - CDC 1994 Revised classification system for human immunodeficiency virus infection for children less than 13 years of age. MMWR. 1994;43;No. RR12
- CDC revision of the surveillance case definition for acquired immunodeficiency syndrome. MMWR. 1987;36(suppl):1-15a
- Bayley N. Bayley Scales of Mental Development. New York, NY: Psychological Corporation; 1969
- Drotar D, Mortimer J, Shepherd A, Fagan JF Case report: recognition memory as a method to assess intelligence is an infant with quadriplegia. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1989; 31:391-394[Medline]
- McCall RB, Carriger MS A meta-analysis of infant habituation and recognition performance as a prediction of later IQ. Child Dev 1992; 64:57-69[CrossRef]
- Fagan JF, Drotar D, Olness K, et al. The Fagan Test of Infant Intelligence: Cross-cultural and Racial Differences. Presented at annual meeting of Society for Behavioral Pediatrics; September 21, 1991; Baltimore, MD
- Amiel-Tison C, Grenier A. Neurologic Assessment During the First Year of Life. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 1986
- Sigman M, Neumann L, Carter E, Cattle DJD, Souza S, Biwilbo N Home interactions and the development of Embu toddlers in Kenya. Child Dev. 1989; 59:1251-1261[CrossRef]
- Caldwell BM, Bradley RH. Home Observation for Measurement of the Environment. Little Rock, AR: University of Arkansas; 1979
- Elardo R, Bradley RH The home observation for the measurement of the environment (HOME) Scale: a review of research. Dev Rev. 1981; 1:113-145[CrossRef]
- Fagan JF, Detterman D The Fagan Test of infant intelligence: a technical summary. J Appl Dev Psychol. 1992; 13:173-193
-
Bellinger DC,
Jonas RA,
Rappaport LA,
Developmental and
neurologic status of children after heart surgery with hypothermic
circulatory arrest or low flow cardiopulmonary bypass.
N
Engl J Med.
1995;
332:549-555
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Johnson CB Developmental issues: Children infected with the human immunodeficiency virus. Inf Young Child. 1993; 6:1-10
-
Browers P,
DeCarli C,
Civitello L,
Moss H,
Wolters P,
Pizzo D
Correlation between computed tomographic brain scan abnormalities and
neuropsychological function in children with symptomatic human
immunodeficiency virus disease.
Arch Neurol.
1995;
52:39-44
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Diamond GW, Kaufman J, Belman AL, Cohen L, Cohen HG, Rubinstein R Characterization of cognitive functioning in a subgroup of children with congenital HIV infection. Arch Clin Neuropsychol. 1987; 2:245-256[CrossRef][Medline]
- Frances DJ, Fletcher JM, Stuebing KK, Davidson KC, Thompson NM Analysis of change: modeling individual growth. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1991; 59:27-37[CrossRef][Medline]
- Cohen HJ, Papola P, Alvarez M Neurodevelopmental abnormalities in school age children with HIV infection. J Sch Health. 1994; 54:11-13
-
Papola P,
Alvarez M,
Cohen HJ
Developmental and service needs of
school-age children with human immunodeficiency virus infection: a
descriptive study.
Pediatrics
1994;
94:914-918
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Pediatrics (ISSN 0031 4005). Copyright ©1997 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J E. Harrop Management of pain in childhood Arch. Dis. Child. Ed. Pract., August 1, 2007; 92(4): ep101 - ep108. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. C. Shanbhag, R. M. Rutstein, T. Zaoutis, H. Zhao, D. Chao, and J. Radcliffe Neurocognitive Functioning in Pediatric Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection: Effects of Combined Therapy Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, July 1, 2005; 159(7): 651 - 656. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. S. Houck Taking `ouch' out of doctor visits easier than ever AAP News, August 1, 2004; 25(2): 66 - 66. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||








